A debate On The article Posted

*Dakoo_Minzy* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
On the recently posted article of CityBhasker,Bhopal,my view on it,and lets have a debate on it too😳

They are telling We cannot have imaginary Historical stories running on TV,since they are kalpanaic and not real.

To say more precisely,in today's world people are getting more interested to history rather than present modern soaps.

Why is it that happening?They need to be thinkin of this question rather than asking for restrictions on these soaps.

When this topic came to my mind my first thought was of all saas bahu serials that are running on TV.

You take Prerna of KZK,how many times has she got married??Howw many kids has she got??Howw manyy grand kids??Even her grandkids are married,but still u find her to be just like any other non grey lady,even younger than them.

Leave this,get to Baa of KSBKT,she is somewhat over 150 in age keeping in view of how many leaps have happened.

Come to KNK,there we see new Kundali thing be introduced which tells Kanav will have relation with another aldy other than his wife,and that relation will be more valuable.

Come to Komolika,how many times has she been sent over to Jail,but still evrytime she comes back yet too young and full of energy

Om of KGGK,there whose funeral service we all witnesed,he is back again.

When Cezanne quitted,there came plastic surgery for him.Smriti quitted,and tere too came plastic surgery.

In all saas bahu soaps,we cant even identify who is whose daughter and whose mom.Itz all really complicated there.

Once one gets married to a person,and gets 2,3 kids there,then that person dies,so he/she gets maried to another,then the dead person comes baack,so tere goes the story.

The same story seems to repeat on and again,and people who seem to be fools,they keep on viewing it(tat includes me too).For this there is no restriction.That is even though whatever they are showing is out of world and totally imaginary,no1 seems to mind.

Marrying 10 to 20 persons and having diffrnt kinds of kids,no1 has problem for tat.

All familes has gt negative members,which can no doubt affect the peaceful nature of families.

And above all mny Misunderstndings which i can say with stress could hve affected many a less family peace.

And exchange of kids,Tanu of KGGK,she was exchanged for Pranay.This act is it good to be shown on tv?Wont atleast one child feel insecurity of his/her a parent??


All these ahs no problems,
No problems meanign absolutly no problms,
Why?????
Coz,people think ti makes sence,and media seems to worssip the quitting and coming of actors

While coming to Soaps like DharamVeer,it is imaginary,But all its story is based on past.Its an historical base story.

Any one with a brain can understand that whatever that is shown on Historical soaps have happened at past.It is not related to present tings.

In face DV and soaps like this make people get patriotic.

Infact,take Dv frndship,seeing that evem we feel like having a good bond with our frnds,and take two best frnds on Saas bahu,both will fall for the same guy,and after that the frndhip has no value.

Even if historical shows shows somethings that hasnt happend,isnt it good for the present generation to hv an idea on what cud hv happened in earlier days.How the king kingdom times where.

Its no doubt,these days saas bahu serials are getting lower TRP's and other shows are gaining in.
Younger generation are comletly ngnoring saas bahu soaps.

Do u think,
The histircal stories which doesnt have any superstitial beliefs but makes us get more aptriotic and goes into the deepness of society is more better than the saas bahu soaps running on TV,which is nothing but fully superstition filled,


Did i say a big baashan??😆Gosh tat is what happens wen my patience is been cheked and i get angry,i hv stopped only coz tere is some more revisions to be made😆



Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

725

Users

8

Frequent Posters

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
hhmm can't remember any movie or tele serial which is has a connection with reality. actually we viewers dont wanna watch reality. we want fiction . it gives the writers freedom to innovate and it gives viewers something different frm their own lives..we all know what's happening around us don't we? our lives r routine.. boring..while in dreams and fiction we can visualize a diff. world. but yes fiction must not go too far..in DV it's acceptable but rajkumar aryan and jai maa durga,lucky, hatim i find a bit weird..
ImmaculateDream thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Good topic minoo .. i just posted an article with the same subject ...

i agree with luv_khwaish .. fictional serials shouldnt go too far ...abt .saas bahu soaps it is so boring to sit n watch the same concept, story, with similar tracks being repeated again n again ... with no susbatance at all .... if they are called to be real then its not fair .. they are faaaaaaar from reality ... a person dies is bound to cum back in a kitchen soap ......

whereas historical serials are better if they are fictional .. real historical serials can raise fingers, no matter how much research is done ... the best recent example is Jodha akbar ..


lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
beautifully written minzy... longest post i have read in a while and definitely your longest one i suppose... but dont worry it is pretty apparent that this article went in because they were running out of article content (needed to go to press) and needed a trash filler or with motives like negative publicity etc in mind.. because of it people like us who dont even know that a paper called dainik bhasker existed now know about it...
i dont think we need to worry about it at all.. cos it doesnt voice opinions of the general public...

basically the person who wrote it has not come across terms like ingenious, innovative, inventive, artistic, imaginative etc...

hence lets just forgive them for their ignorance... even the person who wrote it knows what the K galore or most reality shows have to offer.. koi justification ki zaroorat hi nahin hai 😊
215629 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
I need to ask the writer of this article what sense he can make from the present reality shows and crap serials revolving around absolutely nothing!The only conclusion I can reach is that guy was so confused between choosing among the bad so he made pleasant dramas like DV 'bali ka bakra' 😕 How beautiful is it to have a soap based on the diminishing values like faith,friendship,kinship and love 😳 and how still more relevant is it to have such kinds of concepts in the contemporary world! Can anyone come across such heart-touching scenes and dialouges in those lavishingly setted serials which only concentrates on getting enviuos,feeling jealousy and pulling others out of their way to relaise their meaningles goals?

Poonamjayaswal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: luv_khwaish

hhmm can't remember any movie or tele serial which is has a connection with reality. actually we viewers dont wanna watch reality. we want fiction . it gives the writers freedom to innovate and it gives viewers something different frm their own lives..we all know what's happening around us don't we? our lives r routine.. boring..while in dreams and fiction we can visualize a diff. world. but yes fiction must not go too far..in DV it's acceptable but rajkumar aryan and jai maa durga,lucky, hatim i find a bit weird..

no but i love rajkumar aryan and jai maa durga,lucky, hatim,DV!!!!!!!!!!!!!They are 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% good than these nonsense daily soaps!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I just hate these DAILY SOAPS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😡

shimmer thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: lashy

beautifully written minzy... longest post i have read in a while and definitely your longest one i suppose... but dont worry it is pretty apparent that this article went in because they were running out of article content (needed to go to press) and needed a trash filler or with motives like negative publicity etc in mind.. because of it people like us who dont even know that a paper called dainik bhasker existed now know about it...
i dont think we need to worry about it at all.. cos it doesnt voice opinions of the general public...

basically the person who wrote it has not come across terms like ingenious, innovative, inventive, artistic, imaginative etc...

hence lets just forgive them for their ignorance... even the person who wrote it knows what the K galore or most reality shows have to offer.. koi justification ki zaroorat hi nahin hai 😊

you are write di.....inko jawaab de bhi to kya dein.....sab kuchh saaf saaf sabke saamne hai...i feel like a stupid talking against them........everytime they cme up with these unlogical articles....and minnoo you're right even if teh historical shows aren't real they are the closest to reality........unlike ekta or other shows.........i agree they show a lot of masala but its for entertainment....and to entertain yourself you need sth. different with a bit masala......otherwise everything would seem so obvious and straightforward.....but not anythin like these saa-bahu sagas.......i never watch them now.......these people still were able to take our time see......😆😆😆

*Dakoo_Minzy* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: luv_khwaish

hhmm can't remember any movie or tele serial which is has a connection with reality. actually we viewers dont wanna watch reality. we want fiction . it gives the writers freedom to innovate and it gives viewers something different frm their own lives..we all know what's happening around us don't we? our lives r routine.. boring..while in dreams and fiction we can visualize a diff. world. but yes fiction must not go too far..in DV it's acceptable but rajkumar aryan and jai maa durga,lucky, hatim i find a bit weird..


yes,luky i do find it a wierd,coz tere r some lewdness kind f things tere,bhoot wooth,teyy try to make us bliv tey r existin...😆
yup,we know we r livin in a world,all of us have the control to our life,so all these articles r jus absurd nonsence
*Dakoo_Minzy* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sarajee123

Good topic minoo .. i just posted an article with the same subject ...

i agree with luv_khwaish .. fictional serials shouldnt go too far ...abt .saas bahu soaps it is so boring to sit n watch the same concept, story, with similar tracks being repeated again n again ... with no susbatance at all .... if they are called to be real then its not fair .. they are faaaaaaar from reality ... a person dies is bound to cum back in a kitchen soap ......

whereas historical serials are better if they are fictional .. real historical serials can raise fingers, no matter how much research is done ... the best recent example is Jodha akbar ..



Thnxx Sarajee😳yes.....serilas shudnt go far!!....yes,tere r people to raise hands on each n evry subject!!!!let it be for good or wrong no one bother's..but some are alwas born to retaliate....
*Dakoo_Minzy* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: lashy

beautifully written minzy... longest post i have read in a while and definitely your longest one i suppose... but dont worry it is pretty apparent that this article went in because they were running out of article content (needed to go to press) and needed a trash filler or with motives like negative publicity etc in mind.. because of it people like us who dont even know that a paper called dainik bhasker existed now know about it...
i dont think we need to worry about it at all.. cos it doesnt voice opinions of the general public...

basically the person who wrote it has not come across terms like ingenious, innovative, inventive, artistic, imaginative etc...

hence lets just forgive them for their ignorance... even the person who wrote it knows what the K galore or most reality shows have to offer.. koi justification ki zaroorat hi nahin hai 😊


yes,Lashooo 🤗
yes..letss forgive thm for their ignornace..bechaara people...koi aur kaam nahi hena isliye karin...😆😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".