PRC v/s Veer Debate: Judges Thread!!

Page

Next Last

Jwalamukhi

@-Jwalamukhi-

Stunner

+ 9

Posted: 17 years ago

Yes friends, we formally declare the debate contest over with this thread and I must say im impressed by all the participants..👏

It is now time for the judges to give thier verdict in.. The development team members will be asked to come here and judge other then the ones who took part and give thier verdict and points to the teams, and who they think should be the winning team, best debators( 2 debators) 2 from PRC team and 2 from Veer team, and 1 runner up debator from each team.

The teams were as follows:

Prithvi Raj Chauhan:

Poonamjayaswal
ektay11
Innocent Ishita
inderjit cute
generator
Girl_2007
Priti_24

Akanya:

Subha2601
starpisces123
xoxcuddlesxox
thronewood9
rajatnmughda4ev
Heaven princess
anusha_123

Link to Debate Contest Thread:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/dharam-veer/1027622/debate-prcains-v-s-veerains-closed

The topic for the debate was:

"Rajat Tokas suited which role better? Veer or Prithvi Raj Chauhan?"

Our judges are:

Nibbles

Dramaholic

NadiaIqbal

Diyafah

The judgment and marks should be given alongside with the comments to tell participants why they got the respective marks and things to be kept in mind while judging was the examples given by team members, the different points, reasoning, and fight backs. At the same time marks could be deducted for going off-topic, giving back unreasonable answers, getting personal and attacking members etc.

The judges will be here soon with thier respective judging.

Judges PLEASE discuss what you want to ALL here but please PM me the results/winners/debators/runner-ups...THANKS.

Veer -PRC Debate Team

Edited by *Shifali* - 17 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

kiran

@crazy_kiran

Sparkler

Posted: 17 years ago

oh shifu this is a lovely thread, i wld really like to see how the judges decide the winner, coz i am still confused 😆as both the sides were brilliant👏

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Minz aka Minnie

@*Dakoo_Minzy*

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 17 years ago

Shifuuu Brilliant!!!!... Wow!!! kyaa idea!!.....😃

I lovvvv the judges who are cumin along....wishhh them All the Bestt!!!...🤗 n to all debatords who participated.....All the Beryyyy Besshhtttttt😃 Both DV Debate Team and PRC Debate Team did Reallyyyy well.....😳👏 if i hvv to select one....i will be *confused...*😆

Edited by *Dakoo_Minzy* - 17 years ago

Quote

Dipa

@Sharon_235

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

I cannot really wait to see the winners name.

They both played sooooooooo well😊

Quote

_Angie_

@_Angie_

Rocker

Posted: 17 years ago

wow, double bonanza shifu , Thanx dear 🤗 🤗 first we get a wunderful debate & now this 😛

two jabardast threads 👏

Quote

mehraan

@mehraan

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 17 years ago

thanx shifali 4 the lovely thread!both the teams were superb,i really enjoyed it,wata class debators v hve in the forum!!every1 execptionally gud!loved it n really waitg 4 the results!

Quote

Anusha

@anusha_123

Inactive

Posted: 17 years ago

When the Results will be announced

Shifu di??????😊

Quote

@-dramaholic-

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 17 years ago

Helloo To Both Teams!=)

Its an Honour to be Doing this and i'm very great ful to be a judge!!=)

Well i'm sure all my fellow judges will agree, that these things take time.. So let me go read all the debating and then i'll come to a conslusion. Let the Best Debater Win.

Edited by dramaholic - 17 years ago

Quote

@-dramaholic-

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 17 years ago

Before i PM any Results I will Jot Down What i felt with each reply by contestants.

PRCians

Poonamjayaswal - Nicely mentioned about the onscreen love between Veer Shera & Prithvi, Sanyogita. However this does not say how rajat is better in either role since you are talking about the charecters. Again the histroy side of it is very useful since you are presenting facts.

ektay11 - NO PARTIPATION SEEN!

Innocent Ishita - Nice Points as to Rajat had a greater responsibity potraying the role of Prithvi since he was handed over the thorne at a young age. I like the way you have included that veer only relised his responbity after he realised he was a shamik.

inderjit cute - NO PARTIPATION SEEN!

generator - I think you have briefed most of the commen reasons out. Ajmer was mostly noticed from the Serial PRC. Rajat did live up to it as we have all seen, Sagar arts always kept extending his role because he was doing so well. You are correct that becuase of rajat PRC was more noticed and influanced in the younger generation. Although i think it would be better to include a few more points to make your arugement stronger. Also i think you have used good use of histroy of PRC and how PRC was so brave at a young age of 11.

Nice Use of Awards facts. This truely supports your arugement.
I like the point of Veer's charecter was mostly popular since Rajat was first PRC.

Girl_2007 - You have backed up your arugment very well and have defended yourself from every point thrown across to your team. Very well written arugment and good use of proofs that you've used!! You have clearly outnumberd the points made by veer's team and have opposed them with your views which puts your side stronger.

priti_24 - You have given a very detailed view on Prithvi and most of it is correct. you are right that prithvi was a very powerful charecter which came out because of rajat and maybe people could forget veer but never prithvi. Very good arugment presented. You have listed all the main points. keep it up. Also looking at your other posts it seems you are very good at backing up your argument. you've used really good facts which we all know.

VEERians

subha2601 - You have covered most points in which you have stated that Rajat did get to explore more roles as Veer rather than what he could do in PRC. Prithviraj Chauhan was a very predicuable charecter since sagar had to follow what was wirtten in histroy, but i like the way you have defended how veer has more emotions to contribute to rajat's career/role. The part about more events shown about prc wern't real is a strong arugment you hold.

starpisces123 - I like the way you have expressed your views on how DV has given rajat a new turn in carrer. I feel that you have potrayed your debate correctly & the opinions given are not biased. Although it would be better if you would concentrate on More of Veer's charecter than on Dharam's. Overall A Nice Perceptive over last few pages.

xoxcuddlesxox - NO PARTIPATION SEEN!

thornewood9 - Very Useful facts are used but you have moslty used the historical facts of both serials.The debate topic was what role RAJAT Suits..PRC or Veer?. Well i liked reading your histrorical side of the charecters, and i do beleive you added much of how Rajat Suited Veer's role better. Overall i think you added a very good speech/debate and was very formal. I liked the part where you mentioned that Veer's charecter conveys more emotion in terms to compare with Prithviraj..but i still feel if you could elibrate on your points. On other page replies:

Very Good Defending on your own points and debating on others points.
It is correct that veer did face a lot of problems since of the shamik side of view to the serial
Formality is the best policy in debates and you have done it with such great prespective. All points mentioned where clear and you have your ideas to back them up.
Concluding your debate is always neeeded to summarise your take. Well done.=)

rajatnmughda4ev - Well Done!! you have nicely split up the pro's and con's. that was fantastic. Rajat was a child artist while doing PRC but now as veer he is considered more mature. I like the facts you applyed to your arugment . It is true that NDTV Imagine yet does not hold its own award ceromany so that was a con. but well written and very detailed prepestive.

heaven princess - You have backed up thonewood's points postivly, but it doesn't show me more your views. You ned to clear out your own views in your own post rather than just agreeing with a team mate. You have started to give some good points so keep it up. You have also mentioned in a diffrent post of yours "Veer thinks of his family first, Wheras Prithvi though of his people first".. Is this backing your argument..?

anusha_123 - So far i think you have cut all the main points and have been short and snappy. You've included all the main defence arugements and i liked the way you described how rajat's acting skills have grown and maturned for DV.

_______________________

A nice effort from both teams, sad too see that there were a few who let you down.

2 from PRCians Team

and 1 from VEERians Team..