What does this win of Modi depict?

IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Gujarat verdict: Moditva overshadows Hindutva

SAFFRON BANDWAGON: Narendra Modi played the development and Hindutva card on and off.

victory for the BJP in Gujarat, its 'Hindutva laboratory', the credit for which mainly goes to Narendra Modi.

Attacks and "sabotage" came from both within the party and political rivals for the Chief Minister, who was the BJP's face in the crucial elections in the communally-sensitive state.

The victory will give a boost to Modi's stature within the BJP, considering that he single-handedly powered the party to victory, relegating the top leadership to the backseat during the high-voltage and bitter campaigning.

As results showed, the rebels did not pose much of a threat to the BJP in Saurashtra though the party lost some ground in Central Gujarat, hit badly by the post-Godhra riots in 2002.

The Assembly election was virtually a battle between Modi and anti-Modi forces, which even the 57-year-old former RSS pracharak's hardcore detractors would admit.

The Congress, which was desperate to wrest power from the BJP in the state after 12 years, focussed its entire campaign on attacking Modi, clearly indicating that he was the challenge that the party had to overcome.

Despite his being attacked for his role in the riots, the BJP consciously decided to project Modi as the 'Man for Gujarat', seeing him as a perfect foil for an emotive 'Jeetega Gujarat' (Gujarat will win) campaign.

Modi set the agenda for the tightly-fought race right from the beginning, whether it is his emphasis on development initially or the clever use of Hindutva later.

Modi initially concentrated on development and later capitalised on Congress President Sonia Gandhi's "merchants of death" remarks to rake up the Hindutva plank. Right from the selection of candidates to identification of campaign issues, he left his imprint firmly on the party's election strategy.

He made a daring decision to deny tickets to as many as 50 sitting legislators and field around 100 new faces to overcome the local-level anti-incumbency. Initially, Modi spoke only about the development of the state and the welfare of five crore Gujaratis and struck a chord with the masses with his pet theme of Gujrati asmita (Gujarati pride).

He refrained from publicly talking about Hindutva in the election campaign, but subtly reminded people of the Godhra train fire through newspaper advertisements.

The twist in campaigning came after Gandhi's controversial 'Maut ke Saudaagar' remarks about Modi, which shifted the thrust of the campaign to emotive issues like communal riots and terrorism.

Adding to it was Congress leader Digvijay Singh's 'Hindu terrorist" remarks which Modi utilised to the hilt to arouse passions in the communally-polarised state.

Modi countered Congress by referring to the sensitive terrorism issue and referred to the killing of Sohrabuddin Sheikh, which was seen by political adversaries as justifying the fake encounter.

While Team BJP romped home victorious in Gujarat, the claimant for the man of the match crown is surely Modi, who began his political career as a RSS pracharak and went on to become a General Secretary in the BJP.

The BJP left no stone unturned to woo voters. It carpet- bombed its entire leadership, including L K Advani and Rajnath Singh, but what remain etched in everyone's mind is Modi's rouble-rousing speeches and his mask.

He travelled the length and breadth of the state and addressed campaign rallies in all the 182 constituencies, gauged the mood of the people and played the development and Hindutva card on and off.

*************************************

Hi all!

People in Indian and around the world were eagerly waiting for the election results of Gujarat elections....NARENDRA MODI was the TARGET OR POINT OF FOCUS...

    Does this election depict the basic thing that common people are bothered about DEVELOPMENT rather than fancy election promises and religion ?
    Did BJP contribute more than Congress to India's development? Did India shine more in BJP's rule than Congress?
    Will the gujarat election take back BJP to Hindutva ?
  1. Should BJP shun its Hindutva and focus on development lil bit more to make a comeback in National level?

Cheers,

Myth

Edited by mythili_Kiran - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.3k

Users

6

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

SolidSnake thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

    Does this election depict the basic thing that common people are bothered about DEVELOPMENT rather than fancy election promises and religion? It shows that CM (common man😆) has voted for development, security and strong leadership.
    Did BJP contribute more than Congress to India's development? Did India shine more in BJP's rule than Congress? No, the basic foundation of the modern India was laid down by the Congress (but then they were in power in majority of years). But these days it has become a Gandhi (read Nehru) family Pvt Ltd. There is no internal democracy in the party and it considers its birth right to rule India. Congress has always been given a free pass by media and intellectuals. Emergency, Licence Raj, 1962 debacle, 1948's J&K Fiasco, legetimisation of curruption, vyakti-pooja, parivaar-waad, slow pace of development, Punjab problem, NE problem, J&K terrorism, poverty, illiteracy, hunger, health care etc...Congress had a golden opportunity at the onset of Independence, it had the trust of people, it had the leaders I believe to do wonders...but they failed in ultimate analysis despite all success stories (green/white revolution). Adopting Socialism (read Marxism) was a mistake IMO. Development ke maamle mein bahut der ke baad hum jaage zaroor lekin jo nuksaan hona tha woh to ho gayaa. I remember reading somewhere that people of India were unfortunately given personal freedom before economic freedom whereas it should have been other way around or atleast both together. BJP (read NDA) has had only once chance at governance and they did fairly good IMO as first timers.
    Will the gujarat election take back BJP to Hindutva? What do you mean by Hindutva? If you mean back to Ram Mandir days, I personally think NO. BJP has evolved as a party with time.
  1. Should BJP shun its Hindutva and focus on development lil bit more to make a comeback in National level? BJP has always been focussed on development as any other party. As NDA they fought on development agenda but lost.

It would help if our "secular" media was a bit neutral in reporting. Their Modi hate is amazing and laughable to watch. They seem to be in a world of their own, and are losing credibility slowly.

Cheers,

Myth

sareg thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

Gujarat verdict: Moditva overshadows Hindutva

Hi all!

People in Indian and around the world were eagerly waiting for the election results of Gujarat elections....NARENDRA MODI was the TARGET OR POINT OF FOCUS...

    Does this election depict the basic thing that common people are bothered about DEVELOPMENT rather than fancy election promises and religion ? It is always a combination, the fact that he was in power and fought the anti-incumbency without relying as much on the hindutva plank was amazing
    Did BJP contribute more than Congress to India's development? Did India shine more in BJP's rule than Congress? 5 years of BJP vs 55 years of Congress, if you take the # of acheivements made in the 5 vs the 55, the scales are tilted in favour of BJP rule
    Will the gujarat election take back BJP to Hindutva ? Read the headlines of the article you quoted😉
  1. Should BJP shun its Hindutva and focus on development lil bit more to make a comeback in National level? You mean embrace "Moditva nationwide" we might have to open massive asylums for secularists😆

Cheers,

Bottom's up

(always will be a)Myth

-Believe- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

Gujarat verdict: Moditva overshadows Hindutva

Hi all!

People in Indian and around the world were eagerly waiting for the election results of Gujarat elections....NARENDRA MODI was the TARGET OR POINT OF FOCUS...

    Does this election depict the basic thing that common people are bothered about DEVELOPMENT rather than fancy election promises and religion ?All Parties like, the same wine in different bottle 😳
    Did BJP contribute more than Congress to India's development? Did India shine more in BJP's rule than Congress?I dont think BJP contributed more than congress,Rajiv Gandhi period india's development starts actuly i think so...😊
    Will the gujarat election take back BJP to Hindutva ? I wonder in Gujj More than 2,3 crore Voters are religious!!!?? 😳or uneducated ??!!!😳...I cant believe all are religious there...😊
  1. Should BJP shun its Hindutva and focus on development lil bit more to make a comeback in National level? Forming a single party Govt its bit tuff in india present situation.......so I dont think Hindutva movement works as they expecting. 😳

Cheers,....Just chill

Myth.............Vinus😊

Edited by Believe - 17 years ago
sowmyaa thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5


I totally agree with you Deepak. Also, what exactly we mean by Hindutva would be interesting to know. Also, giving "equal" rights to all community is also Hindutva to me. 😉 And like the title of this article say... "moditva overshadows hindutav" 😳
Edited by sowmyaa - 17 years ago
Yeah thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
I don't think I can answer those questions....but I am disgusteddddddddd! If i'm not wrong...he led the slaughter of many muslims rite....I mean why on earth would the Gujus elect a slaughterer lol...

ewwwwwwwwwwww is my only verdict 🤢
IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Thanks for replying Deepak

IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Agree....that moditva is not universal (India wide) principle but ..does'nt the win of modi depict..that people are bothered more more about development thant religion...riots and all....may be we the people out of gujarat have an unnecessary evil picture of modi...because of media😊

IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sowmyaa



I totally agree with you Deepak. Also, what exactly we mean by Hindutva would be interesting to know. Also, giving "equal" rights to all community is also Hindutva to me. 😉 And like the title of this article say... "moditva overshadows hindutav" 😳

😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".