CID losing it way?

anilmerani thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Guys i am a freelance entertainment journalist, i also occasionally contribute to tellybuzz as well. Off late i have felt that CID is losing it way. Many of the storiesdont tie up in the end. Even the special episode where Mahesh Manjrekar was the the bad guys.There were too many loose ends. i am not sure if they even explained how the team got away from the bad guy;s in the penultimate/ last episode.

I want to do a story on the same and would like your feedback Pls PM me.

Thanks
Anil Merani
Mumbai

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

1.2k

Users

5

Likes

8

Frequent Posters

EstelleEvenstar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Well I hate to say this but Yes, CID has lost its way 😭
Just watch the episodes of early 2010 and thn the episodes of June to Present, you can see the difference, ever since Sachin and Kajal joined the team CID's graph has come to a very low point, some of the episode doesnt even had a SCRIPT.
Negative Points: ( June to Present)
>> No Story lines
>> tooo many loose ends
>> Abhi-Daya Disappearing Acts
>> ACP's crazy behaviour (he has started to shout ALOT)
>> Stupid Episode Endings
>> TOO MUCH SACHIN
>> No Abhi-tareeka track
>> No Vivek-Freddy scenes
>> Serious Freddy
>> That stupid 'Piano' wala dialogue

one of the major disappointment was Akhri Chinuti's Last episode, the way they ended it was Pathetic. The Creatives ruined a great story in th end.

well Seriously If they dont have time to keep the great Rep of CID, End it, why on earth are they trying to ruin GLory of 12 years???? Instead I ( and in this case i think majority CID'ians would agree) Would LOVE to watch CID classics, Again and Again ❤️

(err *Edited* I am not blaming Sachin and kajal for everything 😆 I just dont like Sachin at all, No Offence to Sachin-Kajal fans. Kajal is OK tho. I think i'll just blame FW for all the negative points 😕 Or Creatives. I donno whose fault it is TBH, I just cant see a Downfall of CID, and i HOPE they sort it out and We get Old charm of our CID BACK)
Edited by angelbuffy - 15 years ago
dr.fahmi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
@angle Agred with every point u mentioned except one. I m glad that abhi-tarika tract has ended. No offences😊
Suneel_kumar thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
can anyone tell me.......if episodes r not gud...then y it is not loosing trps??😕
Shagnika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
EDIT : sorry for typo mistakes! Using cell, so.......

Therw haa been a steep downfall in the quality if the show this year, ever since bi weekly strted! Surely biweekly format gave them TRPS and as a result money but a far as the quality is concerned, it has gone from bad to worse.

I wont say that there have been no good episodes at all. There have been certain episodes which have created a lot of impact among the viewers and surely, they go into the list of some of the best episodes of the show. For example : this year we had, Khoon ki holi..... Khatra Chemical Bomb ka, Manali Muder, Deshdrohiyon ke viruddh CID, Kissa lodnapped Bachhe ka( quite a nice episode).... And some Ac parts like part 1, part 5 and part 7 and part 8 were good too with special mention of 8! Certain changes brought have been positive according to me and some others i suppose-- like, We wanted Abhi-Tarika track to end and it did! We wanted Feddy to be treated as a senior officer and so less of stupidy from him.... This track has seen fluctuations though.

Rest all varied between bad to average episodes. The consistency graph is nowhere to be seen! Story writers have been suffering a lot because of shetage of ideas i suppose. Certain points are repeated just too frequently! Casting has seen a downfall as well qith no surprises stored for us! Its become too predictable!

One major problem that CID faced afyer bi weekly was the team management which hampers the episode to a large extent! Disconnected scenes are surely a big loss to an episode!

Acp shouting all the time! He wasnt like this before! Where is our Acp Pradyuman? The super duper intelligent detective and a brilliant leader?

Daya's character too has seen a gradual downfall! The soft hearted Daya is now being promoted as a source of power only! His character has become more about depicting strength! How scary he has become! That piano dialogue is pathetic

Loose ends in the episodes, dragged direction and poor baclground score sometimes have all added to the negatives! The concept of 3 forensic docs is also so stupid to digest and as a result the lab scenes have become nonsensical at times...with "gobar analysis" for 15 minutes or so!

I dont want the show to get over. Its not possible to just live on the classics! How many time can we watch them? I want my fyture generations to know about the show qith positive feelings and i want them to agree with me that CID was the best and will be better soon! Its not that FW is not capable of giving us good episodes. There are many things which FW and Sony can do... But they gotto pay attention to our greivances first and take neccessary steps acordingly!

End the biweekly format as soon as possible and get rid of the extras! Give ebough prominence to TRIO ans treat Freddy with due respect! Viivek and Tasha should be given the needed footage too! If FW need story ideas, please organise contests via which we fans can reach to them with our stories legally! A proper well planned procedure is all we need! Sony needs to understand that CID is not just a 2 month all saas bahu show and accordibgly promote it with dignity! Promting other shows on CID should be stopped!

I have lots more to add! But for now, just this much is enough 😆
Edited by Shagnika - 15 years ago
EstelleEvenstar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: dr.fahmi

@angle Agred with every point u mentioned except one. I m glad that abhi-tarika tract has ended. No offences😊


No offence taken 😊
I know some ppl didnt like that track at all.
those abhi-tareeka moments always bring smile on my face, and i think They MUST get married 😆 I mean cmon he and Daya must have crossed 40+ 😛 The only CID officer who is married is Apney Freddy Sir 😎 oh and ACP sir is married too!

Why everyone always forget that Abhijeet wanted to start a married live long time ago, remember when he was planning to propose Shruti? And his Attachment to that lil Girl in 'Nanhi Gawah' was sooo very touching. So I dont think It would be a bad idea If he gets a family too.
Edited by angelbuffy - 15 years ago

Related Topics

CID thumbnail

Posted by: Minionite · 7 days ago

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/2025860918253703178

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/2025860918253703178
Expand ▼
CID thumbnail

Posted by: Minionite · 1 years ago

Opening TRP is out. 1.4 is pretty good. https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1872335699959263257

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/1872335699959263257
Expand ▼
CID thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima · 2 months ago

https://twitter.com/GossipsTv/status/2001169620565418322

https://twitter.com/GossipsTv/status/2001169620565418322
Expand ▼
CID thumbnail

Posted by: Chocolava5 · 2 months ago

The Finale Episode is here... Today we finally bid adieu to our favourite show and our favourite characters. 💔💔💔 (Pata nahi agla season...

Expand ▼
CID thumbnail

Posted by: SilverBell · 2 months ago

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/2001169620565418322?s=20

https://x.com/GossipsTv/status/2001169620565418322
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".