Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

4.1k

Users

30

Likes

189

Frequent Posters

Angie12 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#41
Radha, I like your theory and also am hoping that Radhika won't be the one to initiate this. Also if Dada has to die after hearing the truth about the childhood marriage, then it is better that Barkha is telling this to Dada rather than Dev. So if the society is mistaken about this because they see Barkha at the funeral, it is better.

Lets see what they show in next few days. But muhdikhayi could have been still cancelled even if Dada was sick. They don't have to cancel it because of death. That's why not sure where creatives are going with this storyline. I liked inclusion of Dada in this story because of interaction between Dev and Dada. No matter what, it is a fight between some conservative outlook (Dada's) versus a progressive outlook (Dev who would bring much needed changes). So it would have been much more interesting to see that clash rather than seeing Dev feeling guilty about his choices.
radha_bilahari thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: why6

Radha, I like your theory and also am hoping that Radhika won't be the one to initiate this. Also if Dada has to die after hearing the truth about the childhood marriage, then it is better that Barkha is telling this to Dada rather than Dev. So if the society is mistaken about this because they see Barkha at the funeral, it is better.


Lets see what they show in next few days. But muhdikhayi could have been still cancelled even if Dada was sick. They don't have to cancel it because of death. That's why not sure where creatives are going with this storyline. I liked inclusion of Dada in this story because of interaction between Dev and Dada. No matter what, it is a fight between some conservative outlook (Dada's) versus a progressive outlook (Dev who would bring much needed changes). So it would have been much more interesting to see that clash rather than seeing Dev feeling guilty about his choices.

Why6,
I would have also preferred a Dev-Dada confrontation. a fight between conservative and progressive thinking would have been the best. But to Dev's disadvantage is the fact that there are mulitple people to silence him and am sure Radhika would also come up with her "jane dijiye na" stuff. Dev would have been totally suffocated and he would neither be here nor there. He needs a break from all this, do an introsopection and address the issue.
Now Dev will take matters to hand and set things straight. If things happen the way I see, then both Barkha and Radhika's situations are the same where Radhika is considered to be the wife of Rohan and Barkha of Dev. this will make things easier for them to resolve issues and will also appeal to our logical senses.
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: radha_bilahari

Why6,

I would have also preferred a Dev-Dada confrontation. a fight between conservative and progressive thinking would have been the best. But to Dev's disadvantage is the fact that there are mulitple people to silence him and am sure Radhika would also come up with her "jane dijiye na" stuff. Dev would have been totally suffocated and he would neither be here nor there. He needs a break from all this, do an introspection and address the issue.
Now Dev will take matters to hand and set things straight. If things happen the way I see, then both Barkha and Radhika's situations are the same where Radhika is considered to be the wife of Rohan and Barkha of Dev. this will make things easier for them to resolve issues and will also appeal to our logical senses.


Is it logical ? it will be more complicated situation and i do not think there will be any way out then when once you are projected as Rohan,s wife and other one as Dev,s wife ...So curious to see how this web will be weaved and then solved , action-packed drama ...
radha_bilahari thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#44
Neerja,
I dont know how this story is likely to move forward.
The logic part is in both the marriages there was no proof. Rohan-Radhika marriage was an asakshi vivaah, where at the end it was Rohan's word against Radhika's word. similarly in Dev's marriage the girl in the gunghat was not known, the society believed it is Barkha. Even in Rohan-Radhika marriage the society believes that the marriage is completed before the fire accident. For these beliefs someone has to dearly pay, the subject which can be addressed by Dev on resuming his duties at the healm. So the situations are similar in both the instances.
Who is paying for this? the lives of two girls are at stake and it is not fair to any of them.
Edited by radha_bilahari - 14 years ago
chipak thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#45
Thanks Chalhov for the info..it was interesting reading all the views but now DD death is gamechanger, i am having few issues circulating inside my tiny brain reading the whole discussion and needed to put it out:
1) Is DDg gonna die out of shock (of loosing in front of RaDev union) or guilt (that what he was calling adharm is nothing like that) from childhood marriage revelation..I prefer later that he realize his mistake and go peacefully.
2)If DDg is to die after listening truth then is he going to ask Rads this last favor to keep it secret and sacrifice for his honor/name or is it inadvertent presumption by Society during funeral that Brakha is CB (provided no Moohdikhai ceremony) and then Rads herself deciding to not reveal the truth and ask barkha to keep on the act. Personally i would hate first option that is DDg even after knowing that RadEv are always meant to be together, that there is no sin committed with their marriage that its destiny that they get married again sud still think of making the same mistake and die with this burden (that is if he feels a single ounce of guilt). But the second option of Rads herself deciding to keep on the act is even more worse than the first one. I dont want rads character to be made as second Rp who is not concerned about others(Dev here) but only the name in society...that wud be destroying Rads charcate. DDg asking her to sacrifice is one thing and she herself deciding to give up another unimaginable thing from rads (But she already proclaimed that for her DDg/his image is more imp than her marriage with Dev so i am dreading here that its not another RP in making
3) Before dying is he going to ask Dev marry Barkha (like he did with his son)..that wud be suicidal i know but i am dreading that this might happen. It can go this way that its Rp last wish and Rads (full of guilt from her own side) convince Dev to to do coz the way Brakha claiming to be Dev's outside wife is only possible if she is married to him else why wud a girl agree to ruin her own life pretending to be false wife of someone else agrred that she is under gulit or for her frd she is doing..but how long can she can act thsi way without being married to Dev...Dont want Cvs to make her Saint out of this and thats why thinking she may be Devs second wife
4)I think killing RPs character is either to make whole story more complex/interesting or is easy way out for makers. Cvs can use his death as one big fish to keep many ends open in the story..a) Childhood marriage secret gone with him and brakha might not tell anyone else coz of fear of what happened with this truth (or Rads asking her not to) b) None will come to know if after listening the truth DDg actually agreed for Radev (that is if dies instantly and not able to communicate his last wish or repentance to Radev) c) I dont know if Khashi Maharaj foretelling related to CB is known to anyone else but think everyone knows Khasi maharj told RP that his smallest GS will be nxt RP. So in that case Dev will be RP but noone will be aware of what importance rads hold for this family..and in that case it will be rads doing all good for family but PB thinking its Barkha..more suffering for rads.. d)keeping reason for DDg death as secret and making Brakha feel guilty for it thsi agreeing to act as fake wife (may be lateron she starts thinking herself as real wife..chances are less but Cvs can go this way) e) with DDg gone all of Dev's support is also taken away (Padma yet to be seen her loyalty once Rohan comes back) and with no DDg (possible regretting his actions if is kept alive in story) there will be more problems for rads and Dev...

In anycase i do not want DDg to go so soon without realizing his mistakes and without repenting his actions (for Devs parent and now most probably for Dev) and in case Rads also supporting DDg (or acting on her own) will be big let down for me. I wish rads to consider Devs pov once before agreeing/deciding on anything. Atleast she shud be aware how Dev must have felt knowing (though his turmoil for his childhood and mother not shown) knowing how his past was ruined by his DDgs one decision (for which he claims to be regretful) and how once again Rads is ready to rob off Dev from his future with her one sided decision..i dont want this all this to happen without Devs consent or Rads misguided beliefs...

Do not know what happened to day but eagerly waiting for updates..😕

Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#46
DD death will leave explosive situation in the house , Interesting track if give logic to the track for the action ...Curious to know how this web of guilt imbibes and sucks all three of them in it and how Dev will entangle it with Radhika,s support or Barkha,s ...Rohan Babu has also entered ...Whatever iis better than saas -bahu nautanki

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".