Shall I go ahead with the rules? READ Page 8 :) - Page 6

Thanks Angelic for your response. I am all hopeful for the password system for the CC still hehe. I concur with Aditi (mjhtac) on this. As Sanu (Sweet_Misery) referred these rules I believe should apply to MN and SG CCs only if they are creating a mess here to be honest as it isn't fair to others but if the application is done not too harshly then it is fine to be applied to all.

it's actually fair if this rule is applied only to SG n MN CCs or any other such particular fan grp CCs...i didn't check out sanu's post earlier

n also sanu has a point, if they dont care for personal warnings, why would they bother abt CC warning, like many ppl already mentioned, IO CCs are generally like-minded/taste ppl n many dont bother abt what the rest of the ppl say...even if u lock a CC for a day, i dont think there will b any change.....but ya, may b u can give a trail.....we can't give up b4 trying

Originally posted by: Angelic_J

@ Aditi - Hi (:

This is NOT the final set of rules guys. This is exactly WHY I made this topic. I want input from everyone so we can all come to terms with what we all think is FAIR and JUST to everyone who is part of CC. Yes we gell well with people who share the same set of values as us but that does not mean I can go around bashing people as much as I want. At the end of the day this is a public website that does have its own set of rules that need to be followed by its members. Please do share what EXACTLY you think seems unfair/unjust from these new rules and I will worj with you guys to tweak that (:

Hey Jot..im glad youre hearing us out before chalking out a final set of rules.I understand that as a moderator you have to take into consideration people's feelings quite a lot.what I would suggest for you to step in and intervene is when:

1)there's security risk to any particular member-as we are familiar with some incident in the past when a member's personal details have been leaked due to vengeful act of someone on this forum

2)i agree with the bolded part of your post.specific bashing of a particular member on a CC shouldnt be allowed.not few days back some DMG member was bashed,albeit on some other site,but its still bashing.an IFs member can be accountable for that.you should definitely raise W/Ls on that CC/close it for a while if that happens.but then,i suggest you should wait for the posts to be reported as well.sometimes members simply indulge in verbal duel without reporting each others CCs.id let them do that and not interfere.
then again i dont include mocking as bashing,but that is just my perception.I-Fs has a completely different perception on humor

3)the second suggestion is not just for general comments like "XYZ's fangroups are so retarded"...if you have to close CCs for that,you would have a load of extra work on your hand ,believe me.my suggestion is,if a CC is known for its dislike quotient for a particular fangroup,they should stop visiting it.but stalkers, as we know are hopeless,so we give out an open invitation to each and every stalker to stalk and memorize each and every post on our CC,however,they cant quote us anywhere,or report us for not liking their favorite couple,however,i dont mind stalkers hitting the like button on our posts,friendly stalkers are always welcome.

4)since this post was made keeping in mind the SG vs MN eternal war,i would like to say,we have our full right to like/hate a particular character/couple.i should be given freedom to call an actor constipated or single expressioned if i want.the actor's fans have their full right to drool mindlessly over him/her.we dont stalk their CCs.they should leave us alone as well.high time.
Eg:i like Ranbir Kapoor quite a lot.in fact am absolutely gaga over him.but i wouldnt care if another CC calls him wimpy voiced/snobbish.its their opinion,they are not starting a discussion with me on him,why should i report them?

@ Senny - But see we were going to come up with a new system anyways but thanks to MN vs SG we just did it a bit sooner. Plus I don't believe in discrimination so either the rules apply to all or none. It isn't fair to seperate SG/MN fans from the rest of the fans (:

Angelic, yeah deep down I felt too. But its just like one child is creating trouble, then you reprimand and possibly punish that one and not all the children. Man I being in the legal field talk like this. Well there are a lot of things which are not spared from discrimination here as I have observed and thus felt that may be here when someone is not at fault shouldn't be punished.

But I am all hopeful that this new system would be welcoming and comforting!

Well said Aditi!

Can we get a password protected CC?

Coming right back to the stalkers reporting topic that I'm obsessed with..

If within a CC members have a difference of opinion then yes, they can be reported (though its highly unlikely cos they are supposedly like minded individuals and would sort it out (hopefully) among themselves , but if it goes to name calling and insults then the report button may be used.

Originally posted by: myownarea

Coming right back to the stalkers reporting topic that I'm obsessed with..

If within a CC members have a difference of opinion then yes, they can be reported (though its highly unlikely cos they are supposedly like minded individuals and would sort it out (hopefully) among themselves , but if it goes to name calling and insults then the report button may be used.

But if the members are busy bashing a certain person who is not a part of the CC, then stalkers are acting like proxy moderators and doing the job of reporting the post ..etc

My suggestion is that IF the members of a CC are bashing a actor/character - then they should be allowed to, because Stalkers have absolutely no business in getting hurt and reporting.