Why SANJU is compared to SALMAN & Not Aamir-SRK Films? - Page 5

Originally posted by: Pehchaan.Kaun

EVery good thing is generally compared to the best. I take offense when the standard of the good thing goes down to Ranbir kaka. But never mind, Hirani is a brand. 🥳 Of course he will be compared to the best out there of the game i.e. Salman.

Originally posted by: Piyatrix

Entire country is raving about Ranbir's performance yet this member has no idea about acting or performance 😆 kya kare Sallu fan jo hai ..waise Hirani only works with actors who knows how to "act" he'll never work with non actors 😆

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

Chahe kuch bhi ho jaaye everything eventually boils down to BO and SRK v Salman, Salman v Aamir, Hirani v Aamir, RK v RS etc etc etc. Who cares about script, acting, writing etc. We will only focus on star power and box office and make everything about a single individual. A hit or flop is never about a single person. Am sure we realise it yet it's convenient to ignore this fact in fan wars 😆

Originally posted by: DevilsKick

With this logic, Hirani hasn't worked with any star except Sanjay Dutt, Aamir & Ranbir, so every other star is non-actor including Srk, Hrithik, Irrfan, Nawazzuddin =)) LMAO =)) 🤣

Originally posted by: DevilsKick

Roger ji I would have talked about film SANJU, but eventually I would have been accused of various things, so better to talk things which ppl understand.

But as a RK Fan, I am still waiting for Jordan Ranbir to be back on Screen, Rockstar is only film which deserved Success big time, once Ranbir realize it, there will be no stopping.

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

I disliked Rockstar though. I personally thought Sanju was a better film (poor Hirani shouldn't be compared with someone like Imtiaz 😆) but that's just my opinion. Anyway my point is that a film is never about a single individual. Race 3 did not do well because it was a bad film. Bad cast, terrible director, bad album and a lazy Salman. Salman deserves flak for interfering in every single aspect of the film and making a mess of it but it doesn't really mean he has suddenly lost his star power. BB is Salman's biggest hit in recent times because it had everything Race 3 lacked. Feel good story, good cast, good music etc. Ditto with say a 3 Idiots or CE or now Sanju. The films were entertaining and the cast delivered. An ATBB or a BB is a combination of so many factors. But then we make it about a single person and argue endlessly about star power and BO clout. That was my only point :)

Originally posted by: Piyatrix

Hirani is not 80 he has a long career ahead he'll surely work with all the actors u have mentioned 😆