Hence Proved... - Page 2

No they are not. Mainly SRK is done. Salman is hit and miss. But Aamir is and will remain relevant for a long long time.

Its about the script which Race had but Race 3 didn't.

Well Kick was a huge hit too with the same Jacky. And I actually thought they had decent chemistry in Kick. Race 3 being bad is not just the female lead or the cast. It's a combination of several factors. Salman (or any actor for that matter) is no Aamir. You interfere beyond a point and decide everything, things are bound to go wrong. And Remo is an extremely mediocre director. If that's not enough, Salman inserts a sub standard cast into the film. That's too much pressure on his stardom 😆 I hope Salman learnt his lesson. I thought he did after Jai Ho and esp after BB became a huge hit but probably not. The biggest reason why Aamir delivers the highest grosses is simply because he does good or at least decent films. SRK on the other hand has horrible script sense and Salman seems to take his stardom for granted and thinks he can make anything and anybody work. I actually hope all this is a lesson to these actors. Let the director do his work. Don't interfere in the casting and get someone to read your scripts if you are bad at it.

Filmmaking is and always has been a collaborative effort. Now if you get overconfident and believe you can do everything from casting to writing to singing to acting rather than leaving those things to the professionals, then well this is what happens.

For Tubelight , he said it was different and launde lapades didnt watch it . I wonder what he has to say abt this one

Well Kick was a huge hit too with the same Jacky. And I actually thought they had decent chemistry in Kick. Race 3 being bad is not just the female lead or the cast. It's a combination of several factors. Salman (or any actor for that matter) is no Aamir. You interfere beyond a point and decide everything, things are bound to go wrong. And Remo is an extremely mediocre director. If that's not enough, Salman inserts a sub standard cast into the film. That's too much pressure on his stardom 😆 I hope Salman learnt his lesson. I thought he did after Jai Ho and esp after BB became a huge hit but probably not. The biggest reason why Aamir delivers the highest grosses is simply because he does good or at least decent films. SRK on the other hand has horrible script sense and Salman seems to take his stardom for granted and thinks he can make anything and anybody work. I actually hope all this is a lesson to these actors. Let the director do his work. Don't interfere in the casting and get someone to read your scripts if you are bad at it.

I think the days are gone when movies like Kick work . Salman isnt fit like before and guys like Tiger is rising among his core audience. The last movie which worked only cos of him was PRDP , even that couldnt match BB,Sultan or TZH. I think his golden run is over and he is going the SRK way unless he starts doing actual good movies