Who did a better job in the respective biopics?

Page

Next Last

Poll

Who was a better performer?

JaaniDushman

@JaaniDushman

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

Since it's the reason of polls- here is mine 😆 Who aced their character given to them? I'm not saying which is the better film- but which person fill in more to the shoes of the character? Or was convincing - PC as Mary Kom or Sonam as Neerja?

Quote

Frequent Posters

Mallika-E-Bhais

@Mallika-E-Bhais

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

Are you serious.

PC.

Obviously.

Sonam was good & looked freakishly like Neerja, but PC being the wonderful actor that she is, beat Sonam with both hands tied to her back, effortlessly. Her skill set way much above & beyond anything a Sonam can produce, in such that a woman who looks nothing like a short Manipuri lady, makes you believe she is Mary Kom!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

923901

Suspended

Posted: 9 years ago

Sonam lived up to the expectations (as it was low)

PC somehow didn't deliver as expected from her in Mary Kom

Quote

JaaniDushman

@JaaniDushman

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Mallika-E-Bhais
Are you serious.

PC.

Obviously.

Sonam was good & looked freakishly like Neerja, but PC being the wonderful actor that she is, beat Sonam with both hands tied to her back, effortlessly. Her skill set way much above & beyond anything a Sonam can produce, in such that a woman who looks nothing like a short Manipuri lady, makes you believe she is Mary Kom!

These are polls biopic war poll it is! 😆

@bold- YAAAS I agree! - PC's dialouge delivery in MK is enough to eat up Sonam's Neerja IMO

Neerja was overall a better movie, but PC was better in getting the nuances without any bias whatsoever. I didn't like MK as a movie so much, but I LOVED PC's perfomance in it! The accent, how she looked so young during the start, the boxing sequences done so well, and the chemistry with the guy and her coach! ❤️ Sonam has of course bettered her perfomances better from before, but it was inconsistent!

Quote

JaaniDushman

@JaaniDushman

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: SunSaathiya
Sonam lived up to the expectations (as it was low)

PC somehow didn't deliver as expected from her in Mary Kom

IMO MK the movie didn't deliver in terms of expectations, PC got the nuances perfectly for me! I thought the screenplay let her down, there was no gripping moments in the story it was very flat!

While the screenplay elevated Sonam's perfomance! It was such a well written movie, and yes of course Sonam did a pretty decent job too!

Quote

jibber-jabber

@jibber-jabber

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

PC for Mary Kom > Sonam in Neerja

Neerja was a better made film IMO.

Quote

Jiyagulabi_26

@Jiyagulabi_26

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

That's a shame that you compare ram mdhvani's sweat and work with that ok who loved to ruin biopics. Forget pc acting what snoozefest omung made then one blunder wasn't enough he made sarabjit

Quote

566912

Hibernated

Posted: 9 years ago

PC was good. But Mary Kom's director was total letdown. Movie was all over the place. See what he did with Sarbjit. No one should give him another biopic to ruin.

Whereas Sonam was ok but Madhvani lifted the whole movie up. And direction puts Neerja above Mary Kom as a whole movie. To the general audience Movie > individual performance.

Undoubtedly PC worked her ass off for Mary Kom. Her dialogues n body language was spot on. Wish the director was someone else.

Voted for PC.

Quote

566912

Hibernated

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: gulabi22
That's a shame that you compare ram mdhvani's sweat and work with that ok who loved to ruin biopics. Forget pc acting what snoozefest omung made then one blunder wasn't enough he made sarabjit

She is not comparing movies or director.

She is comparing individual performances.

So there is nothing shameful.

Quote

JaaniDushman

@JaaniDushman

Voyager

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: gulabi22
That's a shame that you compare ram mdhvani's sweat and work with that ok who loved to ruin biopics. Forget pc acting what snoozefest omung made then one blunder wasn't enough he made sarabjit

Erm it's clearly written that the poll is about the perfomance of the actor than the movie!

Edited by Patronus - 9 years ago