Should Bollywood give second chance to Shiney? - Page 11

Its so amusing to see how the topics get derailed in the BS...What is the need to drag in the other criminals/culprits???Are the people who are doing it trying to implicate that since so and so got away with it, we need to accommodate EVERY criminal and look the other way???I don't think this is what they want...Then what is the need to derailing the topic with unnecessary comparisons???Why can't we look at the things objectively??


(yes, whoever tries to evade the law is equal to the scum of the earth..no two ways about it...but we should reserve that discussion for another thread...)

Originally posted by: PCRocks

I agree with you i mean look at Salman who killed innocent people and still got away with it and top of that whole bollywood supported him...I am not supporting Shiney but it's just that i don't agree with the system

The topic is hardly about the system...Its about your individual opinion and all you had to do was whether you are willing to give another chance to this rapist...And incidentally, you are also the one who can decide whether YOU want to give another chance to the law abusers like Salman...Its the people who have forgiven Salman and are flocking to his movies and so the industry too is playing along...If the people didn't watch his movies, I want to know which film maker would be willing to make movies with Salman or whoever it was...

Originally posted by: ladygaga

I just described what happened with him.. i am no one to judge if he did commit the crime, or if he didn't commit the crime or if he deseves anyone's sympathy, or he deserved the humiliation.. or what not.

Why do you act like a judge Sanam ji?? Your facts are facts.. but anyone else's perception is total bulshit in your eyes.. and that is what i call being presumtuous.. there are a lot of people who think he didn't commit the crime.. and there are a lot of people who don't equate his crime to shiney's crime... so why are you out there to ridicule their opinion... Their opinon is as valid as your opinion.

Again your assumptions about people that they don't regard common man's life... i would beg to differ.. everyone makes their own judgements.. and everyone's perception is differnt.. that does not mean that you can label all those people as hypocrites.

Originally posted by: Nuktaacheen

@ bold... not everyone's... and not the words, i would use...! 😛😛 i don't see situations in the same light...!

and i already stated my reasons... some actions are just NOT justified... if you are going to justify something wrong, then be prepared for counter arguments as well...! 😉😛😛

it's a FACT that most fans can't think that their favourites are capable of any wrongdoing... it's not an opinion, so really, i don't need much to prove it anyways...! 😛😛

people can think that both crimes are not the same in their eyes... but when they give a free pass to one, and not to the other, that is hypocrisy... no matter, how you present the case...!

calling me presumptuous or judgemental isn't going to prove your point...! 😛😛 i've already given the definition of hypocrisy... i don't need to relay it again... if you can prove it otherwise, please feel free to do so...! 😉

Originally posted by: ladygaga

Again your turning this thing into a fan war... bringing in unecessary comparison... calling people who might not look at two cases in a same way hypocrites is not acceptable by me.. that is where i see an issue.. but its obvious you are in no mood to give the opposing party the chance to share their opinion without giving them unecessary labels.. so it is of you use to continue this discussion.

What I don't understand is that people get all worked up when I blame Salman for his crime, saying that "he was framed/his driver did it" and justifications (for which.. btw... Salman hasn't thanked you for yet)

Neither Shiney nor Salman or any other person who commits a crime whould be left without being punished.

Originally posted by: Nuktaacheen

don't think sogazelle meant it for 'you', though he/she did quote you... it was more of a general comment...! 😛😛 people are writing shiney off on one hand, yet on the other hand, singing praises and 'going off easy' (i believe is the term) on someone else, because they flaunt their charitable deeds...! 😛😛

Thank you for summing it out for me... That was exactly my point... I just got frustrated by some people thinking that some other heinous crimes should be excusable just because those who committed them have more power.

Originally posted by: liverach

It's sad how this all turns out...

a superstar kills someone by being drunk and whatnot, and is now touted as the "best action star of Bollywood" (I beg to disagree. but that doesn't even need to be said LOL)

oh and simply for the sake of stirring the pot and stating the obvious, I'm talking about Salman Khan, the murderer.

and when Shiney is the sinner, everyone gets their moral brigade and out and is like "oh nonono we can't bring back a SINNER!"

fail.

THANK YOU. i COULD NOT HAVE SAID IT BETTER!!

Originally posted by: liverach

What I don't understand is that people get all worked up when I blame Salman for his crime, saying that "he was framed/his driver did it" and justifications (for which.. btw... Salman hasn't thanked you for yet)

so why do people consider it so HEINOUS when one suggests that maybe Shiney was framed too?

can't it happen? If it can happen with King Salman, why can't it happen with Shiney?

THANK YOU!!! That was exactly my point!!! It's not that I was defending SHINEY, but I was just flabbergasted by the way some members were finding all sort of ridiculous excuses for someone whose reckless behavior a death ensued... and being so inflexible towards SHINEY... I mean if that's not BIAS, then I don't know what the word means then... but really... It's mind blowing the extent to which people will try to defend their favorite star just because he makes them feel good in front of the TV!! That's not reality people!... Reality is what happens when he's not entertaining us and who he really is .. It's about time we start separating the two, and take that veil off our eyes... because I think we are the ones who look ridiculous.