Agree or Disagree and why?(GAME)

-CmPunk123- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
The game is something like:
I will be ranking all the contestants from best to worst according to me.
I will also post the reasons of why I like or dislike them and how can they be in my like list in the future.
If you agree with me,post in affirmative but if you disagree with me what you have to do is chose any one of my ranked contestant and post why you disagree with that one. KEEP IN MIND YOU CAN ONLY CHOSE ONE CONTESTANT AND ARGUE!

For e.g If I say I dislike 'x' and 'y' for different reasons and even though you disagree with me on both you can only chose one of the two and argue why I am wrong!

Let's see how different our opinions are here.

My contestant list would be something like:

1. Mandana Karimi.

Why Like: I have always disliked her this season for her obnoxious behavior but lately I have started to like her. She is not as bad as people try to portray her here and in the house. She is a different person with different opinions but no one seems to respect that. If she speaks up for herself,she is annoying and if she doesn't,she has become boring. Unnecessary hatred for her on this forum has made me like her and now I am full on supporting her. She has her own shortcomings,everyone have,but only hers are tested inside the house.
Why dislike: Not Applicable.
How can she redeem herself: Not applicable.
Rate out of 10: 9

2. Keith Sequiera.

Why Like: He is smart and very calm. These are two qualities I have always admired. He speaks very well. He doesn't jump into fights for no reason. He tries to calm situations. However, the biggest reason for me to support him is the unnecessary hate he is getting on here. This guy is the most criticized here. Whatever he does or says is censured and beaten to death.
Why Dislike: Not Applicable.
How can he redeem himself: Not Applicable
Rate out of 10: 8.5

3. Rishab Sinha.

Why Like: I find him entertaining. Even his fights have element of fun and masti in them. He is also very clear about his stance. He is smart and thinks very logically. I like him for these reasons.
Why Dislike: One thing I dislike about him is how he hasn't gone against Kishwer so far. Makes me feel he is scared of her.
How can he redeem himself: Confront Kishwer about the spitting incident how he confronted Rochelle by nominating her and bringing it up later.
Rate out of 10: 8

4. Rochelle.

Why Like: She is very smart and intelligent.
Why Dislike: She changes sides way too often. She can also be very annoying at times.
How can she redeem herself: Staying away from Prince,not getting into unnecessary arguments and stop getting insecure of WCs.
Rate out of 10: 7.

5 and 6. Priya and Kamalweet.

Haven't watched enough of these two write anything about them.

7. Suyyash.

Why Like: He is sensible and sensitive. He is also caring. He is very good when Kishwer and Prince arent around.
Why Dislike: Very weak in tasks. Despite playing cricket for 10 years he has no team work ethics. Makes a fool of himself in front of Salman. Has enunciation problems. On the wrong side of the fence.
How can he redeem himself: Doing better in tasks. Stop listening to Prince's ideas. Stop trusting Prince. Stop shouting when angry. Speak in a way that is at least understandable. Be a fun person. I see him depressed always.
Rate out of 10: 6.

8. Kishwer.

Why Like: She is opinionated and straightforward.
Why dislike: Very stubborn. Never listens to others. Loud mouth. Annoying. Illogical and not smart. Dominating. Wants to rule only. Excessively opinionated. Bad dressing sense.
How can she redeem herself: Listening to others' viewpoint. Subside her loud nature. Give others a chance to speak up(dont be dominating). Stop targeting ManD!
Rate out of 10: 5.95

Prince.

Why Like: Not applicable.
Why Dislike: Arrogant. Ghamandi. Pugnacious. Dumb. Follower. Subordinate. Not task master as he said in his introduction. MCP. Annoying. Ugly. Paltimar. Ghatiya.
How can he redeem himself: Not applicable.
Rate out of 10: 0.

I am not doing this for Digangana as she is hardly ever seen.!

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

857

Users

7

Likes

28

Frequent Posters

Ponga.Pandit2 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
That's exactly what I feel...Mandana is not that bad...she is definitely not fake...and you got all right in your post.
Rithu0203 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Agree w.r.to Mandana. She is one who mostly misunderstood one inside and outside the house.
One reason is her language barrier, not able to explain/argue freely with others and finally she ends up in single abusing words, which makes her look bad.

For me, Mandana is one who believes less in physical strength and more in mental strength and plays mind game and tries to play individually that's what i liked about her.

Really she stood out from others with her small idea to stole the coins to win the task. Clearly she is different from others and more over few HMs are insecure of her and tries to put down her.

I wish she stays strong and plays strong.
-AAMIRnSHERRY- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
Agreed with almost everything said!!!
sanayabarunlove thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
I'll agree with a few things. But Mandana has proven to be nasty and outright dumb in certain situations. The first was when she played the Hotel game and treated everyone 'according' to the task. And when Rochelle bitched about her so she could get nominated by Mandana to be safe, as a part of a task, she lost her plot. She argued with Rochelle for no reason whatsoever. I'm not supporting Rochelle, just explaining how Mandana can play double standards like a pro.
There were instances where she called the housemates stupid, foolosh etc. She called Rochelle an idiot, she called Prince. f***ing moron, she keeps calling people names. It's like according to her she's the only smart person in the house. her overconfidence overwhelmes me to a great extent. she's very unreasonable and illogical most times. Yesterday she was downright nasty when she compared the importance of her stuff and Kawal's stuff. She called his stuff materialistic and her own emotional and whatnot. Seriously, the girl lacks serious manners and she really needs to understand at some point!
-CmPunk123- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
@Fawadlove
I would appreciate if you could pick one of the contestants and tell why you disagree :)

@SBlove
You're right but at least she says on face unlike many others who plot behind backs. Plus lately she has been getting a lot flak for nothing.
sanayabarunlove thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: -CmPunk123-

@Fawadlove

I would appreciate if you could pick one of the contestants and tell why you disagree :)

@SBlove
You're right but at least she says on face unlike many others who plot behind backs. Plus lately she has been getting a lot flak for nothing.


Well it's not always commendable to be straightforward. especially when you cease to make sense whatsoever every single time. But I respect your call.
Kwerky thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
That's an interesting post.
I agree with you on nearly everything about all contestants. However, I have a slight disagreement over Rishabh. He is definitely entertaining but I think he lacks clarity as far as the game is concerned.

He fought with Prince so much in one week...but went on and nominated Rochelle and Kanwaljeet. I can understand Rochelle..but why Kanwaljeet..when he entered the house just 2-3 days back? Beats me...was there no one else in the house? What happened to all the tiffs displayed with Prince or Kishwer - were they just for screen time? If Rochelle is guilty of spitting in his eyes (and she wasn't even involved in that)...then why let Kishwer off the hook?

He came in saying that he dislikes Kishwer but he is yet to go after her. Rather he picks on Mandana unnecessarily now.

He sided with Mandana when he came in..dropped her like a hot potato when Priya came in. He is after Mandana over petty issues for the last two weeks now..behaving like a jilted lover. First one to get out in the last two tasks. So for me...he is moving from neutral to dislike if he doesn't mend his ways soon...as he appears clueless to me. Not very good, very good. 😆

Edit: completely agree with the reasons for dislike you have used for Prince and Kishwer...couldn't have said it any better.
Edited by Kwerky - 9 years ago
-CmPunk123- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Kwerky

That's an interesting post.

I agree with you on nearly everything about all contestants. However, I have a slight disagreement over Rishabh. He is definitely entertaining but I think he lacks clarity as far as the game is concerned.

He fought with Prince so much in one week...but went on and nominated Rochelle and Kanwaljeet. I can understand Rochelle..but why Kanwaljeet..when he entered the house just 2-3 days back? Beats me...was there no one else in the house? What happened to all the tiffs displayed with Prince or Kishwer - were they just for screen time? If Rochelle is guilty of spitting in his eyes (and she wasn't even involved in that)...then why let Kishwer off the hook?

He came in saying that he dislikes Kishwer but he is yet to go after her. Rather he picks on Mandana unnecessarily now.

He sided with Mandana when he came in..dropped her like a hot potato when Priya came in. He is after Mandana over petty issues for the last two weeks now..behaving like a jilted lover. First one to get out in the last two tasks. So for me...he is moving from neutral to dislike if he doesn't mend his ways soon...as he appears clueless to me. Not very good, very good. 😆

Edit: completely agree with the reasons for dislike you have used for Prince and Kishwer...couldn't have said it any better.


I do agree he still hasn't gone after Kishwer for the spitting incident.
Makes me feel he is basically intimidated of her.

MuguetDScorpion thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: -CmPunk123-



1. Mandana Karimi.

Why Like: I have always disliked her this season for her obnoxious behavior but lately I have started to like her. She is not as bad as people try to portray her here and in the house. She is a different person with different opinions but no one seems to respect that. If she speaks up for herself,she is annoying and if she doesn't,she has become boring. Unnecessary hatred for her on this forum has made me like her and now I am full on supporting her. She has her own shortcomings,everyone have,but only hers are tested inside the house.
Why dislike: Not Applicable.
How can she redeem herself: Not applicable.
Rate out of 10: 9

I used to like her because she seemed right to me. Yes she was arrogant and she went against her own well wishers but at least whenever she stood up she stood up for the right things. This is not the case anymore. Most of the time I see her arguing for the wrong things. She thinks she is always right and that's why doesn't understand anyone's POV. 😕 So from 10/10 she went to 5/10. 😕

2. Keith Sequiera.

Why Like: He is smart and very calm. These are two qualities I have always admired. He speaks very well. He doesn't jump into fights for no reason. He tries to calm situations. However, the biggest reason for me to support him is the unnecessary hate he is getting on here. This guy is the most criticized here. Whatever he does or says is censured and beaten to death.
Why Dislike: Not Applicable.
How can he redeem himself: Not Applicable
Rate out of 10: 8.5

He was one of my favorites. Very calm, smart and nice to everyone. But then he went on his joru ka ghulam mode and I don't like a few things about him now. From 9/10 he is at 7/10.

3. Rishab Sinha.

Why Like: I find him entertaining. Even his fights have element of fun and masti in them. He is also very clear about his stance. He is smart and thinks very logically. I like him for these reasons.
Why Dislike: One thing I dislike about him is how he hasn't gone against Kishwer so far. Makes me feel he is scared of her.
How can he redeem himself: Confront Kishwer about the spitting incident how he confronted Rochelle by nominating her and bringing it up later.
Rate out of 10: 8

He was my most fav when he entered. Then he became boring. Now he is back again. Though I don't like when he overdoes things and sometimes goes wrong too but I think currectly he is the best in the house. From 10/10 to 8/10 and currently 9/10.

4. Rochelle.

Why Like: She is very smart and intelligent.
Why Dislike: She changes sides way too often. She can also be very annoying at times.
How can she redeem herself: Staying away from Prince,not getting into unnecessary arguments and stop getting insecure of WCs.
Rate out of 10: 7.

She was forever an irritating girl but at least she used to take the right stands. Now she is most of the time delisional. From 8/10 to 4/10.

5 and 6. Priya and Kamalweet.

Priya is sometimes right sometimes wrong. So I will give her a 6/10.
Uncle ji I liked him a lot but recently he was seen nowhere. He gets a 7/10 from me.


Haven't watched enough of these two write anything about them.

7. Suyyash.

Why Like: He is sensible and sensitive. He is also caring. He is very good when Kishwer and Prince arent around.
Why Dislike: Very weak in tasks. Despite playing cricket for 10 years he has no team work ethics. Makes a fool of himself in front of Salman. Has enunciation problems. On the wrong side of the fence.
How can he redeem himself: Doing better in tasks. Stop listening to Prince's ideas. Stop trusting Prince. Stop shouting when angry. Speak in a way that is at least understandable. Be a fun person. I see him depressed always.
Rate out of 10: 6.

I disliked him till I guess week 5 or 6. He was like a real gunda and went wrong in everything. All he did was fighting because of GF. Now he looks a little better. From 2/10 to 6/10 now.

8. Kishwer.

Why Like: She is opinionated and straightforward.
Why dislike: Very stubborn. Never listens to others. Loud mouth. Annoying. Illogical and not smart. Dominating. Wants to rule only. Excessively opinionated. Bad dressing sense.
How can she redeem herself: Listening to others' viewpoint. Subside her loud nature. Give others a chance to speak up(dont be dominating). Stop targeting ManD!
Rate out of 10: 5.95

Same as Suyyash. She sounds better now. From 0/10 to 6/10.

Prince.

Why Like: Not applicable.
Why Dislike: Arrogant. Ghamandi. Pugnacious. Dumb. Follower. Subordinate. Not task master as he said in his introduction. MCP. Annoying. Ugly. Paltimar. Ghatiya.
How can he redeem himself: Not applicable.
Rate out of 10: 0.

Disliked him and still dislike him. 1/10 till now.

I am not doing this for Digangana as she is hardly ever seen.!
Digangana sounds nice but she is invisible in the house. 5/10

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".