IMPORTANT -PEEP IN -REGARDING PLAGIARISED WORK - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

2.5k

Users

11

Likes

79

Frequent Posters

Cieli.Santi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Plagiarised! Being a writer I know how bad it feel to have your works copied out, without permission.

Harshu 15 stories! Are not 2 or 3. Just by translating Hindi dialogues into English is called a Plagiarism. Its not right towards the original writers.

If you had taken permission about copying the work you should have mention it in the story with small note, but in this 15 stories not even in one i saw that.

You should first apapologise to the original writers and then to your readers. And yeah you should take down the stories too

@Harshada thank you for being this to our notice, we appreciate your hardwork in finding proof and all other things.
auroradowney thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
I had my doubts. Now I am damn sure that you too like rizz faked your so called illness. Well having parents who are damn good doctors has its perks and i immediately knew something about ur illness was off. You faked every single thing. Guess what ? You just proved my doubts and megha didu's doubts right. And you are saying you got permission. Bullshit. First try to lie conveniently then try to fool us. First you say you have not taken permission from few who actually didn't reply. But now you say you haven't taken permission from 2 writers. Seriously, do we look that dumb to you. I can't believe. You just proved that you are guilty. And don't show us attitude. Because we too know damn well how to show attitude. Okay. Accept your disgusting deeds and apologies to everyone on this forum. And to those authors also. And ho sake to please writing or shall I say COPYING / STEALING others works, quit it. You don't have the talent of writing. It's just not in you. You know not everyone can write stories. It's a gift given by god, which unfortunately, god decided to not bless you with. I know it must be very hard for you to know the reality that God didn't bless you with the power of pen. But suck it up and don't disgust us. Okay.



And Harshada. Love you sweetie. I don't know how to thank you enough.
Edited by dblackrubyneer - 9 years ago
Dark-Beauty thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#13
Harshada yes she is our friends, that doesn't mean we are supporting her.
True friend never support wrong.
When you pm me, after verifying it I immediately pm her and demand an explanation and an apology
Though she post an apology but didn't explain fully.

She disappointed us big time.
She's our friend from longtime and it's really shocking for us.
She's repeatingly saying she took the permission, but still she should post a msg above the story letting us know it's not her work.
She did a big mistake.
I tried to talk to her but she is leaving the IF.
After what happened with rizz, she should have think before doing this.


But anyway thanks for letting us know and I truly appreciate your effort.
Aayat23 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Dark-Beauty

Harshada yes she is our friends, that doesn't mean we are supporting her.
True friend never support wrong.
When you pm me, after verifying it I immediately pm her and demand an explanation and an apology
Though she post an apology but didn't explain fully.

She disappointed us big time.
She's our friend from longtime and it's really shocking for us.
She's repeatingly saying she took the permission, but still she should post a msg above the story letting us know it's not her work.
She did a big mistake.
I tried to talk to her but she is leaving the IF.
After what happened with rizz, she should have think before doing this.


But anyway thanks for letting us know and I truly appreciate your effort.


Tia even she was my friend before this. But by posting incomplete apology and now by running she disappointed me big time.

That's the reason writers think before sharing their stories. After your demand she posted it. What if harshada never have found this? She like always have continued copying it and would have never admitted. This apology is not coming out because of guilt but because she has been caught.

I was not going to enter in this matter that's why I asked harshada to remove her post and let you people handle your friend. But the way people are taking harshada's stepping back as harshadas fault here I am supporting what's right.


I am not asking for punishing her as I am no one to ask And even don't feel that is needed but at the same time I can't bring myself to forgive her as she is not accepting her fault.
rosamale thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
I was not thinking to step into this matter. but i read a lot of comments and i read her apology also. i have come across these kind of posts before also. what question i have is, shouldn't we give her the benefit of doubt? you guys know about her more than i do, but i am still ready to give her benefit of doubt. May be she didnt realize that she was committing a grave mistake.
i have been in IF for nearly 5 years. and i still didn't know that taking same idea and changing the plot would come under plagiarism. if it is like that, aren't most of us already doing that, coz after all everyone is using the story of Arjun. just a thought.

I agree she was supposed to give due credits to the original author. that's clearly a mistake she had done, but she apologized for that. if she has blatantly defended herself telling that she has not done any wrong, then we can crucify her. when she already apologized, what else needs to be done? cant we see it as a mistake rather than thinking that it is a crime?
auroradowney thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
How can we say that she doesn't know what is plagiarism... and she didn't change plots... she copied them... word to word... how can we say she is innocent after we know she has copied 15-16 stories. .. I don't know about anyone else but for me the fact that she is innocent is impossible to digest... she is a criminal... and she deserves punishment... she is not good enough for our support... that isn't what we did in rizz's case although the cases are poles apart but still the common point is that they both ARE plagiarist... They are in no way INNOCENT... I never expected such kind of behaviour from the members of this forum... its really disappointing...
IAdoreYou thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
@ Rosamale

Do you know what actual matter is ?
She havent change any storyline or plot ...
She just translated dialogues from English to Hindi ...
she did copy entire works of others ..

My first question to you is ...
Have you checked the links I posted earlier?
If you would have checked then you would have not been asking this question...

And answer to you your earlier question ...I would have given her benefit of doubt if she would have apologised on her own and have told everyone complete truth. ..

Even I had stepped back letting her friends handle this matter ...but the way you people are reacting to this. ... I think there should be no law for plagiarism and plagiarism should be considered as only mistake instead of crime ...

And answer to your another question she wasn't able to defend herself. ...because I have posted proofs ...

Even after being on IF for nearly five years ...you don't know that copying another writer's works as it is with only changing character name and translating dialogues comes under plagiarism ?

Then I think I am at fault here ...

And about your last question that can't we see it as a mistake instead of crime ...then I would have let it go thinking it as her mistake if she would have accepted things completely but now instead of doing that she is running away ...

And for your kind information ...I am neither member of this forum nor I have interest in creating this mess ...

I did it thinking it as my responsibility as a reader.


rosamale thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: dblackrubyneer

How can we say that she doesn't know what is plagiarism... and she didn't change plots... she copied them... word to word... how can we say she is innocent after we know she has copied 15-16 stories. .. I don't know about anyone else but for me the fact that she is innocent is impossible to digest... she is a criminal... and she deserves punishment... she is not good enough for our support... that isn't what we did in rizz's case although the cases are poles apart but still the common point is that they both ARE plagiarist... They are in no way INNOCENT... I never expected such kind of behaviour from the members of this forum... its really disappointing...


I am sorry dear i cant say anything about Rizz's case because i dont know who she is.
auroradowney thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
Rose dii... sorry for snapping but harshu is at fault... she is playing the sympathy card... she is faking innocence... she is a plagiarist... she copied every damn word... she doesn't have the talent of writing... she is a criminal...
rosamale thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Alvapriya

@ Rosamale

Do you know what actual matter is ?
She havent change any storyline or plot ...
She just translated dialogues from English to Hindi ...
she did copy entire works of others ..

My first question to you is ...
Have you checked the links I posted earlier?
If you would have checked then you would have not been asking this question...

And answer to you your earlier question ...I would have given her benefit of doubt if she would have apologised on her own and have told everyone complete truth. ..

Even I had stepped back letting her friends handle this matter ...but the way you people are reacting to this. ... I think there should be no law for plagiarism and plagiarism should be considered as only mistake instead of crime ...

And answer to your another question she wasn't able to defend herself. ...because I have posted proofs ...

Even after being on IF for nearly five years ...you don't know that copying another writer's works as it is with only changing character name and translating dialogues comes under plagiarism ?

Then I think I am at fault here ...

And about your last question that can't we see it as a mistake instead of crime ...then I would have let it go thinking it as her mistake if she would have accepted things completely but now instead of doing that she is running away ...

And for your kind information ...I am neither member of this forum nor I have interest in creating this mess ...

I did it thinking it as my responsibility as a reader.



I have written stories and i had given permission when someone asks me whether they can copy that. they dont give me credit and i am fine with that coz atleast they got permission from me and they have changed the characters, plot and conversation to fit into their shows demands.

Regarding the links, yes i checked a few. and still i am saying all these things.

if a person dont know that he or she has committed a crime, then why would they go and apologize first? she realized that her mistake was grave and apologized once you pointed out. doesn't that count?

About her running away, this is virtual world where no one can see you face to face. if she feels that she is being cornered and there is no was anyone would believe her, why would she still stay back and getting humiliated again and again? No one would do that. they will try for sometime and if they feel no one is there for them, they will eventually quit. its not like we are in her real life right? we are a part of virtual life.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".