Do you think it was a fair statement

In the second round chuk chuk rukruk juhi said that noone was to hit the buzzer until all the 4 words came up. If you did you would be penalized even if the song was right and the reason given was that it has to be a level playing field.Do you think it was fair on her part to say that

I thought that explanation was so bogus..If someone was good and knew the song with 2 words then you should actually say sabhashi as with that limited clues they were still able to identify the song. If they song wrong yes then it was fair because this is how the rounds are played.This is the test of how well they can link but more IMPORTANTLY how quickly they can

As soon as you think you know the answer buzz in. This is not turn by turn round but for them to buzz in. If she is saying level playing field then in the dhun round how come she is not waiting for them to finish thedhun as that too means she is not t giving the same level playing field to all

hmmm.. I dont agree with u Priya.. bcos if they allow to sing even before the words r up.. then the players will hit the buzzer before hand and by that time all the four words r on screen. and obviously Juhi or anu cant take the words back or cant stop the screen.. so it will be unfair for other teams.. and according to me the current rule is totally justified...

Another thing i cannot understand is in the third round when east hit the buzzer and to their luck it was was IShq when they hit and the word was indeed ishq but it was the first salaam e ishq and not second 😳she did not let them sing and gave them -ve. why is she behaving so dumb..if they did sing from the wrong word then she should give them -ve thats so fair and square why make these new rules that really are not making sen se😕

Originally posted by: *Sunita*

hmmm.. I dont agree with u Priya.. bcos if they allow to sing even before the words r up.. then the players will hit the buzzer before hand and by that time all the four words r on screen. and obviously Juhi or anu cant take the words back or cant stop the screen.. so it will be unfair for other teams.. and according to me the current rule is totally justified...

ya i understand that but if some team jumps the gun then they will be penalized. its not like nothing is happening to them and its overlooked like mistake.And if indeed the words do pop up they need to have a mechanism where by they stop the chuk chuk .I can underget tstand your viewpoint that it is because the team who hits first may get the undue advantage that they get to see the other words and incase the song they were thinking was wrong they get to change it but lets be a little realistic here ...these are kids and i doubt they can change that quickly. just my opinion😳

well... see I think the same things happened in Risthon ki antakshari.. when soumya pressed the buzzzer just listening to one sur... and many people objected.. .. bcos tafter the buzzer was pressed..the dhun did not stop till Anu or juhi commands the MD's...so I think keeping the pat experiences they have made new rules.. atleast this way everyone will have equal opportunity.. rather than the game going to people who r superfast in pressing buzzers..

Originally posted by: priya.nair

ya i understand that but if some team jumps the gun then they will be penalized. its not like nothing is happening to them and its overlooked like mistake.And if indeed the words do pop up they need to have a mechanism where by they stop the chuk chuk .I can underget tstand your viewpoint that it is because the team who hits first may get the undue advantage that they get to see the other words and incase the song they were thinking was wrong they get to change it but lets be a little realistic here ...these are kids and i doubt they can change that quickly. just my opinion😳

I also agree with sunita on this.First of all if the players press the buzzer beforehand,they will be able to guess the song once the words appear.I don't think it is possible to stop the words as soon as the buzzer is pressed.
And I don't think we shld underestimate these kids,,they are very sharp and have a really good presence of mind.So if they realise that the song is wrong,they can and will change it immediately on seeing all 4 words.More importantly Juhi's expression is enough for them.Her expression will tell them that their song is wrong and they would,therefore change it.If you observe closely all kids(esp noticed Navin doing this) look continuously at Juhi's face while singing a song!!
And last but not the least,let us take a situation where there are 2 teams A and B.Let us say,A is leading B by 10 points or more in the beginning of round 'chhuk chhuk ruk ruk'.A team's motive is to continue to maintain its 10 points lead at the end of the round/increase its lead.....what would you do if u were a part of team A?I'll tell u wht I'd do.I'll press the buzzer for every clip as soon as the first word is shown.If i get it right,i get + 20.If not ,I only lose 10 marks.If the oppostion team were to get the answer right,they would get +20 for every right answer and make up the 10 marks lead in 1 answer.so my best bet is to deny them that opportunity.If i pressed the buzzer for all 6 answers,and let us say ..... if i get 2 out of 6 answers right(which any person would definitely get),i would still lose 40 marks (4*10) and gain 40 marks(2*20).So bingo.. at the end of the round by doing almost nothing except depriving my opponent of a chance i get to maintain my lead!
This kind of thing is possible in many other rounds too(esp fulll and final),but in this case since the words can't be stopped ,the team which presses the buzzer stands an almost 90% chance of getting the answer right. This kind of strategy can be played in full and final if a team has a minimum lead(around 70 marks)
and sorry,if this sounded like an essay..i have a tendency to write long posts!!!

Well said Anu..👏👏👏... Loved reading ur comments..and u have gone into so much details.. its amazing..😊

Originally posted by: rock&roll

I also agree with sunita on this.First of all if the players press the buzzer beforehand,they will be able to guess the song once the words appear.I don't think it is possible to stop the words as soon as the buzzer is pressed.
And I don't think we shld underestimate these kids,,they are very sharp and have a really good presence of mind.So if they realise that the song is wrong,they can and will change it immediately on seeing all 4 words.More importantly Juhi's expression is enough for them.Her expression will tell them that their song is wrong and they would,therefore change it.If you observe closely all kids(esp noticed Navin doing this) look continuously at Juhi's face while singing a song!!
And last but not the least,let us take a situation where there are 2 teams A and B.Let us say,A is leading B by 10 points or more in the beginning of round 'chhuk chhuk ruk ruk'.A team's motive is to continue to maintain its 10 points lead at the end of the round/increase its lead.....what would you do if u were a part of team A?I'll tell u wht I'd do.I'll press the buzzer for every clip as soon as the first word is shown.If i get it right,i get + 20.If not ,I only lose 10 marks.If the oppostion team were to get the answer right,they would get +20 for every right answer and make up the 10 marks lead in 1 answer.so my best bet is to deny them that opportunity.If i pressed the buzzer for all 6 answers,and let us say ..... if i get 2 out of 6 answers right(which any person would definitely get),i would still lose 40 marks (4*10) and gain 40 marks(2*20).So bingo.. at the end of the round by doing almost nothing except depriving my opponent of a chance i get to maintain my lead!
This kind of thing is possible in many other rounds too(esp fulll and final),but in this case since the words can't be stopped ,the team which presses the buzzer stands an almost 90% chance of getting the answer right. This kind of strategy can be played in full and final if a team has a minimum lead(around 70 marks)
and sorry,if this sounded like an essay..i have a tendency to write long posts!!!

thanx for ur nice words ,sunita