Judging the Judges… Amul Voice of India

Judging the Judges…

Well, our great judges or mentors, as they are sometimes called, have been grilling contestants of talent shows quite well. These shows, at times, are more dramatic than any of the saas-bahu sagas. In this list, we judge the judges of the 3 singing talent hunts that are good pastime on the weekends.

Amul Voice of India (Star Plus)

Alka Yagnik
Looks- 6/10
Performance and style-7/10
Singing- 9/10
She should win the title of the most kanjoos judge ever. Perhaps she compares the singing of the contestants with hers and that's why the best of the lot also get average marks.

Jatin-Lalit
Looks- 2/10
Performance and style-5/10
Singing- 6/10
This duo is quite dry on the show. They come in the 'all praises' category. Even if someone has sung really badly, they sugar coat their comments.

Aadesh Shrivastav
Looks- 4/10
Performance and style-6/10
Singing- 5/10
A good judge but he should definitely not give make over tips because he needs one urgently.

Abhijeet
Looks- 3/10
Performance and style-5/10
Singing- 9/10
His point scale is a little too generous with girls so the male contestants have to really bank on the other judges to give them marks.

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

*** Edited by viewbie to add link ***

source: indya.com

wonder how the reporter clubbed jatin-lalit and gave them a combined score for looks 😕😆 and why are they being rated on their "singing" when they are music directors... same for aadesh...