Is this show actually focussing on the issue.

ranjnanarang thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Guys I have been watching Antra for a while now. And I think that off late this show has become more of Aditya- a great and bashed dad than a show about Antra.
I feel that instead of spening so much time on Aditya and Vidya's issues they need to look at the problem thay have based their show on.
The doc and his treatment looks quite abstract to me. The therapy sessions look very ramdom to me. The only issue they are addressing right now peoperly is the society's outcasting Antra.
I dont see the logic of Arti behaving like a spoiled child. Her not accpeting Antra is understandable but her acting like a dodo is not. I feel that if they are talking about a serious subject like this then they have to have some serious character line up.
Right now the show is basically focussing in Aditys being the doting and Ideal dad than Antra being autictic. They do need to show all this but the time they are spending on this is a bit too much.

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

687

Users

4

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

sasha722 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
hi ranju
wel i dont agree with u
the serial is going on a correct pace ( pov)
my pov its amiddle class family with limited income
& when u hve a special child in the family the expense on their treatment
their schooling there other expense become high
as adi is father & vidya is not her biological mother
so adi has do all d work
so the bond is with adi
vidya is softeeeeeee & her love adi is there
love is blind
as its a serial they hve to show all the shades of life
regarding her treatment even i felt its fast
i cannot write much as i am not aware of the facts
how they teach in these special school

as they r not slow learners as they r limited in conversation

so the difference arise automatically
regarding aarti what she has specialized in MBA she herself only will know
or she culd not get cleared in her first attempt ( HAhhhhhhhhhh)
she 222222 loud no softness in her
but i love her character
variation of character has been wel potrayed
Pl ranju put ur comments on it 2
i wait 2 hear from u


Bugger thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

hi ranjana .....wassup buddy! gud to see ur post here .....

ok back to teh post i agree wit sasha here .......i think the show is going at a gud pace!
they juss cant focus on antara , they hav to focus on oethr things as well .......like wat probs the parents and person close to her facing cuz of her!!
the show is not only bout her being autistic but also how the ppl around her cope up wit a child like this around!
i think they r presenting teh whole thing very well .......but ya the therapies they show looks a bit odd sumtimes but i think they wud hav researched on tht too .......the serial by the look of it appears well researched!
p.s - juss check on teh mrd forum its gonna get archived ...farewell bash is going on....so do post ur comments
skeptical thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ranjnanarang

Guys I have been watching Antra for a while now. And I think that off late this show has become more of Aditya- a great and bashed dad than a show about Antra. Since he is the caretaker, he is going to get more prominence. He is weak at times and thinks recklessly at times but he is evolving. His thoughts are going to decide Antara's future.

I feel that instead of spening so much time on Aditya and Vidya's issues they need to look at the problem thay have based their show on. Yes, the show has been unneccesarily cluttered up with their "masoom" story.
The doc and his treatment looks quite abstract to me. The therapy sessions look very ramdom to me. Rehab and initiation processes are always slow. Progress of the child depends on his individual capacity. Every exercise has a reaon. To explain in minute detail wouldn't be possible since the viewer would get fatigued and the serial would come through as a documentary. And then what about the TRPs? If they fell, the show would get axed. The only issue they are addressing right now peoperly is the society's outcasting Antra. I feel its very unrealistic. I can't believe that in such a big society noone takes up for the Vermas. Indian society especially the urban one is pretty exposed at least in the passing. But those loony ladies are absolutely ignorant. Nobody in the society says anything to them?
I dont see the logic of Arti behaving like a spoiled child. Her not accpeting Antra is understandable but her acting like a dodo is not. She is indeed bizarre. I feel that if they are talking about a serious subject like this then they have to have some serious character line up. True.
Right now the show is basically focussing in Aditys being the doting and Ideal dad than Antra being autictic. They do need to show all this but the time they are spending on this is a bit too much.

The family is a unit. Antara's entry has affected everyone even Abhi has started feeling the heat. They have to show their reactions to her condition. Unfortunately they are lingering too long on the parents because of that 'masoom" angle.
Eh ...... just my two cents worth........
ranjnanarang thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
Guys I agree with a few points and disagree with a few.
When I say that the therapy sessions look random to me I didnt mean that they seem to ba taking time. But they look a lot unreal and abrupt to me.
I agree with Skep here that the urban society is a lot tolerant and understanding then what is shown in the show. But skep there are nerds everywhere. I dont know somehow I am feeling that everything looks quite forced to me.
Just my POV.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".