I don't feel Tanya is wrong -- Yes, a lot of her actions are not justified, but she has gone through a whole lot in her life over these years. If my memory serves me correctly, Karan did meet her secretly with Bhoomi after Nandani was back in his life. If some guy did that for me, I would also assume I meant something in his life. If he can lie to the love of his life Nandani to go meet Tanya behind her back, Tanya has to mean something to him. Yeah, Tanya could have raised Bhoomi as Nandani's friend but what would have happened to her life? Does everyone expect her to never get married? Or she should have gotten married to someone else hoping they would let her raise Bhoomi? Would any other guy accept Tanya as his wife is she's busy raising someone else's child? Or was she supposed to devote her entire life in that house without ever starting a life of her own?
It is possible to fall in love with someone who doesn't love you back and that in no way is wrong. Nandani left Karan, Bhoomi, and her family after she saw Tanya and Bhoomi together. Yes, she sacrificed her happiness for Tanya and went away for twenty years or so. That's a long enough time for Tanya to be with a family which now she considers as her own. She raised Bhoomi, had a child with the man she loves, accepted everyone in that family as hers and spent loads of time in taking care of them. Then suddenly, Nandani comes back one day so isn't it justified that Tanya feels threatened?
Yes, Tanya said that she'll leave Karan once Nandani is back but Nandani came back claiming she's married so why should Tanya leave Karan? Nandani is always saying how she doesn't want to come in between Karan and Tanya but very conveniently, they both are caught in situations together all the time. If I wanted to stay away from someone's life, I wouldn't go to their house or keep any contact with them. Tanya reacts this way because on one hand she hears Nandani say she doesn't want anything to do with Karan anymore but on the other hand, Nandani and Karan are always together. Her feeling threatened and the fear that she might lose everything that she has is justified according to me.
I'm not saying Tanya is right or wrong, or that Karan is right or wrong, or that Nandani is right or wrong -- They are all victims of a very bad situation. If Nandani and Karan want to be together, then Nandani should stop making statements such as she doesn't want to come in between them, and if that is infact true, then she should avoid ALL situations that may pose as a problem for Tanya and Karan's marriage. If Karan does not want to be with Tanya, no one in this entire world can force him to, not Tanya, nor Nandani. You can't force someone to be with you or to love you, if they do, then they do and if they don't, then may never. Yes, it's hard but if he does not want to be with Tanya, he should just let her go. It may hurt her a lot now, but he'll save her a lot of misery that she's been going through. Time heals everything!
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
