Indian Idol 12

Indian Idol Judges Trolled For Ruining Kishore Kumar Songs

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1869

Users

9

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

mickymouse21 thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Neha himesh and Anu too

All 3 have ruined Kishore Kumar songs (ruined is a decent word for whatever they did)

Neha ne to hag diya yeh jawani hai diwani pe.. i felt like crying 

Anu malik should stick to his garam chay ki pyaali only 

All contestants sang much much better than these judges 

Edited by mickymouse21 - 2 years ago
SK2014 thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

No surprise. First thing sony tv should understand not everyone should sing songs by legends especially when the original singer is a legend like KK. And second mistake is 100 songs seriously how can anyone prepare themselves for so many songs in short time. So in an attempt to create record they forgot that everyone including judges need time to prepare. Kishore ji songs are not one of those singers can sing impromptu. That's why judges failed miserably. Contestants are better prepared so they were atleast sounding better.

But Twitterites are going too far in the trolls. It's not worth making a fuss out of everything happens on the show just because they have access to social media platforms. They need to learn to have some tolerance. Actually I feel judges and contestants should be appreciated for their efforts to entertain us in these tough situations. 

suresh555 thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

Honestly, sorry for being harsh, but when they take buffoons as judges, this will happen 

The three most besura singers judging a music talent show is crazy enough but them singing and getting more screen time than the contestants is totally lunatic 

Neha's voice is like an emergency siren, and her trying to add oomph to every number, further murders the song. And to add to the irritation, why is she lypsyncing and acting out to every song a contestant is singing. Her acting skills look disgusting.

Anu sounds like he is going through a root canal when singing 

Himesh is like a village idiot, he literally screams and dances to every song and on Sunday caused the maximum damage

This all happens at the cost of contestants not getting to perform enough and viewers being tortured to watch besuras act stupid 

Edited by suresh555 - 2 years ago
suresh555 thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

This content was originally posted by: SK2014

No surprise. First thing sony tv should understand not everyone should sing songs by legends especially when the original singer is a legend like KK. And second mistake is 100 songs seriously how can anyone prepare themselves for so many songs in short time. So in an attempt to create record they forgot that everyone including judges need time to prepare. Kishore ji songs are not one of those singers can sing impromptu. That's why judges failed miserably. Contestants are better prepared so they were atleast sounding better.

But Twitterites are going too far in the trolls. It's not worth making a fuss out of everything happens on the show just because they have access to social media platforms. They need to learn to have some tolerance. Actually I feel judges and contestants should be appreciated for their efforts to entertain us in these tough situations. 


It's not even a question of preparation, the judges seemed to be like playing antaskshri at a picnic table. Also, their voices are not cut out for such classic songs

Realityshow thumbnail
Visit Streak 750 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 0 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 2 years ago

This 100 songs of KK was a terrible idea. The way to have done it was to emulate what they did with Kumar Sanu 50 songs in Idol 10. That was a much liked episode.

Doing half rehearsed Kishore songs is worse than terrible. Thank god they did not try Manna, Mukesh or Rafi!

Kumar Sanu, Alka are good fits. 90's mostly had terrible movies and melodic songs and outright trash like Sarkai Lo Khatiya. No one complains if songs like those are poorly sung. 

mickymouse21 thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

Himesh's jumping and dance was too annoying.

Honestly i like Himesh as composer and singer too sometimes... He earned lot of respect by his work all these ott things doesn't look good on him.. sometimes i feel he does these things unknowingly

mickymouse21 thumbnail
Anniversary 11 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago

This content was originally posted by: Realityshow

This 100 songs of KK was a terrible idea. The way to have done it was to emulate what they did with Kumar Sanu 50 songs in Idol 10. That was a much liked episode.

Doing half rehearsed Kishore songs is worse than terrible. Thank god they did not try Manna, Mukesh or Rafi!

Kumar Sanu, Alka are good fits. 90's mostly had terrible movies and melodic songs and outright trash like Sarkai Lo Khatiya. No one complains if songs like those are poorly sung. 

They did 100 90s songs episode this season... And they completed 100 songs in one episode (Sunday)..

Not like this week 50 on Saturday and 50 on Sunday.

That time Udit Alka and Kumar Sanu helped to complete 100 songs as they sang most of the songs so judges involvement was not that much as yesterday and Saturday.

Meredith thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

They should have had a Amit Kumar special. He has some good songs as well.

KabutarHoled20 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

This content was originally posted by: suresh555

Honestly, sorry for being harsh, but when they take buffoons as judges, this will happen 

The three most besura singers judging a music talent show is crazy enough but them singing and getting more screen time than the contestants is totally lunatic 

Neha's voice is like an emergency siren, and her trying to add oomph to every number, further murders the song. And to add to the irritation, why is she lypsyncing and acting out to every song a contestant is singing. Her acting skills look disgusting.

Anu sounds like he is going through a root canal when singing 

Himesh is like a village idiot, he literally screams and dances to every song and on Sunday caused the maximum damage

This all happens at the cost of contestants not getting to perform enough and viewers being tortured to watch besuras act stupid 

Himesh's singing is like he sings through his nose no offense. Never liked his singing TBH, especially the hype/meme thing they made of his song, jhalak dikla jaa & ghost crap years ago. ðŸ¤¢