Is Ruq taking Jalal's silence as consent for bad behaviour?

skanda12 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

Friends, yesterday's episode was a very mixed bag for me. The first part of the episode started off with a really good scene of Jodha and Jalal tying the dhaga together at the Baba Salim Chisti camp, and even asking each other about revealing their really deep feelings and "mannats" to each other. I thought all was going forward on the same grand romantic note, when Jodha and Jalal looked up suddenly to spot a new visitor on the scene ... and my heart sank!

It was the Grand Queen Ruqaiya, bedecked in all her royal splendour, and surrounded by an entourage, waiting for Jalal to invite her to join his trip with Jodha . Even as she arrived, she accosted Jalal on his foolishness of thus travelling in common man's garb without escorts, and she started her venting on Jodha on a rather ugly note ... saying it was precisely because Jodha was with Jalal that she herself reconsidered her decision to join on this trip. After all, she knew Jodha and Jalal do not get along, and moreover she knew he would have a very uncomfortable trip if he was saddled with Jodha.

When Ruqaiya found Jalal looking distractedly at Jodha instead of hearing her out, her anger seemed doubled. She barked at him to listen to her and went on in a fishwife fashion - admonishing Jalal for the trip, its idea of travelling in disguise, and the insult that it would heap upon him and his Begums and their audha if he were discovered underneath the disguise. It was all about audha, rank, status, prestige, pride ... and the cursing and belittling of Jodha.

To add to matters, Ruq had even set up a royal khema in such an elaborate way as to attract attention to their whole group (just what Jalal wanted to avoid!) ... and she further seemed extremely hesistant to even change her clothes to match those of Jalal and Jodha to be able to join unobtrusively with them on this trip. Jalal seemed slightly firm with her that she either had to change or give up the trip, and that was about the only strong sentence I heard him utter all through the episode. I thought Ruqaiya would blow up in his face - but she instead got all devilishly practical. She thought if she didn't change as he wanted her to, she would herself deliver Jalal to the much-hated Jodha. And so she changed into something not quite as simple as simple garb should be, and insisted on bringing along a grumbling and grunting Hoshiyaar with the party.

The four of them then walked a while, with the background music of Ruq and Hoshiyaar cursing their fate, when night descended and Jalal decided they all had best stay in some rather humble dwellings of a Banjara family - it was a bare hut and the Banjara husband and wife kindly gave over their charpai and vessels and groceries to Jodha for a the price of her gold hair ornament, and Jodha started cooking for Jalal. Again Ruqaiya had all kinds of insults for Jodha's cooking in the hearing of Jalal, and again Jodha in a good natured way continued with her cooking - but Jalal, instead of telling Ruq not to be so insulting, merely defended Jodha's cooking skills. He seemed to prefer a "non-combative aproach" with Ruq, just interjecting minimally to defend Jodha when the insults became intolerable. If he had shut Ruq up, she would have subsided, but instead when he said something favourable about Jodha as a response, it only got Ruq even more riled up!

Then feeling rather competitive Ruq also insisted on cooking and produced the worst burnt roti I have seen in my life. But as Jodha said to Ruq, if it was made with love and mehanat, Jalal would appreciate it ... and he did. Jodha and Jalal seemed on the same wavelength, but Ruq was on a different planet entirely.

The worst part of the episode was left for the end. Ruqaiya had made up the one-bedroom khema into sleeping quarters for herself and Jalal ... and to Jalal's knowledge, she had the temerity to ask Jodha to go and sleep outside the tent! And what do we see in the precap? Jalal comes outside and is watching Jodha sleep on a charpai on the hard ground while his other Queen is snoring away in the comfy bed within. All that he seems to be able to do is watch Jodha, because in the precap yesterday we didn't hear even a feeble protest from Jalal at the treatment meted out to Jodha by Ruqaiya!

Okay now folks, having given the gist of all that happened in the episode, let me come to the central point of my post. I have deliberately condensed all that happened so that I can avoid the petty details of the scenes focus on the crux of my subject today: THE LACK OF SUFFICIENT OURTRAGE BY JALAL!

What was it about Jalal that made him tolerate and never even remotely berate Ruqaiya for her disgusting behaviour? It was childish, rude, inelegant, and downright insulting to Jodha, and yet the same man who says he feels love anew for Jodha in his heart was keeping quiet watching all this?

In one way it seemed very good that all of yesterday's episode was devoted to showing Jalal exactly the difference between his two queens. One was a overgrown child, ill-mannered, power-mongering and utterly spoilt like a badly brought up brat. The other was dignified and graceful even in the face of insults and jibes, and stayed in alignment with Jalal and his intentions to make this disguised trip really bring him closer to the people he ruled over.

Ruqaiaya clearly neither understood the value of this trip nor why it should be done in disguise ... or even why it should not be accompanied by khemas and footmen. Jodha understood and encouraged and supported everything Jalal was trying to do. In fact Jodha even understood that Jalal had to to put up with this brattish wife, so when the exchange between him and Ruq started getting heated Jodha chose to move away and not be a spectator to their quarrels.

I can't fault Jodha for being gracious and aloof and uncomplaining, and yet loving and caring of Jalal ... and neither could I really fault this Ruq for bad behaviour. We all knew she would behave atrociously, and this situation in the outdoors, with simplicity and audha-less-ness as its theme, was bound to bring out the worst in her. We must all be glad that Jalal got to hear the worst of her relentless audha-fixation and brainless arguments, and saw her exposing herself and her meaness and smallness before him. All this was in contrast also showing Jalal the more queenly qualities of Jodha, who even in her inelegant clothes and as the butt of Ruq's hatred, exuded the class and pedigree of a well-bred person of rank and nobility.

But did Jalal do enough? Why did he not set Ruq down harder and speak up when needed against such treatment of anyone, let alone Jodha? Why did he tolerate the behaviour and rudeness of Ruq? Even if she was his best friend or childhood friend, was he not outraged enough to be able to tell Ruqaiaya to her face that what she was doing was wrong?

Okay, Ruq's unwillingness to wear simple clothes, her inability to cook, her inability to trek over tough terrian is all understood as her own problems. That doesn't affect Jalal or Jodha. But when Ruq actively insults Jodha through the horrendous gesture of making her sleep outside the tent like a menial servant, I felt Jalal should have opened his mouth to say something. Otherwise silence is often taken as consent.

In the days when Jalal was so antagonistic to Jodha, and when she too was on her worst behaviour I could at least understand why he gave Ruq so much rope, and never defended Jodha. And in her own bad days Jodha never cared a hoot for Jalal's stature and behaved extremely badly herself and she cannot be easily forgiven for that. None of that however can be a justification for the here and now. A lot of water has flown under the bridge since then.

Now that Jalal knows he loves Jodha, I feel he should have shown how deep is his love by defending Jodha from such desperate open insults from Ruqaiaya. He can speak to Ruq kindly or angrily, speak to her of manners or audha or whatever language she understands, but he cannot avoid speaking to her, right?

Maybe he preferred to take things calmly - and felt that rather than openly berate Ruq, it would be better if she herself slowly watches him falling in love with and favouring Jodha and comes to a realisation herself that she has to yield to Jodha and cannot go on endlessly abusing Jodha from her competitive jealousy. But this kind of "conquering the situation by attrition" does not seem the way to use with Ruq. The more he stays silent and tolerant, the more vile she seems to become and the person having to bear the brunt of her outrageousness is Jodha.
Ruq is crossing all red lines, and this behaviour that she has already shown yesterday should be enough to make Jalal want to stand up for the right and condemn the wrong! Just seeing the difference between Jodha and Ruqaiaya is not enough. I feel he has to stand up and speak up. I want him to summarily show Ruq what is acceptable and what is not, and where she cannot go. I want him to stop indulging her whims and taking her misbehavour in his stride. Childhood friendship is not to be used as a cover up for inaction in the face of unfairness. I want him to be able show his sense of fairness, not by mere silent studying of the situation and by later use of "teda" methods of diverting Ruq's anger ... but instead I want him to be upright, forthright and uncompromising with Ruq.

Folks I have not done my usual kind of post today and have instead chosen to vent. I don't know how much difference my venting will make to Jalal or Jodha or Ruqaiaya or the Creatives. But at least I have got my sadness off my chest and can survive the weekend.

The only saving grace for me would be if, on Monday, we find that Jalal has not stayed inside in the khema at all and has spent the whole night outside with Jodha, not sleeping all through the night and just sitting beside the one he loves. But even if he does this grand gesture for Jodha, it is still my feeling that he should at least say something to condemn Ruq's actions before sitting outside with Jodha.
Let's wait for Monday and see if Jalal is vocal with Ruq first and then supportive of Jodha also. I hope that's what will happen!
Edited by skanda12 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

119

Views

11.4k

Users

36

Likes

464

Frequent Posters

brownprincess25 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I DIsliked 2nd part of the episode but thanks for the thorough review as usual
Do you think he may have not said anything because of the Dhakka incident? I feel that the truth will come out on Monday. Obviously, he does care that's why he was not asleep. IF he doesn't care than oh boy he needs to man upLOL
Edited by brownprincess25 - 11 years ago
Pallavvi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
The same ques. .jalal wil be asking her in few days :-)
history_geek thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Thoughtful analysis...!..

Episode started off very well with dargah scene...

I feel Baba Chisti indirectly gave a signal to Ruqs also that time is going to change...but she could not understand?

Btw, Ruqs nakhras were funny...

But the episode appeared to be a big let down..towards the end...

I wish Jalal does not stays with Ruqs to pamper her...and ONLY after she falls asleep. go out to see Jodha... If he genuinely feels for Jo he should keep a balance between pampering Ruqs and caring for Jodha...!!

But still after seeing precap i feel Jalal will NOT let Jodha 'akela' outside...

Either he will, take her inside to khema. Or he may decide to stay out... I hope positively... 😊

And, if this does not happens, then Jalal's feelings for Jodha are JUST ''hawa hawaii''...!!!

Let's wait for Monday...!
Edited by history_geek - 11 years ago
Akanksha_33 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Great analysis Mansi...
Frankly, the precap has confused me as hell... I really don't know the real story about the precap so I can't say anything... it can swing both ways...
but How can Jalal let Jodha sleep outside in the floor? Why can't Jalal be frank to Ruqaiyya about his feelings to Jodha? if he can talk about the letter to Ruqaiyya then why not this? 😡
This Ruqaiyya I can't watch her nakras anymore! 😡
history_geek thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Akanksha_33

Great analysis Mansi...

Frankly, the precap has confused me as hell... I really don't know the real story about the precap so I can't say anything... it can swing both ways...


but How can Jalal let Jodha sleep outside in the floor? Why can't Jalal be frank to Ruqaiyya about his feelings to Jodha? if he can talk about the letter to Ruqaiyya then why not this? 😡



This Ruqaiyya I can't watch her nakras anymore! 😡



Ruqs should understand Jalal is not her private property. And, Jodha's gesture was praiseworthy. The moment she felt Ja-Ruqs...wanted to talk...she herself left the place...!...
Akanksha_33 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: history_geek



Ruqs should understand Jalal is not her private property. And, Jodha's gesture was praiseworthy. The moment she felt Ja-Ruqs...wanted to talk...she herself left the place...!...

If Ruqaiyya would have understood this... by now I would be partying... Angry
Jodha is a very dignified lady Abhay... she'll never want to poke her nose in anyone's business... and that's what makes her different from Ruqaiyya... in this case Ruqaiyya is completely the opposite... Angry
Edited by Akanksha_33 - 11 years ago
ChupChupKe thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
i really felt very bad for jodha in that last scene . .the pain in her voice n in her eyes.. 😒 i m confused abt the precap so no commnets on that . 😕The only scene which i loved in yest's epi was JaJo's Mannat Scene .
banuprasa thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Hi Mansi,
Nice analysis. I wonder how Ruk got all the arrangement of that Khema when she & hoshiyar got nothing on hand when they continued their journey with Jo & Ja. Also when Jalal insisted earlier in the episode that he do not want to take rest in the arrangement made by Ruk & want to continue the journey only like Aam admi then why is he accepting the sleeping arrangement done by Ruk again for him.

I hope Ja do not take Jo inside because she may not agree for that & Jalal will stay outside with Jo.

On seeing angry Ruk in the precap seeing Jalal starring at sleeping Jo, she may again have some argument with Jalal & return to Agra. This will let Jo & Ja continue their journey alone like previous.
history_geek thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Akanksha_33


If Ruqaiyya would have understood this... by now I would be partying... 😡

Jodha is a very dignified lady Abhay... she'll never want to poke her nose in anyone's business... and that's what makes her different from Ruqaiyya... in this case Ruqaiyya is completely the opposite... 😡



thus trip will be a watershed moment in Jalal-Ruqs life.. She is assassinating her character in the eyes of Jalal, herself..!.. After each passing day she is getting intolerable...but, yesterday she was funny also... 😆 ... But, in the end she was back to her own self...! 😕

what if she gets to know that baba predicted Jodha will be MUZ..? 😲 😃 😉

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".