Do you think Sur Kshetra is actually Aman Ki Asha?

-Alina-

@-Alina-

IF-Rockerz

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Firstly i havent opened this topic to get bashed or to promote bashing...so please Peace out !

Anyway after watching yesterday's episode, I seriously dont think this show is doing anything good ! I truly love and respect all those people(esp judges) who are present in that show...but after yesterday's episode, there is a bit of disappointment in me. It more looked like a war rather than a hope for Aman ki Asha.

I still remember when for the first time promos of this show aired, there was this thrill and excitement in me and I actually thought this wont be any of those Indo-Pak rivalry shows or cricket matches ! But I guess I was wrong. Yesterday those exchange of words between Atif and Asha ji then Himesh's words and then the environment on that show actually made me to wish that please God no more Pakistan-India fights !! I actually feels sick when i watch such shows or hear people talking about it !! cant WE, both the countries, live happily together like good neighbors do? Why we find reasons to fight?

And yes about the behavior of some people on the show...is actually not at all accepted by me. I wont name them(obviously), but I find it harsh and rude . We all love music. Lets make it a reason to tighten our relation rather than making it more miserable !

15

Reply

Quote

Anondo Rahman

@Anondo.R

IF-Sizzlerz

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

Agree 👍🏼 I'm highly disappointed after watching yesterday's episode. Can assume what will happen next

5

Reply

Quote

shim_ca

@shim_ca

Senior Member

Posted: 11 years ago

i totally agree with you. i am not from India or pakistan. eventhen, these exchanges of words between judges and mentors gave me a mental pressure. we are enjoying less music as we are more tensed with their discussion. this is not the way to bring two countries togther.

9

Reply

Quote

Divya

@dkmystery

IF-Stunnerz

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

it is all scripted... this will bring TRPs na, ppl will like 2 c how they 'fight' with words... Atif's attitude in the 2nd epi was what put me off n I decided not to watch. any show that had grown up Indian n Pak ppl competing was bound to go this way!

remember how Shahid Afridi had 1st praised Indians, then went bk to Pak n said, we pak muslims have big hearts lol

maybe that political party saw this very epi n let the channel air the show coz they showed the ppl weren't behaving well n this is what politicians from both the sides want

1

Reply

Quote

Divya

@dkmystery

IF-Stunnerz

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

n on a different note, Alina, they changed Raghav's surname, it's now Raghav Singh as in, Raghavendra Pratap Singh 😃

Reply

Quote

Niki_cool

@Niki_cool

IF-Sizzlerz

+ 6

Posted: 11 years ago

It seems like a war show rather than a singing show😆 Mentors are like always prepared to attack ...Like come-on guys everybody is a human being and the deserving one should win, no matter its an Indian or Pakistani..SIMPLE...if we are hell tensed due to this think about the poor contestants...🤔 Edited by Niki_cool - 11 years ago

4

Reply

Quote

amina.ahmedraza

@amina.ahmedraza

Goldie

Posted: 11 years ago

war of words is actually a disappointment .. and then the Bg Music the stills like serials

6

Reply

Quote

Maha

@-Maha-

IF-Sizzlerz

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

It seems like two armies are fighting on border.This Ind vs Pak card will definitely give them Trps.Lost my interest after this week episodes.Just watching for the sake of Atif .He is looking so handsome😆
I Did not like the way asha ji behaved.Lol @ the BIg heart thing IF she was trying to reply to Lala than I think she should behave maturely & not like afridi & Cricket is different thing & Music is different.They should not bring such lame arguments in a music competition.A big heart definitely knows how to ignore such things & move on😊.
I am really impressed with the way Abida ji & Rona ji is behaving.👍🏼Trying to avoid all arguments & maintaining peace.Even yesterday the way abida ji replied to asha bhosly was awesome.
Himesh is fine.I did not find anything wrong in his attitude.
The whole atmosphere is so tense. instead of creating such environment they should have learned from other shows like choty ustaad. that was also scripted but i felt that was real aman ki asha..
Edited by -Maha- - 11 years ago

3

Reply

Quote