EP 634 : CID Under Fire (9-Jul-2010) - Page 57

Originally posted by: bhinder.kamboj

guys don't you all think that discussion is going far away from Promo?? we are getting too hype about this thing..it will hurt if episode won't touch height of our expectations... So way to go back... and just watch episode at 10pm ,,if suppose to be good, then would have a party here....

Well I knew it will happen... So was not expecting too much from them.. 2 minute ka scene aur name de diya CID Under Fire... never seen height of such hype... whats going on?

Disappointed with this one, really.

First of all the plot was not good, the motive for the girls blackmailing her was quite weak. Abhi sir and Daya sir had quite reduced screen time and almost no scenes together. Sachin was everywhere, although my real problem is why on Earth was he so rude when questioning the flower shop guys in the beginning? 😕 I didn't like that all, it's so unlike what a cop should be like. I'll blame the writers for that though.

The fire scene, as expected, was just a smaller part with no overall impact on the plot. I'm pretty sure they're deliberately doing this to keep the fans in emotional suspense about something happening to the officers. The title, "CID Under Fire", had nothing to do with the story, just more uncalled hype. Thumbs WAY down, PT team. 👎🏼 And, after all that, the final girl turns out to be dead. Can't they show CID rescuing someone for a change??

There were some positives among this mess though, and to be fair I'll list them too - the psycho guy and his father acted pretty well and the factory location was good. Tasha and Vivek were given slightly more screentime, thankfully. No Freddy tomfoolery, thankfully, and he got more prominence in parts too. The discussions in the lab were meaningful, although Abhi sir came very close to flirting at one point. 🤢 The editing and pacing was fairly good and I think the directing wasn't bad either, it was the plot which was a real fail.

Overall, quite a disappointment especially seeing how they built up so much unwarranted hype over that petty fire scene. Bad move, creative fellas. Hoping for a better episode tomorrow, no excuses.

ACP Sir's absence and Sachin's too much presence it getting unbearable for me to watch. They have ruined everything I loved about CID.

And why did they take the culprit and his dad back to the factory after catching them?! Shouldnt they have taken them to the bureau? Totally non-sensical...



And here I was hoping to see a team-centric episode 😒

The case was seriously bad made just for the sake of finishing an episode. Abhi-Daya together not a single scene, very less of Freddy sir no link to one another, Everything was bad CID has given bad cases earlier but at least we had Abhi Daya together. I hated this case than ever, the culprit seemed deliberate, Not a single positive element in this episode. I am throughly disappointed and sad

Originally posted by: Bhavanab

@prabha di yes I agree with you I just cannot bear this confusion any more,the team needs to be divide,I mean Sachin wasn't there in the jeep scene(thankfully) and suddenly came up in the confession one,the director,creative people,actors and audience everyone are confused

yeah sachin was suddenly there and Abhi wasn't! like he turned into Sachin while entering the place! stupid direction 😡

worst...worst ...worst....episode

Originally posted by: DemonStar

There were some positives among this mess though, and to be fair I'll list them too - the psycho guy and his father acted pretty well and the factory location was good. Tasha and Vivek were given slightly more screentime, thankfully. No Freddy tomfoolery, thankfully, and he got more prominence in parts too. The discussions in the lab were meaningful, although Abhi sir came very close to flirting at one point. 🤢 The editing and pacing was fairly good and I think the directing wasn't bad either, it was the plot which was a real fail.

I agree the psycho guy did a good job but still he was not all that special for the kind of mystery they created around him, hiding his face and all. Then he was suddenly revealed with no drama. I did not like all that mystery they tried to create. The father did OK, I am not impressed, he acted too over-smart most of the time but did well in the last scene. I felt Freddie is still where he has always been Silent Spectator. Its good to see that Salunkhe's Bickering tone is largely reduced, its good to hear him in his current tone. Return of "Taarika ji" I hated it but I will let that go. Editing was fine and Direction too. The problem is with the script itself. Even a genius can do anything if you have such a lame story and bogus screenplay.

Its only Vivek in the Fire Scene that I will like to remember.

I actually liked the fire scene (my Daya Sir's entry scene today, he joined so late in the case ) like @DemonStar the factory location was good. The whole scene was filmed really well, kudos to the cameraman and art director. If they had not hyped it for all the wrong reasons this scene was the highlight of the case.

my review:-
The case according to me was a blunder,a huge mistake by fireworks,not even worth watching a second time.

First of all the Title itself was unjustified,I mean how can they use the title CID under fire,when there was no relation of the case with it ??Like Heart-attack killer the title didn't match the crime
Coming to the fire scene,didn't match even 10 % of how much it was hyped,It started suddenly and ended suddenly,no relation of it with the case,only thing i liked in the fire scene was VIVEK,he was very good there and throughout the episode and why was that man holding the syringe in the fire scene ??

ABHI-DAYA what's the problem of fireworks ?? unhe kitna bataana padhega ?? Abhi-DAya were there for very few scenes and the ones in which they were present they were with different people,not even a single scene of Abhi-Daya and they were talking only through phone,imagine they were chasing a guy by discussing on phone

Sachin-This guy is nothing less than a parasite,I mean why does he have to be there in every scene ?? Is he a magician or what ?? I mean he's there with daya in one scene and in the next he's with Abhijeet and in the flower shop why was he behaving so badly with the guy ?? I don't like him that's it

Forensic-Better,Yes Abhi-Taarika momentary flirting did make me skip a heartbeat but it was controlled

Side actor-Were far better

CAse and reason to murder was a huge mistake,a blunder
Freddy-Tasha-were there but very less,Freddy almost saved us from sitting through stupid comedy

Kaajal-Thank god she wasn't much !!
ACP-Missed him badly,bahut bahut miss kiya iss baar

sat through this episode only for Vivek

In total the case for me was worth than disappointing,totally obnoxious and bad !!