JUDGES EXAM - now grade the judges!

Abhijeet - 7 (he knows his music all right, but he gave too much importance to toshi and towards sanchita)

Alka- 9 (great judge, but i'm cutting 1 point for her giving 8 to abhas' mitwa )

Jatin ji- 7 (a total crack pot... gives marks for ATTEMPTING tough songs,gives rotten marks for personal reasons but has a good sense of melody obviously from his songs)

Bappi- 7 (ok, nothing great)

Kunal ganjawala - 8 (great , but gave too much importance to lame singers like areeb and jayant, and was just plain nasty to prakriti)

Shreya- 8.5 (this 1 was just plain jealous of ash's voice, but was very good in judgin evry 1 else)

Pritam- 5 (best judge in ustaad, WORST in srgmp so i took an avg)

Vishal shekhar- 9 (i would have given 10 if not for their disastrous job in jjws)

Shankar 9 (10 iif not for leniance to asma)

himesh -8 (good, but biased sometimes)

Lalit - 7 (pure EVIL)

Aadesh-8 (pure EVIL too, but shown improvement in srgmp)

Farah-4 (pretty lame, but is funny)

Sonali - 0 (no business here)

Anu malik - 2 (nuff said)

Javed - 6 (terrible.)

Kailash kher -8 (good, bothing great)

Alisha - ??? (didn't watch nuff of ii3 to know how she was)

Shanu da- 9 (great judge! )

Udit ji - 6(judging hi nahin karte hain)

Sonu 9.5 (great judge!)

Shaan- 10 (PERFECT, yet hasn't judged much till now)

Anu kapoor - 8 (decent .)

Ahmed khan - 0 (how dare he judge.)

Ismail, sukhi n monty - 0,0 and 0! (HORRRRRIBLE.)

Asha -10 (on the dot judge)

Amit kumar - 9 (he may have been all "i'm not happy" on k for kishore, but i dont blame him)

Sudesh bhonsle -8.5 (good)

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

Abhijeet - 7 (he knows his music all right, but he gave too much importance to toshi and towards sanchita)
yeh he is a biased judge, seen him on ESBE as well, he favored some contestants 7

Alka- 9 (great judge, but i'm cutting 1 point for her giving 8 to abhas' mitwa )
didn't watch that show, but she was good in lil champs 9

Jatin ji- 7 (a total crack pot... gives marks for ATTEMPTING tough songs,gives rotten marks for personal reasons but has a good sense of melody obviously from his songs)

Bappi- 7 (ok, nothing great)
i think he is all right, he is entertaining

Kunal ganjawala - 8 (great , but gave too much importance to lame singers like areeb and jayant, and was just plain nasty to prakriti)

Shreya- 8.5 (this 1 was just plain jealous of ash's voice, but was very good in judgin evry 1 else)

Pritam- 5 (best judge in ustaad, WORST in srgmp so i took an avg)
he is not a good judge at all in SRGMP so i will give him 4

Vishal shekhar- 9 (i would have given 10 if not for their disastrous job in jjws)
from SRGMP their rating is 10

Shankar 9 (10 iif not for leniance to asma)
i would say 8

himesh -8 (good, but biased sometimes)
agree with 8

Lalit - 7 (pure EVIL)

Aadesh-8 (pure EVIL too, but shown improvement in srgmp)
yeah 7 for him

Farah-4 (pretty lame, but is funny)
she deserves to get 8 from nach baliye

Sonali - 0 (no business here)

Anu malik - 2 (nuff said)
agree with you on that

Javed - 6 (terrible.)

Kailash kher -8 (good, bothing great)

Alisha - ??? (didn't watch nuff of ii3 to know how she was)

Shanu da- 9 (great judge! )

Udit ji - 6(judging hi nahin karte hain)
yes he does very litlle judging so 5 for him

Sonu 9.5 (great judge!)
he is good, 9.5 for him is right

Shaan- 10 (PERFECT, yet hasn't judged much till now)

Anu kapoor - 8 (decent .)
yeah agree with you on 8, he is good, just his anger which is his personal thing

Ahmed khan - 0 (how dare he judge.)
no he is good, well he is a choreographer so he get's 8

Ismail, sukhi n monty - 0,0 and 0! (HORRRRRIBLE.)
well ismail is pretty bad, maybe 4 for him

Asha -10 (on the dot judge)

Amit kumar - 9 (he may have been all "i'm not happy" on k for kishore, but i dont blame him)

Sudesh bhonsle -8.5 (good)

man u have so many judges in your mind, i have markrd the ones with which i am most familiar with

Originally posted by: gursharan

man u have so many judges in your mind, i have markrd the ones with which i am most familiar with

well farah khan is fine in Nach, she's just spices up somethings, but she does gives marks very accordingly, and points out most of the mistakes.

well yea ahmed is only suppose to be judging dance, he doesn't have to say anything about singing.

Originally posted by: gursharan

well farah khan is fine in Nach, she's just spices up somethings, but she does gives marks very accordingly, and points out most of the mistakes.

well yea ahmed is only suppose to be judging dance, he doesn't have to say anything about singing.

dont get u. 😕

u saying he shouldn't or he doesnt?

if ur saying he shouldn't then yes.

but if ur saying he doesnn't then no he's said a lot of foolish things on performances of contestants.

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

dont get u. 😕

u saying he shouldn't or he doesnt?

if ur saying he shouldn't then yes.

but if ur saying he doesnn't then no he's said a lot of foolish things on performances of contestants.

no, i am saying he shouldn't be saying all that, let abhijeet do all the technical stuff he should just give marks.

Originally posted by: gursharan

no, i am saying he shouldn't be saying all that, let abhijeet do all the technical stuff he should just give marks.

hmmm yeah the cheeseball should keep his mouth shut.

I only watch SRGMP and Indian Idol4

Originally posted by: Meredith

I only watch SRGMP and Indian Idol4

 

  Sonali- crappy actress, therefore crap judge,

   Kailesh-ok

  Anu Malik-has music knowledge 8

 Javed Akhter-8

 

  Pritam-0

 Adesh- 8

 HIMESH-ARROGANT

 Shanker-9

good 👏

😆I so agree with u on teh sonali one hehehehehehhehe ur funny lol but true she doesnt have any business judging a singing contest.........