Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 38 - Page 59

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I have always attested in my posts both are victims and both made mistakes which they have to correct. And I always said Mannat should have never ever lied and tried to defend RoTu and it wasn't her place to take the blame for Aman's truth. But she chose RoTu and DK over Vikrant.

Watch today's episode & Mannat's speech to Neetu.

And I have always mentioned that taking Vikrant's side would not have served the same consequence...she would be still thrown out of SM...

I don't know why people are not understanding this point.

Vish had already taken Vik on her side since she entered SM on day 1. Mannat had a inkling of Aman's truth but she herself did know the entire story so what would she have told Vikrant...

Even if Mannat had shown proofs Vikrant would not have believed her (thanks to Vish & ARS for that)...

And i had also mentioned that that when Aman truth happened, Mannat was not even born so the onus was not completely on her to tell the truth..It was solely RoTu's & to DK

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

And also saw mannat saying "yeh hota hai beta, vo vikrant saluja nahi... Vikrant saluja na dhairya ji ke aage adhe percent bhi ache nahi hai,vo chahe bhi na dhairya ji jaisa nahi ban sakte.... Isiliye mere dost ko swarthi nah kahe...

Making mannat say all this and then showing dhairya actually have feelings for her... It's looking like they are showing that mannat can misjudge people too...

Maybe dhairya will not turn negative but might be a bit grey and mannat might blindly trust dhairya against vik, maybe they are trying to put mannat in vikrant's shoes too.. Just like how they are gonna put vik in mannat's shoes when vik gets to know about yuvi's truth.. This is a prediction though

I don't even care if the dude turns negative or not, His crying made me laugh more 😭 and Mannat's speech was out of the world and Neetu you know how much I love her

That whole scene was this basically

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

If it was platonic then he could have said that they are friends or mannat is like family to him.... But him talking about mannat's will and there was something about marzi, manzoori etc.. too... Felt like he actually is confessing he has feelings but he also knows mannat will never love him back, so he doesn't expect anything expect respect from her..

jab tak he is not crossing the boundaries & being touchy like yashika, i am fine..

often times out of emotional dependence people do fall for each other...

But the minute they make him grey and fight against Vikrant for Mannat, thats were makers loose the plot

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

And I have always mentioned that taking Vikrant's side would not have served the same consequence...she would be still thrown out of SM...

I don't know why people are not understanding this point.

Vish had already taken Vik on her side since she entered SM on day 1. Mannat had a inkling of Aman's truth but she herself did know the entire story so what would she have told Vikrant...

Even if Mannat had shown proofs Vikrant would not have believed her (thanks to Vish & ARS for that)...

And i had also mentioned that that when Aman truth happened, Mannat was not even born so the onus was not completely on her to tell the truth..It was solely RoTu's & to DK

I am referring to Mannat lying to Vikrant, threatening Vish and supporting RoTu and DK over Vikrant.

It was not Mannat's place to tell the truth or hide the truth or threaten anyone to not tell the truth. I was supporting Mannat until she was requesting RoTu to tell the truth to Vikrant.

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

If it was platonic then he could have said that they are friends or mannat is like family to him.... But him talking about mannat's will and there was something about marzi, manzoori etc.. too... Felt like he actually is confessing he has feelings but he also knows mannat will never love him back, so he doesn't expect anything expect respect from her..

Haven’t seen that scene but I wish I could throw the cast iron pan on the channel & writers. They do absolutely NOTHING to expose the cobras already present, but now turn Dhairya also grey??

I would love to see how long this show will run without ever exposing the main villains.

Remind me never to watch another Mukta Colors combination with Jassi thrown in.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

See I said so. Poor DK sacrificed his life for his brother, took care of his family, so it's only natural he falls in love with his brothers wife and this is not back stabbing at all

Not at all, he sacrificed his life for his brother's family—no backstabbing, just unconditionally paying the price for his brother's crimes.Looking after his brother's wife,kid and parents with no feelings, A "fool's errand"...

Neetu is savage today.He is caught off guard and revealed his true feelings..I liked her for the last two episodes,though I hate her in general all the time..

It's finally here, just as we long anticipated, Rd..

Even Mannat is on the high horse...acting high and arrogant..

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I am referring to Mannat lying to Vikrant, threatening Vish and supporting RoTu and DK over Vikrant.

It was not Mannat's place to tell the truth or hide the truth or threaten anyone to not tell the truth. I was supporting Mannat until she was requesting RoTu to tell the truth to Vikrant.

Her threatening Vish was valid bcs Mannat did have a hint (intuition) that she would do something opposite & Vish successfully did that...

If Vish did not do not that then the ball would have been in Mannat's court. Atleast she would have gotten chance to show the proof first...

Big revelation that DK likes Mannat but he says he knows his limits and would never cross the line. this is not in Mannat’s presence.
Mannat says a lot of things against Vikrant. Which were hard to hear. Her anger stems from his rejection of her and the baby and him giving divorce papers on Shruti’s funeral day. Him knowing about the pregnancy and giving divorce papers both are manipulation’s by people. When will those people be brought to book yaar?? Yeh Kya hai??

Ronny meets Vik at the market outside the hotel. And they have an argument with both accusing each other. Vik throws the brahmastra; they lied to him. Ronny admits it, he says they apologised and apologised but did he ever forgive them? He says not to come looking for Neetu. And be happy with the life he have chosen 7 years ago.

Mannat is feeling bad that Neetu accused DK of having feelings. She come to him with coffee . And apologises to him. She says she has got coffee for her best friend ( specifying)

ARS hallucinates that Mannat beats her up for killing shruti. Malla arrives to the rescue. ARS says they have to work very fast and be careful otherwise all the plotting of so many years will come undone.

Vish calls Vik and tries to find out from him about Mannat. She asks him if he has forgotten his mom after going to Indore. He denies it and says he was busy with Yuvi. She also asks him about Mannat and the ice kaand. He says he will come back and tell her.

Vish is happy thinking that the hate they poured between Manvik is still burning bright between them.

Pre cap: Vik seems to be standing outside their house watching them dance. Mannat senses him. Is it Mannat’s dream?

Originally posted by: Rdigest

See I said so. Poor DK sacrificed his life for his brother, took care of his family, so it's only natural he falls in love with his brothers wife and this is not back stabbing at all

RD

See what I told you exactly 2months back😜😡.

Even my husband said when they were having tea together “ did they hook up Trupti? He likes her and you can clearly see that”😜.

I told you this when they were going to get Dadi on wedding day😡