Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 139

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Bold: but wouldn't he question mannat as to why she hid it??.... Then mannat might tell him the truth na??? , that she came to share and that he rejected, that will make the entire secret to come out.... ??

Pink: but why will she hide after she knows he didn't know... Her entire problem is that he denied her baby right..??, so when she gets to know he didn't know wouldn't she be happy about it and let Vik be in dua's life...?

Chaotic with the way writers are going about adding more negativity and MU's , have a thought Mannat won't tell Vikrant even if she finds out he never knew about the baby nor he rejected the baby by telling herself "this is for Dua's Benefit" and she will get trapped again by the witches coming a full circle to pre-leap where the truth will come out as another shock to Vikrant 😬, this is me thinking like the crazy so called writers😆

Originally posted by: Daman17

I have so many emojis but don’t wanna waste, for me both deserve cycle with carrier to go back to Mumbai 🚵 and enjoy the luxury life on someone else expense. Such a waste addition to the show🙃

I am surprised you even made a post for the losers and I am responding

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Malla toh bachha chor hai. Its proved already. Uska pov ka use nai hai consider karke. ARS might have managed to mention someone's name as father. We don't know that part yet. OR she might have completely changed Yuvi's details only or killed his parents...

Coming to why Mannat kept DK's name, I feel no one has the right to judge what a woman wants do in such a situation. IF she wants she can go ahead without a father's name or with father's name, its her choice.

Children born out of sexual abuse is a completely different case. Usme bhi I have seen 1000s of comments literally blaming the women of not keep the accuser's name which is inhuman & absurd..

Bold- That's so sad💔😭. You know sometimes to settle case victims are asked to marry their culprits. That's all the more cruel😭

TBH I don't get this and can't even imagine their pain they go through 😭.

Now coming to Malla and Mannat. I know there's no comparison but I was saying about the situation they were in. Like being a single mom at that time and the decision they took.

As for my personal perspective I wanted Mannat to give Dua her name That's all.

❤🤗

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

I feel bad looking at audience reaction under the shows posts... they are wanting mannat with dhairya....

Vik questioning mannat's loyalty pre leap though distasteful was required for leap... But atleast now they should have clearly shown that Vik doesn't doubt that mannat was having feelings for dhairya during their relationship but instead is thinking that mannat might have moved on after their relationship ended..and is angry that she moved on so easily while he is still stuck at her...I hope they make this thing clear, this will atleast make audience feel a little bit for Vik...

Was there a clarification I am confused, Vikrant said Mannat moved on after that day right nothing about CA is addressed atleast from what I understood.

And looks like writers are successful in making Vikrant the villain though he was a victim like Mannat of the vicious plans of the villains+ DK.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DTxvihKEtfE/

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Bold this is exactly the point, he started this whole destruction, not believing Mannat even when was found locked up and eventually escaped after trapping Vikrant with Vish. Did he even for a moment think what will happen to Vikrant?

From the beginning he trapped Vikrant intentionally, that was his plan all along until he heard from Dadi which Vikrant never got to hear because she died again DK's incapablilty to protect her.

I don't understand the Vikrant hit DK part & what else was he supposed to do - He saw Vish manipulated Vikrant exactly like she manipulated him to use his position and even get BM by the villains. He destroyed Vikrant's life, so maybe instead of running to the nearest exit in the name of taking care of Vikrant's family and living happily he should have tried harder just like how he searched for Vikrant for years per his own confirmation. Or he searched for Vikrant because he was being EB by the same mother and was unhappy, but now that he is happy with the new found life he no longer wished to bridge the gap with his brother who might be suffering?

Bold... what do you mean destruction and trapping???

How can you say the motive behind this was to harm Vikrant in anyway???? It wasnt... it was to seek revenge for their father and bring back Aman. How is that wrong given where he was and what he knew when he came into their lives?????

Pink... whats the parameter for happiness???? And how do we think he is happy??? By his own admission right???? Thats why I pointed out that neither Mannat nor RoTu consider him as a family member and he knows it....

The only happiness in DKs life is Dua... for that matter nobody is happy... not even Mannat.

Neither is he going to gain anything from this pretend marriage. His own life is on hold because of this whole Duas baba narrative... isn't that self punishment for the destruction his mother has created??? And his brother thrusted on RoTu and Mannat???? How is this not seen as rectifying the mistakes his mom and brother did????

I think the problem with this whole DK bashing is precisely this... everyone recognises that there is some goodness in DK even if they dont accept openly ... he is not exactly like Malla and Y... thats why you think he is given God treatment....

and Vikrant has to be better than DK ... but thats the worrying point for audience who hates DK... because they dont trust Mukta and her team... whether the writers will make Vik look better than DK... given the precedent so far Vik is not looking good at this moment... and there is no hope he will be redeemed in near future

I understand your fear/hate now 🤣

And I will still say Mukta will protect Vik like she always has ... 😀

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Was there a clarification I am confused, Vikrant said Mannat moved on after that day right nothing about CA is addressed atleast from what I understood.

And looks like writers are successful in making Vikrant the villain though he was a victim like Mannat of the vicious plans of the villains+ DK.

Bold:

Well today's dialogue by Vik about mannat's fitrat was not good... but i dont think Vik still has same assumptions about mannat that he accused mannat of, pre-leap..

I can understand that Vik realised his mistake of doubting mannat....during mezbaani confession he said that he is guilty about his mistakes and mad at mannat for leaving instead of staying back and making him realize his mistakes... So that means he feels he was wrong in questioning mannat's feelings for dhairya..

And after seeing mannat-dhairya-dua's most seemingly obvious scenes where anyone could by default think they are family even after those visuals he was shown questioning if they are really family???.....doesnt it show he doesn't feel mannat had feelings for dhairya during their relationship...because if he still doubts that mannat had feelings for dhairya during their relationship, why would he have doubt about them really being a family..wouldn't it be a obvious fact for him, why will he have doubts regarding it... this shows that he doesn't doubt mannat's loyalty for him when they were in relationship..

But audience doesn't think this deep, they go by dialogues... And today's dialogue by Vik at the end of episode was confusing... That's why I want makers to clearly show vik's stance towards mannat-dhairya's relationship... this way Vik will be spared at least from this angle..

Moor I don't recognize his goodness, the moment he failed to even address that Mannat was found locked in a trunk hurt while his mumma played the skit, I lost all respect for him not just as Vikrant's brother but also a cop who was supposed to protect people.

Wasn't it his plan to bring Vish into Vikrant's life, bring out the criminal activities of RoTu and get his Aman back? But suddenly once he got a living talking proof he decided Vish is worse than RoTu , he decided he won't reveal the truth , he will sacrifice, he will take Vish and move away and finally he ditched Vikrant when Vikrant got his memories back and trapped fully by Vish. All I see here is just he and himself.

All his memories of Mannat were also confusing. All the happy moments and that last moment of distraught Mannat... if he recalls that doesnt he realise she was heartbroken????

Why would she be if she waa having an affair with DK????

I had hoped writers will redeem Vik by showing he never doubted her but said all that in anger.

Originally posted by: ChaoticTangles

Bold:

Well today's dialogue by Vik about mannat's fitrat was not good... but i dont think Vik still has same assumptions about mannat that he accused mannat of, pre-leap..

I can understand that Vik realised his mistake of doubting mannat....during mezbaani confession he said that he is guilty about his mistakes and mad at mannat for leaving instead of staying back and making him realize his mistakes... So that means he feels he was wrong in questioning mannat's feelings for dhairya..

And after seeing mannat-dhairya-dua's most seemingly obvious scenes where anyone could by default think they are family even after those visuals he was shown questioning if they are really family???.....doesnt it show he doesn't feel mannat had feelings for dhairya during their relationship...because if he still doubts that mannat had feelings for dhairya during their relationship, why would he have doubt about them really being a family..wouldn't it be a obvious fact for him, why will he have doubts regarding it... this shows that he doesn't doubt mannat's loyalty for him when they were in relationship..

But audience doesn't think this deep, they go by dialogues... And today's dialogue by Vik at the end of episode was confusing... That's why I want makers to clearly show vik's stance towards mannat-dhairya's relationship... this way Vik will be spared at least from this angle..

That's good if it's understood, because I didn't understand if CA thing was cleared or if it will be addressed because all Mannat sees in FB is him rejecting Dua