Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 37 - Page 120

Originally posted by: Moor278

You can justify Viks POV only till a certain extent RD... yesterday's episode wasnt that.

And I am fine with it... fully expecting his obnoxious behaviour to continue for more days now.

Or atleast till he meets Neetu and softens a bit.

And the worst thing is that after denouncing Rotu and throwing them out he has still kept their given name and continues enjoying their money, opulence and business because of a property transfer made by Ronnie in full faith! Continues living in SM. Had he been so upset, shouldn't he have changed his name to aman kumar and no longer live in SM and run the business as if it were rightfully his???

Now who is the gold digger???

The guy is and has been surrounded by gold diggers and leeches since forever and who does he openly call and treat like a gold digger??? Mannat!! Wah wah!!

And what about trusting the one you claim to be so much in love with? The dubious and kal hi aayi hui Vishakha shows him a photo that doesn't prove anything at all conclusively to the viewer's eyes, and he fails to see her genuine excitement at getting married soon to him, her open love in all her being be it eyes, body language, smile, etc. and he chooses to actually believe immediately that she is cheating on him with his bro and double-timing him????

Is all this forgotten by some of the forumwasis???

DK has done nothing of all this and is just doing the needful at the moment and going with the flow and helping out the ousted family and thrown out so cruelly and so badly!! Dua is born, for society's sake he becomes her baba, spends his 7 plus years with this beautiful baby who is now such a cute intelligent gutsy girl. Will he not be protective of her and feel as if she were his own?? After all he has played a huge part in brining her up, keeping her safe till then and has given a decent lifestyle to the rejected ones??

I truly fail to understand why he is being hated so much. He has just done what any gentleman in his place would have done.

Yes he goofed up. Haven't all the others goofed up too?? be it mannat, rotu, vikrant??

It must have been so tough for him also to accept vishakha the mother he literally worshipped, for turning out as what she truly was!!!

Anyway I am done with the ranting!

All in all everyone is just in a terrible mess right now and everyone has played a role oin finding themselves in this shit! And dissing some excessively and being understanding to a select few is not OK in my opinion.

Sorry Moor quoted you by mistake. I completely agree with your balanced POV.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

So I didn't understand Vik, he looked a bit unstable, doesn't he remember what he did, he threw them out. He had no hint of guilt when Mannat reminded about throwing Ronny out. Yes, they lied.

But Vik would not treat anyone, forget people who at one point he loved.. so badly. How does he justify it doing this to people whose money and business he is running??

To me, he didn’t appear unstable. He comes across like a nasty woman who is very bitter & bears grudges for a long period of time. He was dripping revenge.

Plus as always, he is at the beck & call of yet another cobra. Now when he returns to Bombay, he will be the Man Friday for 4 king cobras.

As of now, I don’t still feel pity for him, bcos wherever he has reached, has been self inflicted. As you all know, I don’t have faith in Mukta giving him some EQ & intelligence.

Ronnie’s taunts were oh-so-satisfying! Throwing in,Vikrant Saluja vs Aman Kumar was soul soothing.

We all know Neetu will flip the moment she sees him 😤🤬

Once again you have answered your own question...

DK believed all this and did all that till he believed Vish was right... he didnt knew Dadis version of events.

He didnt after that. Sided with RoTu and Mannat .... isn't that the whole point of contention for Vik and how Vish used it to influence Vik???? He did try to reason with Vik too... asking him to think why he was supporting RoTu who killed their father and not his bio mom?

Vish projected a picture that Mannat is having an affair with DK while he is keen on supporting RoTu because he wants to be rich. Successfully hiding what sach gang was trying to tell Vik.

But that wasnt his intention... this is why he is not the villain. Simply because a person commits a genuine mistake (or lies) we can call him/her villain... by that logic every character including ManVik and Dua are villains for someone else.

I will say it again... everyone character has lied... no one is blemish free... its the intentions that matter.

As for the God treatment... I dont see it anywhere. DK is dispensable. Neither does baba jaap matters. It is purely because as of now Mannat believes Vik has rejected the child.

Like I have told you earlier I will judge Mannat if she continues on the baba jaap after she knows Vik was fooled or Vik is trying to win Dua.

https://x.com/filmy_mons/status/2013812593270628495

For a minute, forget the right and wrong, who is right and wrong.

What an amazing scene by Rushad and Adnan ! So well executed.

I remember some director saying about actors like Madhuri, Shridevi , in their times, that they were placed in ridiculous situations but the skill is making the audience think that it can all happen and making you react to those situations!

Our daily soaps are like that !

Originally posted by: Padmajaan

And the worst thing is that after denouncing Rotu and throwing them out he has still kept their given name and continues enjoying their money, opulence and business because of a property transfer made by Ronnie in full faith! Continues living in SM. Had he been so upset, shouldn't he have changed his name to aman kumar and no longer live in SM and run the business as if it were rightfully his???

Now who is the gold digger???

The guy is and has been surrounded by gold diggers and leeches since forever and who does he openly call and treat like a gold digger??? Mannat!! Wah wah!!

And what about trusting the one you claim to be so much in love with? The dubious and kal hi aayi hui Vishakha shows him a photo that doesn't prove anything at all conclusively to the viewer's eyes, and he fails to see her genuine excitement at getting married soon to him, her open love in all her being be it eyes, body language, smile, etc. and he chooses to actually believe immediately that she is cheating on him with his bro and double-timing him????

Is all this forgotten by some of the forumwasis???

DK has done nothing of all this and is just doing the needful at the moment and going with the flow and helping out the ousted family and thrown out so cruelly and so badly!! Dua is born, for society's sake he becomes her baba, spends his 7 plus years with this beautiful baby who is now such a cute intelligent gutsy girl. Will he not be protective of her and feel as if she were his own?? After all he has played a huge part in brining her up, keeping her safe till then and has given a decent lifestyle to the rejected ones??

I truly fail to understand why he is being hated so much. He has just done what any gentleman in his place would have done.

Yes he goofed up. Haven't all the others goofed up too?? be it mannat, rotu, vikrant??

It must have been so tough for him also to accept vishakha the mother he literally worshipped, for turning out as what she truly was!!!

Anyway I am done with the ranting!

All in all everyone is just in a terrible mess right now and everyone has played a role oin finding themselves in this shit! And dissing some excessively and being understanding to a select few is not OK in my opinion.

Thanks Padma... aptly said.

Bold... is where I get why people are upset... that he could have done all this while being bade papa for Dua.. which is fair enough...

But like Kidult had rightfully pointed out few days ago... when they landed in Indore... Mannat would have been pregnant and they look like a family... all the adults must have decided to continue on the pretense that DM are married. Which is not so wrong to avoid questions on Vik.

And most importantly... RoTu are also in agreement with calling DK as Baba... surely there is some reason for it which we have not seen it yet. Maybe the upcoming scene with baby Dua will clarify that.

My own POV on DKs presence differs as I said in earlier post.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I think their problem is complicated. When both parties are wrong it's then not clear cut. What led to the separation is the Dua bit which Vikrant is not to blame for and he is not even aware of. Basing on both of their characters even though he chased them out of the house they all knew they were to blame and i feel they would have given him time to calm down. The Malla stunt at Shruti's funeral is what sealed the separation.

And when you look at it from Vikrant's angle as well that's the missing link. Yes he reacted badly but he came back once he heard about Shruti's death. The problem with Vikrant is he hasn't replayed that day in his mind otherwise he probably would have realised something. Just before the leap when he was in his room he kept saying she wanted to tell me something. I think their disappearing act messed him up so he then just goes back to blaming them for the lies.

Yeh grown up mard kab baneiga?? Cobras and he ALWAYS blame others for everything. Ever heard them saying WE are at fault. Vikrant apologises for few minutes and then REPEATS his stupidity again and again & again. Like Mannat said, i am not your mother to keep correcting you.

Guess thats why i always side FLs. Coz the MLs are overgrown brats. This one is an extreme case.

Originally posted by: Padmajaan

And the worst thing is that after denouncing Rotu and throwing them out he has still kept their given name and continues enjoying their money, opulence and business because of a property transfer made by Ronnie in full faith! Continues living in SM. Had he been so upset, shouldn't he have changed his name to aman kumar and no longer live in SM and run the business as if it were rightfully his???

Now who is the gold digger???

The guy is and has been surrounded by gold diggers and leeches since forever and who does he openly call and treat like a gold digger??? Mannat!! Wah wah!!

And what about trusting the one you claim to be so much in love with? The dubious and kal hi aayi hui Vishakha shows him a photo that doesn't prove anything at all conclusively to the viewer's eyes, and he fails to see her genuine excitement at getting married soon to him, her open love in all her being be it eyes, body language, smile, etc. and he chooses to actually believe immediately that she is cheating on him with his bro and double-timing him????

Is all this forgotten by some of the forumwasis???

DK has done nothing of all this and is just doing the needful at the moment and going with the flow and helping out the ousted family and thrown out so cruelly and so badly!! Dua is born, for society's sake he becomes her baba, spends his 7 plus years with this beautiful baby who is now such a cute intelligent gutsy girl. Will he not be protective of her and feel as if she were his own?? After all he has played a huge part in brining her up, keeping her safe till then and has given a decent lifestyle to the rejected ones??

I truly fail to understand why he is being hated so much. He has just done what any gentleman in his place would have done.

Yes he goofed up. Haven't all the others goofed up too?? be it mannat, rotu, vikrant??

It must have been so tough for him also to accept vishakha the mother he literally worshipped, for turning out as what she truly was!!!

Anyway I am done with the ranting!

All in all everyone is just in a terrible mess right now and everyone has played a role oin finding themselves in this shit! And dissing some excessively and being understanding to a select few is not OK in my opinion.

Bold: well said. Why keep the name & property of the very person you hate & threw out of your house? Makes him as big a gold digger as the rest of the cobras.

Baby dua scenes coming up, damn casting this child looks like yami younger version.

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DTwq3pykvK-/