Originally posted by: nehaprks
If we choose on basis of talent then Amaal should win hands-down, followed by Praneet and Gaurav; perhaps even Farhana.
If we choose on basis of active contribution then it should be Tanya and Farhana; Amaal during his active days.
If the prior fan-base puts in all their efforts into voting, then Gaurav and Amaal were the most well-known earlier and either of these can win.
If we choose on basis of nice personality then Gaurav is the winner.
On basis of charisma, it should be Amaal - the contestants as well as viewers have always been interested in him.
If we decide on basis of uniqueness then Tanya and Malti fit the bill
The other contestants like Shehbaz and Ashnoor don't really matter.
I am sorry but I have issue with your first line only baaki it's your opinion....
I actually have an issue with this way of ranking “talent.”Gaurav is a brilliant and highly credible actor.Amaal is an exceptionally talented musician.Pranit is a skilled stand-up comedian.
These three don’t just differ in quality .. they come from entirely different creative disciplines. Their skill sets, metrics of success, artistic processes, and professional journeys are not even comparable.
How can you say someone should win on the basis of talent when one expresses talent through acting,another through music composition and singing,and another through comedy and performance?
It becomes an apples vs oranges vs grapes situation.You simply cannot create a single “talent ranking” chart for three completely unrelated art forms.
If the show were about singing, Amaal would obviously dominate.
If it were about acting or emotional range, Gaurav would shine.
If it were about comic timing and improv, Pranit would have an edge.
But Big Boss is not a talent competition for a specific art form.
Music Corner
195