Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 24 - Page 138

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Kaunsa bts?! Also when she was on the floor or covered her well only…

Anyways I am in minority I didn’t find anything wrong at all… also nothing wrong when she was taking care of Sonia … oh well.

Me neither... I just remembered a BTS when I read all this. There was one... taken by some crew and a very low angle shot if you can understand

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Is it just me or I find Sanjays acting very flat… the writing is sloppy and his acting too.

I can’t connect Anirudh with Mannat as father daughter…. Wish they had shown some connection earlier. It’s also very hard to understand when did Anirudh find out Mannat was his daughter… I still remember the scene in the police station where he was inquiring with that constable. Now it feels like he knew all along who Mannat is … quite confused!

Gagan and Ronnie are shown to have a connect with Mannat but I can’t seem to see Anirudhs affection… his IV are better o guess

Agree on this... and there were some updates from IF where it said he went to the hospital to check records and all... that never came out.

Even the update about Punnu being slapped by Vik hasn't happened. Its surprising Malla wont rat Punnu out.

Vikrant for me is fine because he clearly doesn’t know past crimes of ARS..

Mannat and gagan should be the one to atleast doubt her ..neither I could connect to mannat’s sudden love for ArS.

Ani’s love for his daughter is understandable knowing his back story ..

Rest is normal ..m sure after dahi handi..mannat will start using her brain

And m only concerned about Vikrant’s love story from Vikrant’s side as I dont know whether they will involve him in exposing ars..

Every character has a different role to play

Vikrant’s character is driven by love and it has been written very well even in tricky situations like this

Love him

Not questioning your love for him

I am criticizing the inconsistency in writing...

He only bursts out when Mannat is in direct attack... otherwise remains passive.

Agreed that he didnt know about ARSs crimes... but even when Mannat is telling him he absolutely has no reaction to it at all...

Mannat is in trauma, hasnt even got time to process ... but as her life partner... he has to make her see sense... Aishs crimes cannot be excused because she was assaulted.

Same goes for Gagan... I had pointed it out the same day Aish revealed her assault story... Gagan went soft on her seeing her injured ... immediately after Malla revealed Aish is mom... this is before Aish told all of them about Anirudh. Doesnt make sense to me.

I love Mannat as a character... but I dont mind criticizing her character graph if she is looking dumb... and I will do the same for Vikrant or anyone else.

So far the only consistent writing is for Aishwarya

Not for once anyone believed her sob story... not the regular watchers at least...

Originally posted by: Moor278

Not questioning your love for him

I am criticizing the inconsistency in writing...

He only bursts out when Mannat is in direct attack... otherwise remains passive.

Agreed that he didnt know about ARSs crimes... but even when Mannat is telling him he absolutely has no reaction to it at all...

Mannat is in trauma, hasnt even got time to process ... but as her life partner... he has to make her see sense... Aishs crimes cannot be excused because she was assaulted.

Same goes for Gagan... I had pointed it out the same day Aish revealed her assault story... Gagan went soft on her seeing her injured ... immediately after Malla revealed Aish is mom... this is before Aish told all of them about Anirudh. Doesnt make sense to me.

I love Mannat as a character... but I dont mind criticizing her character graph if she is looking dumb... and I will do the same for Vikrant or anyone else.

So far the only consistent writing is for Aishwarya

Not for once anyone believed her sob story... not the regular watchers at least...

Also he tried to explain mannat that she has no role in ars’ plight ..he calmed her down and said that it’s not her mistake , when mannat was blaming herself ..

As for me..the consistency in writing has been beautiful in case of Vikrant as well other than ARs..

Vikrant has always been driven by love and also he calls spade a spade ..once he has come to know Malala’s true face ..he has no sympathy or anything for her ..

Even for neetu ..sure he respects her as mom but he never fails to call her out when she is wrong ..yes he is soft ! Who wouldn’t be ? And he is a son and sons do have soft corner for their moms ..

And here his mom hasn’t tried to kill mannat ..like malla and ARs have done

Mannat knows everything about malla yet she chose to keep mum..that was the biggest flaw in her character ..knowing she always stands and fights for truth like she is doing for ARs

You can call me biased but for me Vikrant is the most well written character and humane..like normal ppl ..not the ones involved in planning plotting and all..

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

Mannat knows everything about malla yet she chose to keep mum..that was the biggest flaw in her character ..knowing she always stands and fights for truth like she is doing for ARs

Even if Mannat tells Vikrant about ONS after that what next ?

Mannat will be forcibly thrown out for doing EMA as she has no proof even if Vikrant believes her. Mannat is needed in the SM.

If Vikrant tries to confront, Malla Will obviously not agree and other Keerat will character assassinate him.

Neetu will keep forcing him to be in the marriage.

Also for marriage annulment, proper proof is needed so currently he doesnt have anything in his hands & neither Mannat

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

Even if Mannat tells Vikrant about ONS after that what next ?

Mannat will be forcibly thrown out for doing EMA as she has no proof even if Vikrant believes her. Mannat is needed in the SM.

If Vikrant tries to confront, Malla Will obviously not agree and other Keerat will character assassinate him.

Neetu will keep forcing him to be in the marriage.

Also for marriage annulment, proper proof is needed so currently he doesnt have anything in his hands & neither Mannat

Of course ..what i am saying is ..mannat has stopped her mission of exposing malla altogether and collecting proofs against malla as she has decided to let the matter go..

I am not expecting her to tell truth without proof

Are behen ... pehle ki baat nahi kar rahi hun... I clearly said since Anirudh track started...

But jab Mannat use Bata rahi hai... this week and especially yesterday's episode... tab ka bol rahi hun... he didnt have a reaction... a principled fellow like him should question what happened to Sunita... especially since he was there when she came out of the burning house... took her to the hospital and all...

Mannat ko to bhi criticize kiya na maine... she stopped revealing about ONS because Vik had already decided to divorce Malla .... thats stupid...

But unless you missed the conversation... everybody wishes Mannat would reveal him the truth and erase his guilt...

Thats the inconsistency in writing ... and its in Mannat and Vikrant both

Lets not call anyone biased... and defend our favourites... its the writers and editors who are doing this... we dont have any control...

Originally posted by: Coolmeg

Is it just me or I find Sanjays acting very flat… the writing is sloppy and his acting too.

I can’t connect Anirudh with Mannat as father daughter…. Wish they had shown some connection earlier. It’s also very hard to understand when did Anirudh find out Mannat was his daughter… I still remember the scene in the police station where he was inquiring with that constable. Now it feels like he knew all along who Mannat is … quite confused!

Gagan and Ronnie are shown to have a connect with Mannat but I can’t seem to see Anirudhs affection… his IV are better o guess

I agree with you Meg... Sanjay falls flat in comparison to all the actors of the show. Also his affection for Mannat isn't reflecting our minds thanks to the actor I suppose...

Originally posted by: Moor278

Are behen ... pehle ki baat nahi kar rahi hun... I clearly said since Anirudh track started...

But jab Mannat use Bata rahi hai... this week and especially yesterday's episode... tab ka bol rahi hun... he didnt have a reaction... a principled fellow like him should question what happened to Sunita... especially since he was there when she came out of the burning house... took her to the hospital and all...

Mannat ko to bhi criticize kiya na maine... she stopped revealing about ONS because Vik had already decided to divorce Malla .... thats stupid...

But unless you missed the conversation... everybody wishes Mannat would reveal him the truth and erase his guilt...

Thats the inconsistency in writing ... and its in Mannat and Vikrant both

Lets not call anyone biased... and defend our favourites... its the writers and editors who are doing this... we dont have any control...

He was just trying to calm her down ..that was his role at that time ..

Let’s see how the story is taken forward ..

Of course ppl have their favourites and it’s okay for everyone to defend theirs

We are here to enjoy but at leats manvik is common factor that binds us