Originally posted by: monsoon_barsha
I think it wasn't intended to be like that and that would have made a more compelling story, but looks like they took the easy way out. Jaya had even mentioned that her character was grey-shaded, and if you remember, even post-fire track when BM went to the Zaveris to confront Smita Smita looked guilty. All that vanished with sniper track and then after recent track when Smita visited Randhawas she threatened BM and made it look like BM was the main culprit.
It's lazy writing and such a shame because we had two fantastic actors who would have pulled off any shade of grey offered to them.
BM was suppose to be gray shaded who would eventually accept Prarthana.
Smitha was suppose to be negative along with Payal in beginning. But that was for Prarthana and Raunak story. They try to keep them negative for PraShiv for messing with Smitha but I think it did not work nor did it made sense. With Smitha being the one who abandoned Shivansh.
But Shivansh entry changed everything.
I think they may not show BM completely negative . It seems to me BM might be involved in PraShiv Separation but I don’t think she is involved in getting Prarthana car hampered. Unless she was?
They may keep her Gray but we cannot say anything. I was just speculating that she was involved in separating Shivansh parents. But they need to good reason to show why Smitha left.
Also lead to Smitha-Shivansh reunion.
Coming to Shivansh dad.
He did seem to love Smitha and maybe he dealing with a broken heart or regret of not trusting her or letting Smita go and not fighting for them.
As he told Shivansh don’t hate your mom and she left because of me.
BM turned it on Smitha saying she left for a richer man . But if watch 41st Zaveri jewelry inauguration scene Kanti said his dad started from scratch at age 40.
Kanti, his Brother mostly and Smitha worked hard from just one shop and now they inaugurating 41st jewelry shop.
So it’s obvious she did not leave for money.
but when Shivansh was young they were also middle class.
And whenever Prarthana was trying to talk about Shivansh with Smitha . Smitha kept referring her as a bade ghar ki bahu .
when Smitha was trying to make Raunak understand she was talking about how when you love someone but they get taken away. When marriage breaks it’s breaks you too. She still dealing with broken wounds from her past marriage and she still cares for Shivansh dad. I am not sure if she knows he died.
Her conversation to BM
First one you don’t know what happened between us
Then second one last time I was weak last time but now I am not. You dealt from inside and I will deal from outside . Something about being mother dialogue.
Also when she learned Shivansh is her son she was sad at reception and in the dark in her bedroom she upset because she knew why he was mad at her.
Also she does not want to share her past with Zaveris
But Zaveris know about Smitha past maybe she had a son from ex-husband
Possibly She brought up Kanti s son as her own and loves him unconditionally so Zaveri respects her and admire her. Sneha felt she was adopted. She maybe Randhawa.
Smitha backstory can go many ways.
she left because people were doubting her character as she was working night shifts. She was hurt and left for her dignity and refused to come back to him.
Randhawas were picking on the Meek and weak Smitha.
BM use to her brothers center of attention till Smitha came and BM was a control freak so she created misunderstanding and she left because he always sided with his sister and when he realized the truth She refuse to come back to him.
Or BM played a big game
or Smitha just left for money
initially I thought she left on her own for her own selfish reason but her flashbacks say a different story.
she is guilty of leaving Shivansh . It could be she lost custody or she did not try to come get him because she did not want to loose her second child to Randhawas.
Let’s see what they show as Smitha story.
Also BM said you left your family for this second family.
From inside there’s a voice saying if there is someone else beside Shivansh they should have done what Shivansh is doing.
BM does not know about Sneha exist till date and nor has Shivansh’s told her about Sneha.
but yesterday’s and today’s she is fully a vamp who does not care about Shivansh or his feelings at all . She doesn’t love him at all
Edited by Nikvi29 - a day ago
1.5k