Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 17 - Page 42

Originally posted by: Aadi04

I would be happy if she slaps him publicly and calls him out for being a creep and no less than Bobby saluja ..

if she had said all this in Chunri falling time .. that you are publicly getting engaged to mallika , your mother is accusing me of being a gold digger while like a pervert you are pestering me for a relationship..

and if she does it infront of Shalini . Calling Vikrant exactly Bobby saluja’s nephew .. it would have been perfect

rich people playing masquerades

I know Vikrant is crazy and acting dumb but don't want him to get slapped 😭. Just want him to get his brain back and acknowledge this was not a good idea. Out of all the junk out there, this maybe the only junk where I can still feel for the leads and don't want physical harm

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

I find it hard to put fault on Mannat considering how she is treated by the Salujas and how Vikrant is now marrying her friend. Focusing only on the ARS saga is probably also a copying mechanism. What good will it do for her trying to focus on what Vikrant means to her when he is no longer available. Crying buckets over a guy who is marrying her best friend? His mum has named her a gold digger after her son then she goes and confesses to Vikrant? I'm actually glad she has something to focus on other than her love story with Vikrant. He needs to clear the mess he has created. It was already going to be a challenge to get accepted into that family without him adding the drama of her stealing her friend's man. Mannat was ready to acknowledge her feelings when he was unconscious after the cake fiasco. It was all in her dialogue when she was speaking to him in his unconscious state. All the marriage functions he is having her prepare would be heart-breaking for her and she is finding ways to cope.

I think what probably would have made you happy as a viewer is if her love realisation is shown upfront even without acknowledging to Vikrant and then she is shown to be choosing to focus on the ARS drama whilst her feelings are made clear. It was a frustration for me at first but i'm now preferring it this way. I wouldn't have wanted her to have a mental breakdown. She is already dealing with a lot. Also there was no time for her to react to anything. Vikrant proposes and immediately tells her she is responsible for all the marriage function preparations. I think for myself in such a situation in order to cope i would get into self preservation mode. And the occasional tears that are pouring out is what shows that as much as she is trying to shield her heart from pain it's not foolproof from the aches. Maybe the actual breakdown would come when he actually gets married (though we know it won't get to that). She is probably going through stages of grief. lol and is in denial about what's happening. I have to admit though that there is an element of it being odd how she is acting and responding to what's happening but it's kind of hard to name it.

With due respect agree to disagree.

See I never said Mannat is wrong. She is completely right at her place and even Vikrant also. They both are right at their places. There is nothing wrong to expect acknowledgment from a girl you love and here Vikrant is doing that only. I know that this plan was doomed from the beginning but for him this was one way and went with it.

Mannat also right at her place because as per POV he is engaged to her best friend and how can she betray her friend when she promised her the same?
See I always wanted Mannat to fall in love first and acknowledge it but sadly it didn’t happen 😢💔. It’s my personal POV . I love when girl falls in love first. Anyways yes but I do want her to introspect her feelings sometimes without ARS on her mind. Same goes for Vikrant I want his introspection also that he is feeling bad for doing this to her and he should do something about it. He should come up with some definitive plan to convince Mannat and his family specially his Mom.
He should acknowledge her concerns also specially regarding his health.

Agree about Vikrant that he should clean this mess that’s what we all want right ?

😜

❤️🤗

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I know Vikrant is crazy and acting dumb but don't want him to get slapped 😭. Just want him to get his brain back and acknowledge this was not a good idea. Out of all the junk out there, this maybe the only junk where I can still feel for the leads and don't want physical harm

Me too...me too...and that's only because of Adnan...if it was anyone else I wouldn't have mind ...

Originally posted by: Resham

Me too...me too...and that's only because of Adnan...if it was anyone else I wouldn't have mind ...

Same pinch there buddy, Its unbelievable I feel bad for him after every episode in spite of him using this silly fake drama. I cannot get to hate this Pookie Vikrant and credit definitely goes to Adnan❤️

I feel his love is so pure the way he earnestly looks at Mannat yearning for her to accept him 😭😘 (it's twisted logic, par ITV is never sane ) + the drugs that his brain is not functioning as it should be.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I am a little confused about the discussion on why can't they show Mannat confessing first. Honestly, I am all for a girl confessing and find nothing wrong with this and would have cheered if Mannat confessed not letting Neetu's taunts take a decision for her.

But in this situation, I am confused since we know what Vikrant has landed himself and Mannat into, what Malla asked from Mannat, Mannat even wanted to clarify with Vikrant if he loves Malla.

Even if Mannat loves Vikrant why are we expecting she confessess if the guy she thought liked him suddenly proposed to her bestie 🤔. Don't you think from Mannat's perspective Vikrant is 2 timing though she is not saying this yet 😬 (we as audience know he is not 2 timing but Mannat is not aware) . And then there is the elephant in the room 'Trust' which is not addressed yet.

At the moment I see Mannat trying to build tallest walls around herself and focus on ARS so this marriage doesn't hurt her, this is what I am seeing from her dance and cold attitude towards Vikrant. In the past too she was surrounded by pain, sorrow, was spying on ARS, recently Neetu , but she was never this cold or distant with Vikrant. But now she is hurting herself by hurting Vikrant and you can see the pain in the last episode when she talks about who is in his kismat😭.

I feel bad for both of them with what they landed themselves into and little more mad at Vikrant for kick starting this domino effect and pushing her into this when she was in such a sensitive state of mind 😭

At this point for either one of them to confess the only way I see is a major accident or their life is in danger or some other shock. Or go straight to wedding, Vikrant might misunderstand Mannat (since the medicine swap BTS came I am thinking about this ) that she is drugging him and force her to marry him or bride swap like we discussed and leave the confession out for now 🙈

Bhai atp idc what they do. If these writers keep on giving badhia romanch along with semi-sane leads, I’m more than happy. I’m watching the show to take a break from real life, not to add more stress to it

Given the toxicity other ITV shows are churning, I’m glad the show is still one of the saner ones.

https://x.com/_silent_eyez/status/1932029555595685954?t=-bDJWvkRI18CkiX97aJHkA&s=19

Watch this...Kasauti zindagi ki title song on them..well edited...

Sorry doubly posted the above

Originally posted by: Resham

https://x.com/_silent_eyez/status/1932029555595685954?t=-bDJWvkRI18CkiX97aJHkA&s=19

Watch this...Kasauti zindagi ki title song on them..well edited...

It's so cute.

I used to watch KZK but when Prerna married to Mr. Bajaj I stopped watching it. I was so mad at EK.

She has tendency to ruin all her pairs 🤬

Thanks for tagging me🤗

https://x.com/artnesbur/status/1931862439923966298?s=46

The finger to lips is just so intimate every single times

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

@bold, I am with you in this, even I didn't felt odd,

@red.... Also when vikranth said Kya ho saktha hai Kya hai vo chodo, tumhare dil mei Kya hai vo bolo.... I really felt this is want he meant.... He wants to know why mannath is feeling sad and all .. I really liked it....

Hmm.... Sometimes I really doubt mannath even if she don't realize, we know she loves him.... That guy is about to get married, but she is sad when she sees him with someone but after that she even don't think about him , just go around ars.... If at all this drama , will mannath ever realize her love for vikranth..... I mean yes vikranth can say I live you... But realizing your true love by yourself and accepting the proposal from a boy you are comfortable with are two completely different things ....

So I am really wondering if not for this drama, would mannath ever accepted her feelings, what are your thoughts....

I still say vikranth is true gentlemen, I did say aise tracks in so many shows... How patiently vikranth asks mannath to analyze her feelings is so new.... I know I am carrying away by adnan acting but vikranth is 😘 😘 😘

My 1st point : vikranth finding no in every yes....

Even I am today's women who believes in women "no" is a "no" but at the same time as a girl/women I also no this ,girls do say no sometimes but they want the other person to manav her, we do expect husband/boyfriend find hidden yes in our no. So when the person you like try to find that yes ,that situation turns out to be sweet but some do take disadvantage of it .So when do this cute little things turns to something horrible.. when force comes into picture.... When we say no and someone forces it in very wrong way...they that is harrasment....

Here when I said vikranth no wala dialogue odd nahi laga , I mean he is not forcing mannath, yes he is trying her and keep asking her to tell what she is feeling but still he is maintaining his dignity...we all need to agree that mannath is getting effected with this drama and it is visible... So when vikranth said tumhare har no mei yes dooondlunga, I felt he mean along mannath no from her mouth , he can also see her teary eyes which is screaming love for him.....

Uff no yes no yes karthe karthe tak gayi hooo....

Now point 2: most discussed point.... Before writing thing comment I re-read my comment twice . I didn't read my discussion because I am in vacation... So I will put only my pov.... I never said mannath should propose first.. the explanation I gave above is from vikranth pov... He can see she is getting effected, he is trying to get the answer why is it effecting... Infact I felt more than answer he is trying to get her think .... Usually these kind of dialogue " why is it effecting you, why are you feeling like this" are given to friend of ml/fl in itv .. they are the one who tries to make ml/fl realize in this kind of situation... And both ml and fl will be tashan of if you don't care I won't care kind.. but here it is vikranth who is trying to make her realize

At the same time I agree that how can mannath propose first when this idiot proposed her best friend.... That's why I never expected proposal from her but I am surprised other than infront of vikranth she is not even thinking about him, her mind is completely around ars... She is not even thinking to herself why she is sad only because her boss is engaged to her bf... Why is she not dance karne wala happy for her bf .... Why?? Is the question she is not even asking for herself ....

Yes as @moor mentioned she is in a place where she accepts his proposal before all this marriage drama...

But again my question

Is accepting the proposal from person who you like /feel comfortable with is same as realizing the eternal love for a person????

So that's why I feel she is in a place to accept his proposal but definitely didn't realize her love for him.... For that she definitely needs a jolt....

Again definitely not official marriage proposal,yeh tho humara kaand king ka very flop plan tha... If he really want to jealousyfy her, he could have did all this planning without including family and all these stupid functions......

..