Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 16 - Page 11

Originally posted by: Moor278

It has to happen for drugs... my assumption is that they have swapped drugging with kidnap as Neetu doesnt have reasons like OG to kidnap Mannat.

Originally posted by: Moor278

It has to happen for drugs... my assumption is that they have swapped drugging with kidnap as Neetu doesnt have reasons like OG to kidnap Mannat.

Is show Mein kisiko reason chaahiye to hate Mannat

Originally posted by: Rdigest

I like this idea actually, this way Aman track can happen in future.

My only thing, he cannot go through this engagement in a public platform and then call it fake. This is my only fear , lost kaa PTSD waapis AA Raha hain where I thought something will never happen and it happened

Bold... agreed..

This way Amans truth can be delayed and more drama can be added in its place...

Lost ka PTSD works in weird ways... It has toughened me up for Vikrants shenanigans 🤪 yet can't help but compare

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I am with you. I felt terrible for Mannat. She doesn't have any support. Vikrant is giving her mixed signals, right from Anu's engagement time. She knows they are more than friends. And about bharosa, she wants him to take her words seriously. He is taking her words seriously but admits it to Malla.... Watching him confide in Malla gives me PTSD palpitations.

Now if he is going to be sitting on a dais with Malla... God help him. If Malla is his best friend, she is also Mannat's best friend. How is Mannat supposed to imagine this is all fake when he has done it in front of his family? And very obviously his family is happy.

Even if she gets a doubt, looks like he is covering his tracks, or Malla is...itna lamba khichne ki kya zaroorat hai?

Word, When did Malla suddenly become his bestie who he confides in 🙄.

I don't have a problem with fake drama as long as he doesn't sit there and silently get engaged since Mannat didn't stop him. I am hoping they salvage this. Seeing the BTS of engagement dias is

Per Ayesha's interview she doubts this is fake so she calls to see if he was indeed talking to Malla and finds his phone to be busy

Hope yeh itnaa naa keenche kee Mannat will not forgive him nor trust when he says this was fake.

@bettyscar - so true about the public proposal 2 days after all the name calling and her walking out. Why or how would she accept the proposal without anything being clarified

thank you Moor, Trupti,Deepa, Saichin, Scarlett and others for your great reviews…… just watched the episode and really loved everything…… up to Vikrant clasping his fingers around MALLA’s hand!

He was looking directly at Maanat and his speech was to her, held out his hand while looking into Mannat’s eyes, so was he expecting Mannat to hold out her hand and accept to marry him, or knew she wouldn’t and had planned will Malla that she would instead ???

What did he mean by he’s going to have to shock her?

I think I have to re-read your reviews/rewatch the episode because I’m as confused as Ronnie obviously was🥺

Originally posted by: Moor278

Bold... agreed..

This way Amans truth can be delayed and more drama can be added in its place...

Lost ka PTSD works in weird ways... It has toughened me up for Vikrants shenanigans 🤪 yet can't help but compare

Plus in lost land may be due story or actors or direction.... But seeing ml... I used to get creepy cringe irritating feeling.... Disgust watching it....

But here I do get angry on vikranth but not it negative level.... I feel angry and sad for him at same time....

I don't know how to put it .... I guess you will also agree that we don't get negative level angry on vikranth compared to lost land

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

haha it's ok yaar .. we have different pov.... I do felt bad for mannath especially when she is crying in new BTS .. also during her rant about saluja's... That's why still wondering why is he even not trying to explain her....

But I also felt he did waited for her yes and felt bad for him....

But don't worry I am still board to through chapals at him whenever mannath cries .

Arye nahee Yaar no need to throw chappals, this whole track the way it's shaping looks like an after thought and written haphazardly. They were going for Anu's marriage for sure , else why all of Mannat's drama to convince them and Mannat taking the promise to not tell his family🤔.

Suddenly Vikrant not only wants to confess par Mannat has to accept Everything's he told Malla who is not even his friend, why couldn't he say this to Mannat whom he loves

Who ever is writing this has given send off to their brain along with Vikram Naaz

Originally posted by: Saichintalli

@bold mee too

Plus in lost land may be due story or actors or direction.... But seeing ml... I used to get creepy cringe irritating feeling.... Disgust watching it....

But here I do get angry on vikranth but not it negative level.... I feel angry and sad for him at same time....

I don't know how to put it .... I guess you will also agree that we don't get negative level angry on vikranth compared to lost land

I totally get what you mean about Vikrant. You can't hate him with the earnest way it's being played.

After hearing the IV's of Ayesha and Adnan, I honestly feel the new director is unable to to bring out the story which these 2 are understanding

Hopefully he picks up the story nuances and not just focus on showing some random romance scenes

Originally posted by: Moor278

Aajao sab yaha pe...

Let's start with Vikku ka pan pitai

Like most others said... Vikku bewakoof but Adnan usko pookie banata hai ki gussa bhi nahi kar sakte.

It starts with Malla Vikrant convo where she wants to talk about the idea of their marriage. Vik is little worried but Malla tells him she doesn't want to get married to him. He is extremely relieved that its still the same.

She first tries to convince Vik on how badly Mannat treated him. He is not at all ready to accept. He thinks about all Mannat said... how much she did for Shalini knowing her job is at stake.. and now she is saying this for Neetu ... who he doesn't think is right but neither wrong. He thinks they (Raisinghs and Salujas) are missing something. Neetu has behaved wrongly with Mannat but she respects elders.. has never said bad about Neetu.. takes everything gracefully. That's how Mannat is.. (fondly talking about her with a smile)

Malla is livid... she is not happy that her words have no effect on Vik.. so her plan B is to suggest marriage

I found it hilarious that Malla thinks saying few bad words for Mannat will turn Viks opinion .. such a dumb girl she is..

Anyway... Vik is confused why is Malla not replying .. Malla tells him you are right... Mannat is a human afterall... all of our family members treat her badly... Puneet treats her like peon.. I was rude to her... its not vocalised but implied by Malla that Mannat has wrong impression about the RS family because their bad treatment to her.

This section ends ... the proposal idea which we saw in BTS might come as flashback.

RoTu convo where Ro is upset still... Neetu comes in and wants patchup. She asks him to transfer all property in Vikrants name since Raveena hates Vik and if something happens to them Raveena won't give anything to Vikku. Resolve matters now.

Ronnie is upset again... he says I won't fall prey to your stupid ideas. First you ask him to marry a girl he doesn't even love and now this... I won't do this.. and Puneet has equal rights on property...

Neetu tries again but Ronnie is not accepting the plan.

Scene moves to Mezbani where Derek wants Mannat to be careful as she has taken panga with Puneet. Mannat is upset and starts venting. Vikrant hears the few bits which is exactly what Malla implied. That the RS family is after her life... she won't care for them anymore. Doesn't like them.

He thinks Mannat hates his family 🤦‍♀️ and if he proposes now.. she won't accept. He needs to give a shock to her (Did you write this dialogue Saichin??? 😉)..

He comes in and asks her why are you here... I thought you dont like anything about me or here. Mannat says its my haq.

Vik asks Derek to prep for evening party where his family would be coming.

He stops Mannat and tells her he will get whatever is in his haq by tonight.

At the party everyone is anxious... Gagan is relieved when he hears Puneet call Mannat.. thinks his plan can still work. Ronnie is happy Mannat didnt leave.

Proposal scene happens... I loved the writing so much.. it always happens with ARSs dialougues... it happened with Vik today. They are meant for other person but always fit with what Mannat is going through. 😍

He declares his feelings in a very beautiful soft mushy kind of love... all his words are replies to Mannats questions about class difference... mel nahi hai... but how life chooses 2 people together... that they are meant to be etc etc.... delivered in a most earnest way by Vikrant/Adnan ♥️♥️♥️♥️

Another aspect of this is... since Malla knows... what he delivers (for the rest of the family) is for Malla... but Malla is massively pissed knowing none of this is for her... 😂😂😂

Sukoon I tell you 🙏🙏🙏

He extends his hand and Mannats hands show the hesitation... subtle movements in her fingers... but since she doesn't move... Malla extends her hands... shocking Mannat... Vik has not looked at Malla once throughout... he is only gauging Mannats reaction. Has not moved his eyes from her...

The change of emotions everyone has is so nicely done... initially Ronnie Gagan are happy Vik chose Mannat... ARS Neetu are upset. Punnu is shocked.

When Malla extends her hand... the expressions flips... Punnu goes into further shock 😆😆😆 (@Meera... pineapple Puneet dikha 😜)

Ronnie Gagan are not at all happy with this while ARS Neetu are delirious 🤦‍♀️

My perception after seeing the episode and Vikrants dialogue about getting his haq tonight is...

That probably the proposal was meant to be a on off event... as in he probably expected Mannat to say yes or accept him... but since she took time and Malla immediately jumped in... they have to now carry it forward 😂😂😂😂...

I hope I am right 😭😭😭😭 ... Vikku ne Malla ka harebrained idea jo sunn liya hai... uska aisa hi kuch stupid logic ho sakta hai... 😝😝😝

It was not meant to be taken ahead... but ab karna padega... I am assuming Malla aisa kuch vahiyat reason degi. 🤦‍♀️

Loved Ayesha so much today... her range of emotions at Vikrants words was so skillfully done... Mannat wanted to go ahead and take his hand... but the hesitation and rationality stopped her... Ayesha was brilliant without dialogues while Adnan used his skills in voice modulation to deliver a beautiful beautiful proposal...

Just me or Vikku choked when he finally asked her to marry him????? 😍😍😍😍

Bold - he didn’t say Mannat’s name but he was expecting her to accept? …… or hoping she would.

Then why didn’t Vikrant flicker even for a split second and closed his fingers over Malla’s hand?

(understandably) Mannat was processing what he had just said so publicly and think was very hesitantly going to take his hand - but Malla quickly did instead.

its baffling, they show Vikrant being nervous not to hurt Malla’s feelings at the start of the episode but then oblivious of the emotions Mannat, the love of his life must have felt at that moment, if, as he suspects she loves him too!