Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 7 - Page 68

Originally posted by: Uma85

I think somewhere Vik has realised his tadap for Mannat and just doesn't know how to make her understand that :) the subtle reaction after her question was more like " WTH , why is she not getting my hint " types :-D

Yes, him looking up in frustration was so well done considering the situation they were in.

Also, Vikrant is very aware of the surroundings and the reason why he didn't hug her, atleast this is what I felt when he held her, trying to calm her down and looking around before holding her more closely.

Ok - so I watched the ep - ff few annoying dialogues but did.

I am extremely disappointed with writing-

1. The focus is completely on Shalini’s choice. Even Vikrant emphasized on it- ARS already manipulated her, and she will choose not to complain? so Is this why Vikrant be angry at Mannat? I SERIOUSLY HOPE NOT! I hope they are undercover team.

2. The dialogues and execution are so shallow!
Shalini ko kaisa legega, kya lagega- are bhai- a crime happened on the premises of your business, you need to find culprit so this does not happen again! Talk about regardless of what she thinks you cant let such people loose or they will attack someone else!!! I was hoping that is what Vikrant will point with late night cleaning work- they dont want complaint, culprit is free- Mannat and Shalini wont choose to work kate, Malla should, and then point- what if this happened to Malla? But the discussion took turn to Shalini’s choice!!!

3. So many FB scenes of SA! Why? We got it- Mannat was telling her encounter - we rem. Bar bar chalane ki jarurat nahi. So triggering!
What a insensitive approach!

4. The while dialogue about why Mannat, forever etc- even though it was cute but I found it to be a misfit, just considering severity of situation. I wish they brought this scene into some other track- here we are listening emotional reencounter of two SA attempts with FB scenes and thats the time director/writer thought is good for this scene????

They really need to improve on editing- feels like we jump from one scene to another randomly.

Vikrant getting into boss mode is amazing 🤩. Want to see more of this in this track and in future.

Adnan should honestly play the role of Don in his next outing. He is brilliant when he is angry and shows everyone their rightful place.

All of them were awesome today… I really good realistic episode..

Ayesha is rocking each emotion so well.

Adnan was awesome! The sarcastic way of putting Malla on spot…. The fear when Mannat was narrating the incident that happened to her… the diversion from the question when Mannat asked why? …. The disbelief when Mannat didn’t pickup the praise he was showering.

Shalini was so broken poor girl was perhaps manipulated by ARS…

poor Derek he is in for some serious punishment

The execution was crisp without any over the top acting and background music

PS: they definitely have thought things through.. connecting Mannat assault with Shalini…/derek cleaning up will probably be linked as well

Looks good. Will watch in sometime

I thing they perhaps missed is that normally until the police has spoken to victim no one can actually see them. Oh well … iTV hai

Originally posted by: KarwaChothThali

Ok - so I watched the ep - ff few annoying dialogues but did.

I am extremely disappointed with writing-

1. The focus is completely on Shalini’s choice. Even Vikrant emphasized on it- ARS already manipulated her, and she will choose not to complain? so Is this why Vikrant be angry at Mannat? I SERIOUSLY HOPE NOT! I hope they are undercover team.

2. The dialogues and execution are so shallow!
Shalini ko kaisa legega, kya lagega- are bhai- a crime happened on the premises of your business, you need to find culprit so this does not happen again! Talk about regardless of what she thinks you cant let such people loose or they will attack someone else!!! I was hoping that is what Vikrant will point with late night cleaning work- they dont want complaint, culprit is free- Mannat and Shalini wont choose to work kate, Malla should, and then point- what if this happened to Malla? But the discussion took turn to Shalini’s choice!!!

3. So many FB scenes of SA! Why? We got it- Mannat was telling her encounter - we rem. Bar bar chalane ki jarurat nahi. So triggering!
What a insensitive approach!

4. The while dialogue about why Mannat, forever etc- even though it was cute but I found it to be a misfit, just considering severity of situation. I wish they brought this scene into some other track- here we are listening emotional reencounter of two SA attempts with FB scenes and thats the time director/writer thought is good for this scene????

They really need to improve on editing- feels like we jump from one scene to another randomly.

Promo is more of a gist and I will wait for the episodes to see why and what made Vikrant angry.

The scene of Malla cleaning, have a different perspective. Vikrant was shocked, trying to process and all the three were yapping, Mannat talking about justice followed by Malla's dialogue of I am your best friend so let's cover up, this kind of triggered him and he wanted to make a point since he knows Malla is shallow.

I wrote about why the reaction and his dialogues, let me tag you.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Vikrant's anger ( Adnan was so good here) and his dialogues immediately after when Mannat said she could have been in the same situation as Shalini shows how much he cares for Mannat😍 and his fear of anything happening to Mannat

This is why I felt his dialogues were aligned since it scared him the moment Mannat imagined herself in Shalini's place

What does he say in his mini proposal?

I am very sure Mannat has already understood that ARS is influencing Shalini. Vikrant and Mannat went in the room first then came ARS… but ARS without listening to anything directly said that see Shalini doesn’t want police case…. this is similar to the bracelet incident where Mannat knew Raveena was lying.

I felt Mannat has caught on that ARS is lying