Jhanak Written Update And Episode Discussion thread No 89 - Page 132

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Haan...family will realise J's worth...but given the show's pace, it will take a long time to happen...my concern is show will go off air before reaching that stage if makers stay adamant on keeping Arshi in between Runak for longer period of time...ye zimmedari vs pyar trope can be tolerated till a point...and I think for viewers, the breaking point is approaching...

And coming to Arshi...nothing, I repeat, nothing can portray her as a victim after what she did with Ani! If makers think that ye Rona dhona karwake they can create sympathy for her, it's their delusion...if they really want to reduce poison in viewers' minds for Arshi, they need to undo the violation act...other than that nothing can make viewers see her as victim atp and in future as well...

My hunch is, just like in HA track Ani realised Arshi's inhumanity and lack of empathy and love for him, the last trace of guilt and the belief that Arshi is good soul will also vanish from his mind...and given viewers response towards Anishit, it will happen sooner than the time taken for Ani to realise the former between aag track and HA track..

Ani is the biggest flip flopper in all this. He wants Jhanak but at the same time does not want to hurt Arshi and be responsible for her. Everytime he asks Arshi to leave and comes to their room ad asks her to stay. His take is even though he loves J, he is prepared to stay with Arshi out of commitment, but J's life risk is what is pushing him over the edge to marry her and break his commitment to Arshi. That is a wimpish route to take and a big excuse. He wants to stay married to Arshi while having the license to emotionally cheat with J and take care of her. What woman will agree to it. This whole track is to white wash Arshi and give Ani a reason to betray Arshi, while J becomes again the victim. Bodoma and Jettu are right. Ani will never be able to be happy with J after disregarding his family. He will take it out on J. Unless Runak marriage happend witb Arshi's blessings Runak will never be happy. Runak getting marries now goes against everything they both have said to date.

Ani may end up realizing Arshi is evil but story will be shown in such a way that Ani drove her to it.

Yesterday in hall Ani said Arshi tries to control him but could not suceed and J loves him. Afetr insuting her thus is open he wants to come and explain to her in private. The guy is cuckoo. Ani has to first decide whether Arshi is achi ladki or not. if achi he cannot throw her under the bus, like he does. The guy has bipolar disorder for sure. The show is not unpleasant because of Arshi. She is the vamp/PL, she will be up to nasty stuff. Ani is what is causing the viewers displeasure and this feeling of unsatisfaction with the show. He is not staying on one message.

Originally posted by: xnbstar

@bold I would say that Runak are destined to be together, no matter what unwanted circumstances they have faced in their lives.

This "if" and "else" condition is merely an excuse to satisfy their hearts. Ani fell for Jhanak because of her caring, loving and beautiful personality unlike any responsibility factor.

Arshi's disapproval only provided him with a significant chance to spend more time and fall harder and deeper for Jhanak, an attraction rooted in their Kashmir days.

I wrote for them a few months ago summarizing their relationship:

............

Rab ne to inko milaya hai, 💥

Dil ke bandhan me samaya hai, ❤️

Phir pyaar ki aag me jalaya hai, 🔥

Lakar inko toofan me thamaya hai, 💔

Phir mohabbat ka raah se guzara hai! ✨️

Arshi threw out a lot of truths yesterday. Ani fell for J the moment he saw her in Kashmir. The rest is bullshit - he has always been lying to himself and others.

On one hand he wants her and feels becahin without her, and other he is only marrying her to keep her safe?? What the hell! Pick one!

Originally posted by: PPak

Arshi threw out a lot of truths yesterday. Ani fell for J the moment he saw her in Kashmir. The rest is bullshit - he has always been lying to himself and others.

On one hand he wants her and feels becahin without her, and other he is only marrying her to keep her safe?? What the hell! Pick one!

I knew this since their bike accident!

It was indeed love / attraction at first sight.

Makers ne story ko bahut ziada kharab kardya hai. Kab tak Ani ko dual-meaning dialogues deyngy after letting him said that he decided his naav.

Originally posted by: xnbstar

@bold someone said right:

Ye duniya kisi ki bhi nahi hai!

Waqt aur insaan dono badal hi jatey hain!

Bodoma was the who insisted Jhanak multiple times to consider her feelings and relationship with Anirudh. Ek dafa to kitchen me bhi itna bara lecture diya tha regarding that.

I understand their way of perceiving things is not completely wrong, but still it is not practical in this situation.

Hence proved iss show me negative ya positive characters ki koi value nahi.

Kabhi bhi koi bhi kisi waqt me palat jata hai!

I see Badima's pov.

J does not have support of Tammi, Tanuja, Shubo, Bipasha, Laal, her sister Arshi. And Ani is planning to live in BH. This relationship has zero chance of success, only insults and curses. Ani deceived the entire famiy with his acceptance of his marriage with Arshi. He begs her to stay - even when J said she was pregnant, he was distraught and repeatedly begged Arshi to stay. When J was supposedly dead, he asked her not to leave him. Now boldly he is saying they are not married. J herself has always called Arshi Ani's wife.

To now get married - they will be proving everyone right till now. Thats ok if one has to prioritize ones happiness and sanity, but then neither should be looking to also consider Arshi's feelings and keep piling guilt.

Originally posted by: xnbstar

I knew this since their bike accident!

It was indeed love / attraction at first sight.

Makers ne story ko bahut ziada kharab kardya hai. Kab tak Ani ko dual-meaning dialogues deyngy after letting him said that he decided his naav.

With the excuse of keeping her safe, he will continue his lie, justify to himself that its for her own life, she stay and be with him while he keeps Arshi as mother of his child in the same house.

Even though he fell for her from day one - they will never show him going after her voluntarily, neither will she go to him. Lousy love story

Originally posted by: Dibya_C

Please don't watch tomorrow episode! It will be vidai based only! BTS aye hai kuchh yt me! 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

Originally posted by: PPak

I see Badima's pov.

J does not have support of Tammi, Tanuja, Shubo, Bipasha, Laal, her sister Arshi. And Ani is planning to live in BH. This relationship has zero chance of success, only insults and curses. Ani deceived the entire famiy with his acceptance of his marriage with Arshi. He begs her to stay - even when J said she was pregnant, he was distraught and repeatedly begged Arshi to stay. When J was supposedly dead, he asked her not to leave him. Now boldly he is saying they are not married. J herself has always called Arshi Ani's wife.

To now get married - they will be proving everyone right till now. Thats ok if one has to prioritize ones happiness and sanity, but then neither should be looking to also consider Arshi's feelings and keep piling guilt.

To be honest, the writing is extremely vague and inconsistent to be discussed thoroughly.

Each day's episode presents a changing narrative. Jhanak initially wanted Ani to accept her in front of Bh before signing the annulment, but now she has flipped, using the "homewrecker" tag.

Most significantly, she accepted his love during the Kashmir night and was assured about his promises and acceptance, but later, a lack of communication and misunderstandings resulted in their annulment.

Where was the "homewrecker" tag then? She clearly told Adi that she could not live happily married to Ani because of her illegitimate child, but now, where does this "homewrecker" tag come from?

I would say the writer's narrative has been completely altered. If RuNak wholeheartedly accepted each other, where would Arshi go? So, they contrived this "homewrecker" tag excuse to separate RuNak as long as possible.

Jhanak needs to be brave, practical, and strong now. Anirudh is at least putting maximum effort into improving their relationship, even though most of his actions are still impractical, wheras Jhanak's decision-making is completely ineffectual.

Originally posted by: PPak

I see Badima's pov.

J does not have support of Tammi, Tanuja, Shubo, Bipasha, Laal, her sister Arshi. And Ani is planning to live in BH. This relationship has zero chance of success, only insults and curses. Ani deceived the entire famiy with his acceptance of his marriage with Arshi. He begs her to stay - even when J said she was pregnant, he was distraught and repeatedly begged Arshi to stay. When J was supposedly dead, he asked her not to leave him. Now boldly he is saying they are not married. J herself has always called Arshi Ani's wife.

To now get married - they will be proving everyone right till now. Thats ok if one has to prioritize ones happiness and sanity, but then neither should be looking to also consider Arshi's feelings and keep piling guilt.

To say that don’t do this cos it’s not worth your sanity at a time when Ani and Arshi are together makes absolute sense.. but during that entire period they propped her up and her affection for Ani as the gold standard but the moment when it actually makes sense for them support Ani and J…when the guy ( chalo in your books he hasn’t meant i) talked of ending a comatose relationship… B & J pulled back their support… If this isn’t expedient what is it? To only venerate her when she was sacrificial about her love and berate her when she expressed her desire for choosing a path of happiness with her loved one after Ani had proposed to her is the unkindest cut of all.. This is called betrayal of faith!!

I feel like yeh gif daily post karna padega yahaan pe

Originally posted by: sanfan

To say that don’t do this cos it’s not worth your sanity at a time when Ani and Arshi are together makes absolute sense.. but during that entire period they propped her up and her affection for Ani as the gold standard but the moment when it actually makes sense for them support Ani and J…when the guy ( chalo in your books he hasn’t meant i) talked of ending a comatose relationship… B & J pulled back their support… If this isn’t expedient what is it? To only venerate her when she was sacrificial about her love and berate her when she expressed her desire for choosing a path of happiness with her loved one after Ani had proposed to her is the unkindest cut of all.. This is called betrayal of faith!!

@bold: Rekha ji, I thought this kind of perspective was an outlier but then I took a gander about the forum.....it seems a strong Runak hating faction exists to which this scene was catering today .....there very much exist people who consider Jhanak homewrecker and enjoyed Bodoma-Jethu terming her so