𝓙𝓱𝓪𝓷𝓪𝓴 Written Update And Episode Discussion Thread 53 - Page 143

Originally posted by: PPak

While he has a duty towards Arshi, he also has a duty towards the girl he brought back home with an extracted promise. He knows J wont ask for her wife rights, he wants her to ask and he has said he remembers the marriage and asks her to ask for her haq. He knows she has no motive to kill Arshi. So why would he suspect her.

If he does suspect, he will not be ignoring her like this. The Ani I know and love wont do this.

Lets see if this is a different Ani than the one they showed so far.

Based on his dialogs it sounds like he has resigned himself to staying with Arshi because of his guilt, and wants to ensure J is safe by not focussing on her.

I'm still hoping Arshi will call off the wedding. Ani never will now.

Why you are saying like this? Has he decided to stay with Arshi?

Originally posted by: vira76

So he said mentioned arshi name … when he said sath nahi chodunga

This goes along with what I said about Ani’s traits … he is god of justice like jhanak is goddess of Mahanata. He meant every word he said. In his heart he feels pain for jhanak but his mind is asking him to do what’s right (according to him). He is not being able to ignore what Shristi said , that she saw something. Think this, if he can fight for a stranger girl so much , do we expect him to sit quietly for arshi who he was about to marry, and he has been her friend and had shared romantic relationship with. So in conclusion, his roar for justice is not limited trait to jhanak not it can apply to other people as well. Like it has been mentioned in the show many times by other characters “agar jhanak ki gaha koi aur hota , tab bhi ani wo hi karata ko usanae kiya hai” !

As far as him not completely trusting jhanak goes, he is extremely left brain guy. He seriously lacks emotional intelligence. That is why we saw so many rifts between jhanak and ani! As they both think differently. For anirudh it was strange for Shristi to involve police so recklessly without any proof. So he has been distant with Jhanak. Jhanak and us are have emotional intelligence. And jhanak is extremely right brained person , for her she takes this as anirudh didn’t trust me! Or didn’t even bother to ask me about what happened. So this is it. This is definitely a nail in the coffin for jhanak. Anirudh will not feel guilty about it as he still thinks he did what was right, let law handle it … But yes it’s stupid … how they are writing this and executing this. People will see this as character assassin. And to some degree it is. And it is also not… considering what both of these went through it’s hard to think they will go to this extreme to show how much ani cares for justice. Please don’t expect monologue saying he was acting … he was surely emotional and worried about jhanak but he was also worried for arshi. He didn’t want to be unfair to her because of his feelings if jhanak was even slightly guilty. Shristi , his parents everyone was blaming her … again he was standing in the middle with two opposite set of people. He always used “agar” … so he wanted jhanak to be proven not guilty! But until it’s proven he also didn’t want to trust her because he loves her and forgive her… so doing right comes above love for him… 🙏

Noo you are not wrong ...

Ani's concern for Arshi and Jhanak both is real...he is definitely worried for Arshi.. I also know blind trust is not his biggest strength....he simply goes by what his eyes see and what his mind comprehends....

But yesterday Ani also said Shrishti one thing.....

"Apke alawa aur kisi ne bhi Jhanak Ko Aisa karte hue nahi dekha...so hame proof ka intezaar karna chahiye.."

He doesn't trust Shrishti completely either...

Even if your assumptions is right Wheather they show monologue or not...but he is definitely torn between his guilt and love...He knows what is expected of him..he is expected to stand against Jhanak as it was his hone wali Biwi..in question...but he is not being able to do that from his heart ...so it multiplies the guilt....so in between all these mixed emotions he is making extra efforts to show everyone something that is not in his heart....

This is what I feel....

Originally posted by: Goddy2010

Why you are saying like this? Has he decided to stay with Arshi?

Originally posted by: Anu1515

@Bold this is just Us hoping for a better outcome and sometimes positive… not sure maker’s want to do the same🙊( No chappals please)

yes its mind vs heart again... but in ani's case always mind wins

and in the case of Jhanak always heart wins!

That is why she is letting Shristi go ...

His narebazi in the police station and extracting a promise from them, also means making sure police will do whats right... This means inherently he trusts J, and that is why he has the confidence to say this to the police, do your investigation the most truthful way. Because he has faith Jhanak will come out of this, if they do what's right. so in a way he was helping Jhanak by forcing police to do their work, telling them in a loud voice that he wanted justice and whoever the culprit needed to be punished, but this also implies if no one is culprit then they should not be punished as well ... Also want to make sure his father shubho does not find any roundabout way to incriminate J... Police are the only ones he can use as a shield against Shubho if he decides to file a case in court then it will be more messed up...

Again a very logical and smart way to use what's at his disposal...

We shall see how much we were right ...

Originally posted by: asmitamohanty

Noo you are not wrong ...

Ani's concern for Arshi and Jhanak both is real...he is definitely worried for Arshi.. I also know blind trust is not his biggest strength....he simply goes by what his eyes see and what his mind comprehends....

But yesterday Ani also said Shrishti one thing.....

"Apke alawa aur kisi ne bhi Jhanak Ko Aisa karte hue nahi dekha...so hame proof ka intezaar karna chahiye.."

He doesn't trust Shrishti completely either...

Even if your assumptions is right Wheather they show monologue or not...but he is definitely torn between his guilt and love...He knows what is expected of him..he is expected to stand against Jhanak as it was his hone wali Biwi..in question...but he is not being able to do that from his heart ...so it multiplies the guilt....so in between all these mixed emotions he is making extra efforts to show everyone something that is not in his heart....

This is what I feel....

Originally posted by: vira76

yes doubting will be wrong ... but lets say he does not want to stand in the way of arshi getting justice...

more like being unfair

I will have to see more closely on a good screen about this over acting part... i watched it very much in hurry...

Monologue ka expectation hai muze bhi so we know what is going through this guy's head... but at the same time i feel scared lol 😅... if they give him again some ghatiya mono!

To me, he loved Arshi before he developed feelings for J, but he still spoke against her in favor of J many times... so he is doing the same thing here..He loves J but he cannot be unfair to Arshi so he is speaking up...

it goes along with the character traits but it is freaking bitter medicine for us as its for Charsi and its working against Runak!! 🙅🏻‍♀️

But now that i have cleared my head about his char traits , i am not feeling as mad ... like i feel like i knew he will do this! I am just waiting for more episodes so i get to affirm my understanding

Okay even if let us assume that you are right...

Yes....for Ani if there is something that is more important than his love then it is his commitment and his need to be fair

I also understand that he did all this for Jhanak when he was in relationship and according to him in love with Arshi...so he is doing the same for Arshi... when he is in love with Jhanak....

The point here is he was about to marry Arshi...a choice that he had made regardless of the circumstances....and he deeply cares about her as well...

But this time he himself is torn... even if there is no complete trust according to you...there is no complete mistrust either..

He is still trying to be what is expected out of him, something that seems right but does not feel right....yet he is not being able to do that...He is not being able to doubt her....

I think he definitely trusts her....

He is acting weired... I don't know if it was deliberate attempt to confuse us but one thing is clear it is definitely gonna cause a huge misunderstanding...as there would be no reason for her to stay...

She herself had said..." Jis din Mujhe lagega meri self-respect Ko thes pohonch Rahi hai main Chali jaungi..." It is that point for her...

He did not cancel his wedding with Arshi at that moment...so he is suffering bcz of that now... whatever be the case...

Let's see what are we going to get...

But I would be happy if they give him a monologue that he is pretending.... I don't think Aniruddh's character deserves that ..

The Ani I love won't doubt Jhanak of killing someone....

I believe he is pretending...and putting up a performance...

Let's see...

Originally posted by: PPak

While he has a duty towards Arshi, he also has a duty towards the girl he brought back home with an extracted promise. He knows J wont ask for her wife rights, he wants her to ask and he has said he remembers the marriage and asks her to ask for her haq. He knows she has no motive to kill Arshi. So why would he suspect her.

If he does suspect, he will not be ignoring her like this. The Ani I know and love wont do this.

Lets see if this is a different Ani than the one they showed so far.

Based on his dialogs it sounds like he has resigned himself to staying with Arshi because of his guilt, and wants to ensure J is safe by not focussing on her.

I'm still hoping Arshi will call off the wedding. Ani never will now.

the endgame is Ani-Jhanak … but for the to happen they both need to grow as individuals and this whole MU … he needs to proof to show her not guilty… idk it’s hard to understand him … even if the writer give monologue it’s not going to help because they confuse us even more … let see how this pans out

Originally posted by: Goddy2010

Why you are saying like this? Has he decided to stay with Arshi?

I don't know what to think. I thought the show was heading towards Ani J marriage. And we get J in Mumbai.

I feel the annulment will not go through and or Arshi will pull out of the marriage, allowing Ani to go to J.

They will explore more his possessive side and how it affects their marriage.

J in Mumbai wont last long. She will get back to BH, choton appu di all need J for show to go on.

Originally posted by: vira76

yes, because to him whatever he has done is the right thing to do... until Jhanak or someone explains it to him how his actions might have hurt Jhanak he is not going to understand that and then he will reflect on it...

These are the ways to drag the drama, it's as simple as that!

yup and for trp the show will definitely be stretched…. Will see 🤞

Aah, started responding to this post and IF urao it ! Now have to remember what I wrote and re-write it!

I agree with every single point of yours here. Ani is an innate protector, and he stands up for what is 'right', keeping aside any emotional attachments whatsoever.

With J, the order was protector Ani reigned supreme, followed by mentor/enabler Ani, followed by the lover !

He has stood up for the weak,numerous times, in the past, no matter who is in front of him! Be it for Jethu, Bodoma,Apu di, Chhoton against his own parents.

And of course he has stood by J on many occasions, even if it meant facing the music from his family and Shrishti/Arshi.

This time around, the weak is Arshi ! The misfortune that befell Arshi is apalling, unfathomable even! The state that Arshi has been redued to, from being a happy expectant bride, the feedback that the doctor provided about Arshi's condition, the fact that a mother whose daughter is in death-bed is claiming to have ankho-dekhi some one doing the deed - all of this has shrouded and clouded Ani's logical, level-headed and practical thinking capabilities!

He is 'blinded' by an 'overwhelming urge' to get justice for Arshi and crucify the wrong-doer in the worst way possible - he knows he cannot un-do what befell on Arshi, what's done is done, but he is trying to re-do what's right for Arshi , in the sense , by providing her with justice!

So he is NOT going to ALLOW himself to be SWAYED in J's FAVOUR , because he loves her ! An milder analogy would be - Indian parents, chahe pyar jitna bhi kare bacho se, jaha bache koi galti kare, dhar dete hai do jhapar Tab na yaad aati koi pyaar

We need to also remember that Ani believes what he sees at face value and circumstantial evidence. He saw AK in J's room in the middle of the night and jumped to his conclusions!

He WILL NOT ALLOW himself to be PARTIAL towards J. What he doesn't understand, is by taking the NEUTRAL stand, i.e. I will deem you guilty and not deem you guilty, till you are proven guilty, he is actually 50% bent towards J could have committed the crime - which is ofcourse death nail on RuNak, at least from J's end!

It is NOT a CLEAR STAND like Jethu - "I believe J can NEVER do such a thing". We also have to remember, with Jethu, Bodoma, Apu di and Chhoton, they love J unconditionally, and probably the equation they have with J , it comes easier to believe and support her effortlessly.

Also, take note of Vinayak - he stands up for what he thinks is 'right' against his wife, despite seeing the mis-fortune that his daughter has encountered! Some might argue, his good senses are shrouded, why is he not taking a stand for his own daughter?

With Ani, he has brought J in this mix, na J BH mein 8 mahine hoti, na yeh sab hota, so like Shirshti pointed out today, Ani is the root cause of this pachera !

All said - this is just the makers way to bring in the much needed MU and 'push' for J to leave BH. They could have done it in a better way, with out making Ani behave this way.

However, if Ani's character learns to 'trust' J or learns to NOT unnecessarily mis-trust J, from this experience, it would be some win ! But I doubt it ! Leena's characters are shown to never 'grow' and 'learn'!

It basically justifies J's statement, "Self-respect hai mera, agar kabhi kisi din kuchh aisa huya, ki someone's actions overruns my self-respect, that is the day I will leave" !

For J, Ani is her living- trigger, no matter who does what to her, it is Ani and Ani alone, that can bring out the extreme in J, in this case , propells her to leave BH!

The only other trigger that J has, is her dead mother ! She will come handy when her letter comes out!

Originally posted by: vira76

So he said mentioned arshi name … when he said sath nahi chodunga

This goes along with what I said about Ani’s traits … he is god of justice like jhanak is goddess of Mahanata. He meant every word he said. In his heart he feels pain for jhanak but his mind is asking him to do what’s right (according to him). He is not being able to ignore what Shristi said , that she saw something. Think this, if he can fight for a stranger girl so much , do we expect him to sit quietly for arshi who he was about to marry, and he has been her friend and had shared romantic relationship with. So in conclusion, his roar for justice is not limited trait to jhanak not it can apply to other people as well. Like it has been mentioned in the show many times by other characters “agar jhanak ki gaha koi aur hota , tab bhi ani wo hi karata ko usanae kiya hai” !

As far as him not completely trusting jhanak goes, he is extremely left brain guy. He seriously lacks emotional intelligence. That is why we saw so many rifts between jhanak and ani! As they both think differently. For anirudh it was strange for Shristi to involve police so recklessly without any proof.

So he has been distant with Jhanak. Jhanak and us are have emotional intelligence. And jhanak is extremely right brained person , for her she takes this as anirudh didn’t trust me! Or didn’t even bother to ask me about what happened. So this is it.

This is definitely a nail in the coffin for jhanak. Anirudh will not feel guilty about it as he still thinks he did what was right, let law handle it … But yes it’s stupid … how they are writing this and executing this. People will see this as character assassin. And to some degree it is.

And it is also not… considering what both of these went through it’s hard to think they will go to this extreme to show how much ani cares for justice. Please don’t expect monologue saying he was acting … he was surely emotional and worried about jhanak but he was also worried for arshi.

He didn’t want to be unfair to her because of his feelings if jhanak was even slightly guilty. Shristi , his parents everyone was blaming her … again he was standing in the middle with two opposite set of people. He always used “agar” … so he wanted jhanak to be proven not guilty! But until it’s proven he also didn’t want to trust her because he loves her and forgive her… so doing right comes above love for him… 🙏