Originally posted by: Rancho12345
People sadly don't talk at about the fact that Anirudha himself is victim of his toxic family as he has spend his entire life in that house, just imagine his trauma while growing up as a kid, the fact that he became such a kind hearted man even after staying there and having such parents is in itself praiseworthy.
The amount of bashing Anirudha recieves no matter what he does and even when due to any situation he couldn't do anything is unparalleled.
This may sound like bashing, All the things you said about Ani are valid. To be honest, in a way, all kids in Indian homes (more likely Asian) grow up with complex PTSD as a result of their home environment. But the fact of the matter is, he can see now everyone around him behaves obedient to him in a way. If he can manipulate them to his advantage, why is he not able to proactively defend her against the onslaught of insults? He can easily do it. And if he grew up in a toxic household having some of the same issues as Jhanak does now, why isn't he able to empathize more with her and fight for her regardless? Why does he think Jhanak is in a mindset to understand and fight for herself? She is fricking depressed. People don't find a reason to live in depression, nothing matters to them, period, which is why people take their lives. We are all seeing some signs on it here and there, granted makers are not showing it well...but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist within Jhanak. Being depressed is like sinking in a bog, the more you struggle to get out, the more it pulls you back in. You can never completely get rid of depression; you just learn to work around it.
Also, it's not as if Jhanak's life was hunky-dory either. Imagine her trauma growing up hearing about the dad who left his mom and her mom being labeled a w**** in so many ways. She was so used to the point when Ani told her how wrong this was, she just brushed it off saying It's okay, it's an everyday occurrence for us. No matter how much support system she has, this has got to hurt man. If we want to compare, Ani's problems pale in front of hers. How would any one of us feel in Jhanak's place?
Again, not saying Ani's problems were not valid, both Ani and Jhanak are victims in childhood and both their traumas are equally valid. They both exhibit symptoms of Complex PTSD in their adulthood.
Jhanak should be held responsible for not fighting for herself when her mental health is becoming fragile day by day, but Ani who doesn't experience any of that now is given leeway because he grew up in a toxic household. Make it make sense.
It makes me so sad when people don't comprehend the extent to which Jhanak's mental health has taken a hit in the Basu madhouse.
And I am not Ani hater and Jhanak Stan. I love the characters equally if you have seen my updates.
1.5k