Katha Ankahee -- #15 daily EDT - Page 92

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

94.3k

Users

53

Likes

2.9k

Frequent Posters

Tenochtitlan thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: _OrChiD_

Who made Raghav a doctor? I want to see professors who taken class in medical college if they are fake or real. smiley29



My god when Katha said "pen gift kareie unhey" "puraney jamaney sey unhey bahuth Pyaar hai". A blind even can see her change of expression and sense softness in her voice.


What a dumb psychiatrist!!! smiley7smiley11


He is gonna see Katha and Viaan's engagement photo and turn a blind eye to it. That is the kind of psychiatrist he is. He is so delusional no wonder his wife left him smiley37smiley37

Eternalallure thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 1 years ago

Missed today's episode. Will come here after catching up on itsmiley36

divine_16 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Tenochtitlan


He is gonna see Katha and Viaan's engagement photo and turn a blind eye to it. That is the kind of psychiatrist he is. He is so delusional no wonder his wife left him smiley37smiley37

The doctor who has no idea of what triggered his patient to go such violent....u can expect any weird thing from him.
divine_16 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

It was so nice to see Vsnya also making efforts with her bhai to make Katha aware of the reality by sending those snaps of Viaan's house.Sorry,I absolutely didn't get Ehsaan today.He was so concerned about Viaan...it's okay but when he realises that both are in pain then why not making efforts to reduce the pain of both of them?? Why couldn't he understand that Kaviaan's happiness lies in being together not separated??Concerned about Raghav's family and Katha's pain but not stopping her from taking certain decisions which is harming her the most. His dialogue to Vanya fir Viaan, cracked me up..."uske liye main hun ".Bhai tum toh 8 months tak uske liye the....tabh jab uskey liye kuch nahi kar paaye...uska dard kaam nahi kar payee...toh agey jakey kya hi karoge?? But may be he is too scared after what happened before the leap in Garewal house....so being so pessimistic. Thank God!! finally Viaan said that he is offended with Katha as she thought that he will deliberately reveal something about their past relationship to Raghav's family.When there is so crunch of time then why are the makers not cutting down the SS of Raghav and hjs family??

Tenochtitlan thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: _OrChiD_

Who made Raghav a doctor? I want to see professors who taken class in medical college if they are fake or real. smiley29



My god when Katha said "pen gift kareie unhey" "puraney jamaney sey unhey bahuth Pyaar hai". A blind even can see her change of expression and sense softness in her voice.


What a dumb psychiatrist!!! smiley7smiley11


@Bold. Its good isn't it? Katha's invisible pain, love, angst is visible now just as everyone wantedsmiley36


I always knew once she started explicity showing her emotions, it will feel awkward. I remember when so many whined about "Katha smiling and laughing in front of Raghav and family as if she has forgotten Viaan, what a shameless lady she is."


Showing her true emotions and insecurities was never part of her character from the very beginning for very good reasons. She learnt this skill during Aarav's treatment where she was supposed to hide her emotions and make Aarav feel as if everything is normal. This was also remarked by Viaan in episode 35 or 36 where he was reading an article on Leukemia about how patient's family members have to hide their emotions and then, he remembered all the instances of Katha being tensed and how she hid her tension. In Dubai too, she laughed off and cracked jokes with Abdali when Viaan was right next to her and she hated him like hell.


Honestly, writers were writing Katha in her character from the very beginning of this track. It takes a lot to break her. One such event was ONS and other being Grewal house chaos.


Honestly, writers explicity showed her emotions and condition through her dream sequence at the Open mic event, Her monologue with Viaan in car , her dream sequence with Viaan in Raghav's house and so on. But, people were adamant for some reason which I am unable to understand. Her inner tumoil was in front of the screen but, viewers refused to accept it. It wasn't that difficult to understand her POV if you have seen the show and understood each character and do a brief thinking through character's POV.


Majority of ITV audiences aren't accustomed to this level of logical thinking as so many ITV shows serve you with utter crap featuring - accidental marriage, accidental Karwa Chauth, Accidental pregnency !?, woman transforming to spider, snakes and whatnot where applying logic is simply waste of time and energy.


However, this show is an exception. Here, thinking and wasting your energy indeed helps in understanding the story. Most of the times by the time I even come up with a view, writers show even better picture on screen. For example, recently a discussion on this forum started that "Aarav thinks Viaan slapped Katha". This view may or may not be true but, what this view signifies is a child's perspective. How can a child's mind work. How difficult it is to explain to a child. We grownups, can't think through the lens of a child but, after this remark, many things about Aarav's grudge make sense. Viaan accepted that he hurt Katha, Viaan did so wrong that Yuvraaj beat the crap out of Viaan, He did so wrong that Kailash tried to shoot Viaan but, he got shot in return, Viaan went to jail, Kailash died, Kavita fled to london. So many things without any explanation. If Katha explains him that Viaan didn't hurt her, he won't believe her simply given that he has seen so much. Combine with his already established intellect, it is insanely hard to convince him.


I know this kind of thinking was never required in ITV for obvious reasons but, this kind of thinking is very much common in well written literature and poetries and the writers writing this show are indeed skilled at their craft and this show was well written for over 200 episodes. Yes, they made blunders, but, can't ignore their brilliancies too.


That's why some people of twitter and here too shared common views on the show. As you said "as if Katha told these people on about her feelings seperately". You don't need to go literature college to learn this skill, school level english literature or Hindi literature is enough. We were asked questions to write character sketch of characters and analyze them, that is from where this common thinking coming from.

Tenochtitlan thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: divine_16

The doctor who has no idea of what triggered his patient to go such violent....u can expect any weird thing from him.

I am imagining his delusion during honeymoon with his wife in a goa hotel. His wife comes out in a purple nightie looking at him seductievelysmiley16


He undresses and........................ gets into night dress........ and then sleeps on the bed for entire night. Next morning he realized OH SHIT BAD TIMING smiley37smiley37smiley36

divine_16 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Tenochtitlan

I am imagining his delusion during honeymoon with his wife in a goa hotel. His wife comes out in a purple nightie looking at him seductievelysmiley16


He undresses and........................ gets into night dress........ and then sleeps on the bed for entire night. Next morning he realized OH SHIT BAD TIMING smiley37smiley37smiley36

Bcoz of his bad timing his wife left him.His wife be like..."raho tum aapney delusion aur bad timing ke saath ....main chali aapni good timing dhundney"smiley36
Eternalallure thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Sajini235

If you guys can remember Kaviaan's presentation in Alibhag conconference, do you remember what when Arnirudh asked viaan that whose monument is Taj-Mahal? Then viaan rereplied it belongs both, Mumtaaz's friend and Shah-Jahan. "Shah-Jahan ko Mumtaaz ki saath mila or Mumtaaz ki dost ko unki khayalon ki saath". That's the base concept of current track. In this story Katha is refered as Mumtaaz. So its yet to see who will become Mumtaaz's friend and Shah-Jahan between Viaan and Raghav. Even though we as kaviaan fans want happy ending for them but honestly speaking it seems impossible due to current circumstances. It would have been extremely beautiful journey if channel doesn't shut the show unnecessarily. Go to hell , sony 🤬🤬🤬🤬

There have been too many instances such as this that come to mind. There was that Orpheus Eurydice one. Then too Viaan had also said something along the lines of mohabbat ka maqsad hai poora hona, chahe is duniya mein ya us duniya mein. Another one I remember was after that first dinner the three of them had gone to where Aarav had gotten in an argument with another boy. They had come home and when kaviaan were talking Viaan in his usual shayar way had said something about unrequited love. Like how ek tarfa ishq karne walon ko khush hona chahiye ki zindagi amar nhi hai. Yeah they were mainly talking about Aarav there but it fits their situation too. It's like they've given these hints that their love was fated to remain unfulfilled. Like it was ill-fated from the beginning and no matter how much they try, hey cannot overcome those odds.


As viewers who have witnessed their whole journey it's not easy to digest the possibility that they couldn't be together in the end. It's painful to imagine that all their immense love for each other fell short in the end. But still it would be infinitely more palatable to me than seeing katha with someone else. Raghav shouldn't even be an option. There's no mumtaz ka dost here. There's only shah jahan and mumtaz and whether they get to be together or not. I can somehow imagine them going their separate ways, but I cannot imagine them with anyone else. Door se ek dusre ko chahte hue poori zindagi bita denge par kisi aur ke saath nhi honge.

Edited by Eternalallure - 1 years ago
Eternalallure thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Tenochtitlan


He is gonna see Katha and Viaan's engagement photo and turn a blind eye to it. That is the kind of psychiatrist he is. He is so delusional no wonder his wife left him smiley37smiley37

Ise kehte hain dekh kar andekha karna. Banda ostrich ban gaya hai. Soch rha hai ki mooh chupa lunga aur katha katha jaap karunga to apna pyaar manifest kar lungasmiley37smiley37

Sometimes when you don't want to accept something you deliberately ignore all the signs and shut your eyes. Jo saamne hota woh bhi nhi dekhna chahte because the reality is too hard to accept.

Tenochtitlan thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Eternalallure

There have been too many instances such as this that come to mind. There was that Orpheus Eurydice one. Then too Viaan had also said something along the lines of mohabbat ka maqsad hai poora hona, chahe is duniya mein ya us duniya mein. Another one I remember was after that first dinner the three of them had gone to where Aarav had gotten in an argument with another boy. They had come home and when kaviaan were talking Viaan in his usual shayar way had said something about unrequited love. Like how ek tarfa ishq karne walon ko khush hona chahiye ki zindagi amar nhi hai. Yeah they were mainly talking about Aarav there but it fits their situation too. It's like they've given these hints that their love was fated to remain unfulfilled. Like it was ill-fated from the beginning and no matter how much they try, hey cannot overcome those odds.


As viewers who have witnessed their whole journey it's not easy to digest the possibility that they couldn't be together in the end. It's painful to imagine that all their immense love for each other fell short in the end. But still it would be infinitely more palatable to me than seeing katha with someone else. Raghav shouldn't even be an option. There's no mumtaz ka dost here. There's only shah jahan and mumtaz and whether they get to be together or not. I can somehow imagine them going their separate ways, but I cannot imagine them with anyone else. Door se ek dusre ko chahte hue poori zindagi bita denge par kisi aur ke saath nhi honge.


I think it might be last minute reunion of Viaan and Katha. He and his old wife peacefully divorced because of lack of love. Something similar is happening here too. This is the rushed way to do this as they have no time. This will leave many loose ends. What about Raghav? What about Ruhi? What about his family? What about Aarav, it still doesn't solve her fear regarding Aarav?


Don't know if his clumsiness is intended so that audiences don't feel for him when Katha leaves him or, its simply bad writing. Or, writers started this mess and don't know how to sort it. I will give them benefit of doubt and say that his clumsiness is intended so that audience don't feel attached to him when Katha part ways with him.

Edited by Tenochtitlan - 1 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".