Originally posted by: libran90
Ru, dekh me aa gayi🤗
Kahaan kasam khayi thi ki theories me ghusnekaich nahi. But after reading this and also rewatching prior to that, I had a similar idea brewing in my mind.
So, we all know after such high energy tandav it's rather difficult to comprehend that Imlie's faith which has been so unshakeable in matters of relationships will so easily lose it over Aditya's words and Aryan's statement.
I like how you pointed out that an impulsive character like Aditya gets beaten the shit out of and doesn't raise a finger, which is weird for him and for Imlie. From a neutral POV, it looks like his attempt to gain Imlie's sympathy by riling up Aryan, who himself is very fragile at the moment. It came across as planned and deliberate, rather than genuine. And hence Imlie asked, aapne haath kyun nahi uthaya, something in those lines.
To be honest, Imlie has a better functioning brain than Aditya in these investigative matters, even though she is so dhuh emotionally. Maybe Aditya has forgotten, but Imlie is also an investigative journalist as well. Or he just thinks when it comes to matters about him, she is an emotional fool, I don't know.
We all know, as much as Imlie is dumb, she is also very smart. It could be that her anger for Aryan and concern for Aditya is a projection for both of them to assume what they want, while she tries to understand the Arvind issue. She has read and seen everything, she has a vague idea about the trauma of the Rathore family. She has seen Arpita's trauma as well. More than Tripathis or Aditya, its Imlie who has lived with the Rathores and spent time with them.
Someone like Imlie who gave the benefit of doubt to Aryan when she did not even know him, losing her trust so easily, is weird. Imlie in a few moments recognized that Aryan was not a criminal and not the owner of the fight club, so how will she lose that instinct so easily I don't know.
So don't know about marriage and how much of a forced scenario it will be, but what I do feel is Imlie is planning to gift something else altogether on her birthday to Aditya Kumar Tripathi
Disclaimer: xxxxxNot Keeping Hopes Too High Thoughxxxxx