I think Umar was pretty clear that it was wrong of Karan to do. From what I understand, he was saying ke Pratik didn’t make a bigger issue of it because he wanted to look like the hero. Not that the actual violence wasn’t wrong - I could be wrong but that’s what I understood.
But here - there’s multiple clips of Pratik and Nishant helping Simba to make a case for “Umar fell into the pool himself on purpose to make Simba look bad”. Which is ridiculous. Pratik at least, given he was at the receiving end a few weeks ago - should be calling a spade a spade in this, if he’s so clear on his sense of right and wrong, and it’s not motivated by benefit to himself.
what matters most is Umar immediately spoke to karan when he patkaoed and controlled and said. How can you do this.
I don’t know if he is now speaking what he is after the fact. But he did take the right approach on this when kk patkaoed pratik …