Barrister Babu Episode Discussion Thread| DT note Pg 136 - Page 59

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

55.2k

Users

36

Likes

1.6k

Frequent Posters

Sujz thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Patibabu

He did not believe that a women should serve the way a man did, but still believed in the honor of a woman and wanted to rid the ill-treatment of all women.

And the thing about the school, you really can't come to an conclusion that is this a GOVERNEMNT school runned by British or a private school. There were people who admired British culture.

And admiration being OTT, like seriously? She knew nothing about India before. And now when she has started by Gandhiji, you find it OTT. Everything has it's own peace Sujz. You really can't expect them to show everything at once. And as i said THE WHOLE HEERA MANDI track was because she wanted to meet Gandhiji. And as you said he isn't any ordinary person who she meet's on the road. This was the way!


1. He believed women were just meant to look after house and children. The show's Gandhiji is from an alternative universe.

2. There were no Indian Private Schools in a widespread manner at that time and even if it was its name wouldn't be Oak Leaf School or something and Binoy wouldn't send his child to an Indian School. Plus even in an Indian school they wouldn't allow to invite someone like this, neither MKG was famous enough or had done any work enough to be called as greatest person alive to a school at that time.

3. If she had to know someone about India, she and ANIRUDDH should have started from basic, regional fighters who were relevant and close to them at that place! For that era they would know Bengali fighters better and Gandhi wasn't that famous to be known in a pan India level at that time. So yes, it was ott.

4. So right from HIRA MANDI track, the Gandhiji rant was baseless and defying logic, but we passed it but what they are showing now is clear distortion of fact which doesn't have any justification. Makers are clearly unaware of basic Indian History.

Sujz thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Arpita_De

Uff hoooo 😲 Serious discussion going on, I shouldn't interrupt 😳 But I have one innocent question, In 1918 Anirudh tha kya? and Bondita? Thi Kya? I mean 1st female barrister of Tulsipur thi kya Bondita in actual history? Hell West Bengal mein TULSIPUR tha kya? 🤔 I thought the show is fiction so never asked but now people are expecting reality so just asking.... No offence to anyone, everyone has right to raise questions and so am I.... 😳 Feel free to ignore 😆


I am sorry this is really lame.

When they are taking a show, with a fictional story on historical India which focuses on SOCIAL DRAMA and FREEDOM struggle, they need to keep their facts right. They cannot just distort the whole history of the biggest democracy in the world like that.

Going by that theory, we cannot actually blame showing makkhi and all in a previous colors show which ran for years and was set in 21st century and wasn't even started as a supernatural show.

1193270 thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: briti_asfiya

They mentioned it's 1918 via newspapers and boards so how is Gandhi ji being bald and in dhoti is correct?


Gandhi Ji only wanted women to be educated so that they could teach the kids he believed that women should stay in home only and didn't support women freedom fighters. So Gandhi shown as a feminist when he clearly didn't support Women Empowerment is ignorant.


Schools, Colleges, Hospitals, Courts all were ran by the British Government how could a principal go against the Government DIRECTLY? The management wouldn't accept that and would have closed the school in reality.

Bro not to offend you,but tum dekhti hogi magnifying glass leke date in newspapers, but majority of the people don't so chill!👍🏼
836559 thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: T-Scarlett

Haan na..I was quite confused jab makers ne Tulsipur ko West Bengal mei bataya because it's in UP..I was like fiction hai chalta hai...

Bon 11 yrs ki ho gayi phir bhi mujhe koi fark nahi pada reason being the same..

And ab Yeh Gandhiji waala kand..Tadka lagana makers ka kaam hai and humara kaam hai maze lena..😆

I really don't care about Gandhiji's age in the show as far as they are keeping the story intact..


Nahi Scarlett aise kaise chalega! 🤪 Tulsipur ko WB me kyu bataya hai jabki vo UP me hai ? 🤪

What do you mean? My whole BB life was lie abhi tak?😭 Meko Geography History nahi aata hai matlab makers ne mera galat faayda uthaya behen

A_for_Arpita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Patibabu

Arpi, Tulsipur is fictitious place. Initially its in Uttar Pradesh. Anirudh and bondita both are fictitious characters. There is no history which says that there were as Anirudh or Bondita. But this is based on a novel i guess.

Yes everyone does have a right to speak out, but there are people jo har baat mein negativity dhund rahe hai . And that's an issue.

Sab jab fictitious hai to kyu realistic bana rahi hoo bhai? Or realistic banane ki kooshish mein negativity kyu spread karna( not taunting you, okay!).

I know you haven't taunted me 😆 Tulsipur in UP? That's new to me as Bengal mein tho for sure kabhi nehi tha 😆 Btw my comment was sarcastic 🤪 🤣
A_for_Arpita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: ..RiMi..


Arpi 🤣🤣🤣🤣

On point behen on Point 🤪🤗


What I feel about the show is that it's a FICTIONAL show . They have taken elements from history to weave a story of Anirudh and Bondita. Bas and Gandhiji is one of the elements.


Humko sirf Rudi maangta 🤪

Smart girl 😆 Thank you 🤗
A_for_Arpita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago
A_for_Arpita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: briti_asfiya

But the show is based on History. They should have kept it to Rudhita's personal journey or kept it historically accurate. The couple and their journey might be FICTIONAL the SITUATION wasn't!

Situation too fictional Briti 😳
mrsasfandyarali thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: Patibabu

They haven't exactly shown the years. Not in any dialogues, right? Gandhiji started wearing dhoti in 1921, and as we say it revolves around 1920. So kaha wrong hai Gandhiji ka look? And Briti first thing, THIS IS A FICTITIOUS show, you really can't expect detailed to detailed thing right? But compared to others they have shown much accurate

And baba we still don't know what Gandhiji says to bon about schools. But he believed that women should get educated and be equal like men, but shouldn't serve like men.

And this is all about Bondita's admiration for Gandhiji. So take it that way and enjoy.

They promote the show saying they shows the TRUTH of that ERA while distorting the facts of that era. Wow isn't that amazing, show toh fictitious hai kya uss era ka situation aur modern indian history bhi fictitious hai ki woh tod marod kare uske saath?


Gandhi wanted women education alright but he was also a puritan and a misogynist who helped ensure that India remains one of the most sexually repressed nations on earth. Remember that. But this is an AU Gandhi as far as I've seen.


Kal dekhte hai baki ka.

Scarlett_15 thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 4 years ago

Originally posted by: ..RiMi..


Nahi Scarlett aise kaise chalega! 🤪 Tulsipur ko WB me kyu bataya hai jabki vo UP me hai ? 🤪

What do you mean? My whole BB life was lie abhi tak?😭 Meko Geography History nahi aata hai matlab makers ne mera galat faayda uthaya behen

Yeh log kuch bhi batate hai behen..And yes, your whole BB life was indeed a lie 🤣Tumhe yahi nahi pata ki tumhara Ani jahan rehta hai wo place exactly kaunse State mei hai🤣🤣

Just kidding behena..🤪Yeh History Geography to Civil services exam ke chakkar me padha tha nahi to hum shuddh Microbiologist bhi hai..😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".