Originally posted by: annihilation
I think it shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone that nothing anymore is entirely organic at BB anymore. It's narrative and returns controlled to a great deal and that very clear shows, especially since a few seasons. Last season Rashmi wasn't ever a favourite of BB, she might have gotten to stayed the amount of time she did because one, contract terms and conditions and two, she eventually gained support and sympathy from audiences because her reputation and personal life was constantly tarnished time and again. That's no being favourite of BB, whoever thought so must not quite understand how BB functions.
Hina could have won but her chances were hampered due to the Shilpa-Vikas conflicts and some of it was on her because she couldn't exactly prove herself to be the ideal candidate for the winner going by the mandate.
Every year BB does zero in on at least 3 candidates for the winner positions, imo and does everything the team can to set a narrative around time and see to it at their chosen one's are locked for the top 3 and then whoever wins, wins. But if a wave of great support and liking from the public hampers his plans, he switches to including one public favourite and 1-2 of his chosen candidates in order to look organic. And if the support turns out to be massive, he can't do much to change that. Case in point, I don't think Gauhar and Gautam were supposed to win in their respective seasons but they ended up winning owing to their own personalities and massive public support.
Last season, I don't think Asim was even a candidate for top 5 but he ended up being in top 2 because audiences grew to liking him, especially against Shukla. So, they dropped Rashmi out from even the top 3 and chose Shehnaaz instead because she provided that 'entertainment' value.
Please note that when I see 'audiences' or 'public support', it is just a general reading based on what is being voiced on various public platforms and who it is against/for. We don't have the statistics here to be able to discern just how much percentage of public liking/support each contestant has for himself/herself. And who you think is most liked can change from one platform to another. If majority of people seem to be in Rahul's support at IF for whatever reasons of their own, it might be completely opposite somewhere else.
All this is based on my understanding of how BB used to work once upon a time and how it has been workings since a few seasons now and it is pretty much my own opinion. You can, of course, have your own. And by that extension, nobody here is required to see to the show as you see and you aren't required to either. Let's not get to, 'kisi ko nahi dikhta ya sirf Ruby hi dikhti hain' because kisko kya dikhta hain is entirely subjective beyond a general premise that's established.
What you have written here makes a lot of sense. So who are the top 3/4 BB candidates according to you?