Originally posted by: EtherealRati
Okay, after watching the whole episode....this is what i feel about it....the task was designed in a way ki chori aur impressing was simultaneously .....which is quiet difficult. Par ho sakta tha....gauhar and hina apne gehno ke paas baithi aur unhe guard karti....aur ek ladka usse impress karta....baaki ladke shamiyaane ke bahar se ladkiyon ko andar jaane se rokte.....and girls kisi tarah ghus jaati aur le leti ....then it was possible to do in that way. Or big boss people could have mentioned a timing after which the stealing can start. But they din't unfortunately. That was the loophole.
Coming to the task
I think after the budger, task begins.....aaj tak toh big boss mein yahi hua hain...all understanding of rules is before budger.....but first time big boss stopped because sid and team was standing outside already, so they had the advantage....aur logo ko andar se aana tha.....bhaag kar bhi aate ...tobhi chori ho jaati. Toh it was all started again. Big boss announced there that as soon as the queens go into their shamiyana....the task will start.
1) The first thing gauhar said was ki chori aise honi chahiye ki pata na chale ki chori ki hain.....aisa kab hota hain big boss mein.....chori means bas waha se lena hain....it normally never has meant that jisse chori kar rahe usse pata nahi chalna chahiye in this house. And gauhar toh har season dekhti hain na.
2) Then she asked a boy to guard on which sid said that it isnt allowed. Sid was right when he said that gauhar cant keep a guy to guard the jewels.....cause rules mein yeh nahi likha tha ki queens can keep a guard to safeguard the jewels .....yeh likha tha ki if queens move out of their shamiyana, at that time they can keep a boy guard to protect jewels.
3) Then, i don' t get gauhar roaming with the rule book here and there.....big boss just asked that they have to go and sit....budger was already on....if she wanted a rule discussion....why they dint did before the budger...they all dressed up for the task and sid and hina were shown strategizing too....tab kyun nahi hua rule discussion agar samajh nahi aaya tha gauhar ko....and i dont really feel ki bahut difficult tha samajhna ki kya likha hain. And even if she needed to read rules back....she could have asked a boy to bring the book while she sat at her singhasan. But she wanted that after a budger is on....till the time she doesnt wants to sit ...she should be allowed to roam and everybody else should wait cause she isnt clear with the rules.......jabki hina had already sat on the singhasan. Big boss also said ...ki shamiyane mein aane ke baad....task shuru The budger was on already and so was the task.
Sid vs eijaj
Sid was right in saying that his team job was to steal...why should he be bothered about if boys were able to impress or not....woh toh unko manage karna tha. Eijaj was saying sid spoiled it .....but why after the budger all boys weren't there....doesn't scheming/planning happens before the budger. So it was not sid, but it was the attitude boys showed towards the task in the starting...girls did the planning plotting in the timing which was given before the budger....but guys dint do much...there were literally people saying ki bula lo bula lo....halke mein mat lo after the budger was done. How careless that was....what does eijaj expect that sid should wait that everyone comes and boys start blocking the girls ....why will he wait for that. Woh karna, eijaj ki khudki team ki responsibility thi. Sid ki team had to do their job which they did.....there responsibility was that only.
Okay now coming to gauhar's point .....ki task dekhne ko nahi mila cause start hote hi chori ho gayiii.....haan...toh chori se bachana tha na....that is what was required.....she felt ki audience ke liye impress waala task mein maza hota.....and that din't happened....yup the responsibility to make that happen was on gauhar's and hina's shoulders. And big boss themself kept that chori angle there na...that was sid's responsibility. Unhe rakhna hi nahi chahiye tha ....simultaneously girls could have been asked to impress sid.......kal bhi toh ussi type ka kuch kar rahe ....yeh angle daala hi isiliye gaya tha taaki ladai ho. What should sid do....wait until girls give jewellery to guys.....were girls able to steal a single thing from boys after it was in their hand ? No right ?....so what should have girls done.....should have waited to loose the task. I don't find sid and his team wrong in doing their task ....they were right....unhe chori karne ko kaha tha....yeh nahi kaha tha ki kab karni hain. They were allowed to choose that for themselves.
Mujhe sid ke arguments illogical nahi lage as a viewer but the way he kept them....it all created a chaos....him shouting madly.....gauhar shouting back madly....they trying to prove ....main sahi ....main sahi.....that spoiled the task much more than anything else. The new contestants, jinka pehla task tha....unmein se kaafi confused ho gaye is sab mein. And the whole episode was dedicated to the seniors fighting with each other where juniors were ignored.
