Debate on political son involved and Rhea’s new petition: Times Now - Page 5

Originally posted by: S_H_Y

Why has this turned into left vs right though

Like ndtv,Rajdeep etc are inviting anurag,Akhtars and talking how bw is fair industry, whereas times now and republic gone the other way 🤔

Akhtars came???😆

im not surprised why many channels are supporting them. Only Times Now and Republic TV are supporting DR. Swami.

There is only one person who will know it and he isn’t here anymore. Yes the family has the right to question everything that happened to him but then again. His family didn’t like her from the beginning it seems? we know some family members will have problem with the other person their loved ones are hanging around and now in a situation like this it o my can get worse.

Yes maybe rhea wasn’t innocent but isn’t Sushant also responsible to give her the right to spend those money or whatever she did with it.

He wasn’t drugged that she just spend his money without his knowledge.

she can’t force him to go to a doctor. At the end it’s his decision and she isn’t the one who bought him those medicines. There plays also a big role if he always took those medicines.

Why is it difficult to accept that he had a problem with his mental health and it led to that.

No one hang him in his room. He wasn’t drugged he didn’t take any overdose. He was alone and it was his own decision and people need to make peace with this instead of running to find someone who’s fault. Cause somewhere it everyone’s fault.

there can be many reasons why he did what he did but you can’t pin point what is really the reason. There are sevaral stuff which again would lead to mental illness.

and please this he was happy he had plans isn’t a reason why someone can’t be depressed or whatever kind of mental illness problem he had.

Originally posted by: Scarlet.ferro

Thank you.

I am from the same field and i really would like to know why he was put on medication directly? As a doctor myself , i dont jump to giving my patients medication , forget strong ones. If after therapies and cbt and counselings dont work, then we shift to medicines.

That's not true in many cases atleast I have seen many psychiatrist prescribing pills in your first session whether it's anxiety,ocd, depression, just take the pills.

Finding a good psychiatist is hard

Originally posted by: buttercups2020

Thank you.

I am from the same field and i really would like to know why he was put on medication directly? As a doctor myself , i dont jump to giving my patients medication , forget strong ones. If after therapies and cbt and counselings dont work, then we shift to medicines.

Anti anxiety drugs (I wont be taking the name of medicine as it is unethical) are short term because of their addictive nature. Not many bodies are compatible to many of these and hence we start with smallest possible dosage so that it is easier to take off in case of any rejection from the body.

If at all he was on sedative anti anxiety only, and if his body had started shivering, there is a possibility he was taking them for a very long time before he stopped it ; which itself is questionable. Why was he given a medicine like this for a long time when they can be addictive!

If they were not anti anxiety drugs but actual anti depressants and his body rejected it then it was necessary to change his medication. But the worst part is, there is also a possibility that he never required those medicines.

Even in early depression or mid way, constant cbt and sessions are the first steps taken!!

And it is said he was admitted in hospital for deep depression ; what does it even mean?

He had anxiety issues! There is a possibility he had nervous breakdown. Why is it called deep depression just like this?

Hey..

Actually anti depressants work as anti anxiety drugs too. Here since the person i was replying to is not a doctor, i was trying to simplify it for her.

See, first it is not counseling, it is psychotherapy.

Initially when the patient comes we straightaway don't do counseling.

Initial work up is not counseling but a Psychiatric interview where we allot some time to the patient to first tell us what brings him to us. Based on his entire life story (family history, personal history, pasf medical history and personality) including what brought him to us, we always look for what will help him best.

If the patient meets the criteria for the illness, we start him on medication depending on severity. If its psychosis, we directly start medication because in most cases even self care is lost. If its bipolar mania, event then we start with medication.

If its major depressive disorder..(unfortunately minor depression is not a valid diagnosis) , if its just sadness of mood and other criteria for depression are not being met, we mostly look for adjustment problems .

If there is some issue going on and their sadness of mood is because of that, it again goes into diagnosis of adjustment disorder. For adjustment disorder, unless there is a valid reason to prescribe, we don't. We advice psycho therapy..

For anxiety, because sometimes patients may get panic attacks too, it is always better to start medication and only therapy wont work mostly.

Medication along with therapy is most beneficial. Not therapy alone.

Originally posted by: S_H_Y

Why has this turned into left vs right though

Like ndtv,Rajdeep etc are inviting anurag,Akhtars and talking how bw is fair industry, whereas times now and republic gone the other way 🤔

Seriously...same thought on my mind...I have left leanings...I don’t believe in right ideology...n yet I believe arnab n Swamy are doing the right thing...Why is it so difficult to understand that not everybody is a politician n not everybody picks sides based on political ideology on everything under the sun.

Originally posted by: S_H_Y

That's not true in many cases atleast I have seen many psychiatrist prescribing pills in your first session whether it's anxiety,ocd, depression, just take the pills.

Finding a good psychiatist is hard

Read up comprehensive textbook of Psychiatry, maudsley prescribing guidelines, and a lot of other stuff to understand why Medication or therapy is chosen and on what basis.

Each patient is unique for us and Medication is very important. Just therapy and no medication has also pushed people to extremes.. don't unnecessarily blame doctors for everything. There are bad apples in every profession and the side effects are not demons, they go away with time.

You don't know what warrants medication and what doesn't.

No doubt mumbai police hand are tied due to political party currently in Maharashtra

As many things looks absurd, mumbai police should had been brought the guilty within three weeks of time frame from the day SSR's untimely demise

Doctor must be having his history and chief complaints from his counselling sessions. They can't give medications without counselling and psychotherapy.

I found this. Plz confirm if it's true or not.

https://twitter.com/ippatel/status/1289447538202824704?s=09

Originally posted by: lifeiscool

Doctor must be having his history and chief complaints from his counselling sessions. They can't give medications without counselling and psychotherapy.

I found this. Plz confirm if it's true or not.

https://twitter.com/ippatel/status/1289447538202824704?s=09

Brilliant ..extremely brilliant. I am sure they dont have his diaries also.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4t1H2Vgo24

There is one more.. keep going.. everyone has been forced to implicate.