YRHPK Live Updates/Episode Discussions 17 Jul 2020 - Page 12

Originally posted by: LetThereBeLight

@bold - This uru, i thought of the same....

yesterday i was ok with abir delaying to say truth as i though he doesnt have any idea n mish condition is not ok but after today episode i say he is the one at fault he is emotionally blackmailing mishti n stopping her... fault is not in her but abir....

just think of the man who doesnt leave even a small incident n does investigation against his mother, brother, call spade a spade n called out kunal for his mistake, is this the same man....

yaar a simple autospy will show the cause of death n he is a well influenced person yaar he has contact from high officials to celebrities to business people and you say me he is so dumb enough to not do anything in this 3 months bcoz of his mad love for mishti.... ok he loves mishti so he doesnt want mish to go to jail but is he so dumb to not understand that to prove her innocent atleast he should dig into the matter n solve this in a mature way...

he is emotionally blackmailing mishti, agar kal koi bhi problem aaye then fault is abirs no one else is at fault...

seriously i never though we will be talking like this about abir.... i feel you uru, you are almost crying n i'm getting angry, the man we understood even when everyone wouldnt is bought to this state...

yaar even if we are proven wrong like pali said this foolishness,, this dhaag of his mistake wont go away.... breakup ki time pe bhi we understood but this... i cant stand this uru... why are they doing this with abirs character yaar... 😭

Even an excellent character trait can sour when taken to extremes Diya. That's what they are showing here. Not what we wanted to see, but I still have hope that this will result in good. Abir ke saare theories correct nahi hain. Time he understood his weaknesses also and moved on from there. It's high drama but hopefully will result in good. Everyone makes mistakes yaar, let's see how they deal with it.

Originally posted by: SheThought

I am just extremely saddened by what they have made Abir do!

I was not even this disappointed with him during breakup phase. In fact, I could understand him very well that time.

This - this is not Abir! I really don't know who this person is.

His love, care and everything he is doing for Mishti is fine, but ab usme khud main bahot badi kami aa gayi... main seh nahin paa rahi hoon. Dil sachme todd diya inn logo ne mera.

pali you are making me cry yaar reading all this i cant.... what you n uru are saying is damn true n we people who loved him always know what it feels like to see him like this.. sach mai i cant handle this yaar... why are they putting abir under the bus n destroying his character so much.. 😭

This is tricky.

A guy can come an attack and molest and attempt to rape a girl anytime anywhere but IF she hits in self defence and the guy dies or is severely injured there is a whole case on her where she has to go through police lawyers judiciary to prove herself that she did it in self defence. If the molester is dead there can still be a case on her by his family that she went too far in self defence and could be punished or jailed for it. All this will take up months of her life or maybe even years. Very much fair to the girl who did nothing wrong to be stuck in such a situation.

IDK if what Abir is doing is right. It's easy to say the face the judiciary but we all know how it runs how long it takes to get judgement and if the guys family is powerful how difficult it can get for the girl to prove innocence. All this she has to face coz a random guy one fine day decided to molest n rape her. Her entire life becomes at stake due to that one guy.

When Abir reached both ppl were unconscious mishti n the guy who tried to molest her. Did he know what happened between them. Did he even know mishti hit him in self defence. He just took mishti away without calling the ambulance to take the other unconscious/dead person away. Or maybe he called. If Abir left a random person to die without calling for help it would not be right. It wud have been better if they showed mishti running away to find Abir telling him everything, them coming back seeing the person dead and then mishti becoming unconscious n abir deciding to run away. I don't know what they have shown exactly in the episode though. I am yet to watch it.

Originally posted by: yrhpk_aus

Aiyaa I know, it sounds soo boring and cliche. I've almost had enough of seeing this murder accident in the name of self-defence waay to much in movies and now tv shows too👎🏼 The other day I saw some tamil 'horror' movie and as usual each scary movie has a back story for the ghost..and it again they has to tie it back to some sexual assualt etc. It was soo predictable and boring.

I totally get what you girls are saying. I agree too, at the end of the day, mishbir shouldn't have ran and hid away for 3months! Like I mentioned in yest LU, if they truly felt they were innocent then (there will be someone/god that helps them) confessing up and facing the truth will ultimately be better in the long-run.

yaar nandu even an amateur wattpad writer can come up with more sensible story... its not about the story only nandu its about how low they are taking abirs character... so yourself say nandu is this how abir will behave if it was the sensible abir we know before or say if he will react the same if someone else did this...

let them hide until mish is stable but isnt abir that much educated to know that getting an autopsy can solve half of the problem... he went to the police station nandu he has high contacts... 3 months is a long time...

i thought he didnt have much idea of the incident so only he is not able to do anything legally so he is as of now trying to help mish but never expected this yaar...

Originally posted by: yrhpk_aus

I understand and I agree with all your emotions.

This is what happens when ITV tries to take on mystery murder - we already had apprehensions about how they will deal with this serious issue. Too much heightened drama and creating story holes, loop holes👎🏼

But I'm with diya too. Don't give up yet. I have a strong feeling there's more to it.

But yes, I too am disappointed in the way they have handled it

Please everyone remember though: the LOCKDOWN and Corona times has rattled every show and their storylines. Please don't rush/dive in to hating the writers and production team so quickly...all of them are working whilst risking their health.

Please try to be calm and just let the show go on. Let's see if they come up with something better to tie this mess. If not, we are all free to calmly and patiently say good bye (that by was so hard to even write)

still hanging on 1%🤗

Even i hope that there is more dear.... i'm so disappointed n angry today but still holding on to this hope that things will get more interesting in future... i cant nandu this is so saddening 😭

Originally posted by: angelfire78

Ruhi - her state of mind is directly related to not being able to say the truth. For someone like Mishti it has to be killing her not to say what happened to the police. So Abir is responsible for her current state of mind, not the assault!

No one is saying Mishti killed that person, but why behave as if they will hang her for protecting herself? Why not use it as a moment to teach about how you should speak out against assault? She should have stated what happened, and Abir should have let her.

How can this be justified? Kuhu ne Janmashtami time jo kiya woh bhi accident hi tha na? How is this different? And no one died at that time. Same for Kunal spiking Nishant's drink!

I'm all for seeing where the track goes, but what is wrong is wrong. Even a positive character trait of protectiveness can be taken too far, and according to me, that happened here. I love Abir still, and hope he can see what he's doing to Mishti in the name of protecting her.

Chalo kuch zyada hi bol diya. Sorry! Still love you, just don't agree with your pov in this 🤗

mishti hit the person, when she got assaulted and she is in semi concious... still we dont know what doctor said, what happened to her after that night and every night...

its not that easy to talk abour assault with family, when they judge u for every single thing...

jab se abir mishti ki shaadi hui hain, jas lekar Nidhi tak they are judging her and testing her love for abir..

like seriously, jas said u will break home, u r a home breaker, kuhu taunts and didnt leave a single stone to show how mishti is, how she cant be joint family and how she take her decisions, nidhi always in rant of kuhu and compares mishti with her, i mean more than months kuhu is married and more than a day mishti is bahu of RJV, how can she compare and show mishti down...BB ki games tho alag level par hi hain...

mishti ki shaadi ke 2 din baad she see her husband nearly on death bed and all are concerned about his heath but not a even a single person in RJV tried to ask her how she felt seeing abir like that? if this peopel cant accept mishti then how come abir can say what happened with them?

i dont find any wrong in the abir dealing with, just because he took mishti from there and asking her to forget it making emotional black mail... emotional black mail makes person to come out of thinking in a certain way and makes them to think for others...

if talking about assault with family makes mishti out of it then its wrong, the family like RJV never deserves to know this...

abir is not hiding any crime nor hiding criminal... he is sure of that person death report and his priority to bring mishti out of night mare... i still want to see layers of it as im still thinking its first layer only...

A big no for hiding things....

But i think we should wait for whole track now..cv giving away this mystery in first week of show doesn't it feels weird.......

Originally posted by: Onyourface

People who are saying that death happened that death is due to alcohol or someone else was only involved .....we don't know cuz mish was in unconscious state

Then it's even more disappointing

Iska matlab mishbir ko full story nahi pata and still abir's advice to mishti is to forget everything , it can't be funnier than this

Ek kaam karo , you all think jaise yeh sab kunal aur kuhu ke saath Hua, and re imagine the whole scene again cuz mishbir ke love ke naam pe we justify everything...

....I am damn sure ab samajh aayega ke how wrong this is ....the mess is just inviting more troubles thats all

Jo galat hai vo galat hai ! The series of hiding has just added up to mishti's trauma .... why can't we see this

I am not demeaning abir and his efforts...trust me mujhse zyada dukhi koi nahi ho sakta when it comes to abir right now Bohot foolish lagega to say but I am really in tears , for the first time in the show I am just not able to connect with him , I can't I just can't understand him ..😕😔

And I just hope I am proven wrong ...

Can't agree more guruji👍🏼

I thought the same.......

Abhir is working on his bandage theory..... Try to forget n move

He's not in a position to think that accepting the truth will get Mishti out off this trauma.... Yes there fight will be tough as there is no evidence but is Mishti happy now.... She's almost in hell every time she gets a panic attack

Agree about all the support, unconditional love everything is fine but the basic handling is so wrong

But I guess any one in panic may have done that🤔orrrrr

Let's hope Abhir realises his folly soon..he's scared that no one will trust Mishti but he's to try first

Originally posted by: naq5

This is tricky.

A guy can come an attack and molest and attempt to rape a girl anytime anywhere but IF she hits in self defence and the guy dies or is severely injured there is a whole case on her where she has to go through police lawyers judiciary to prove herself that she did it in self defence. If the molester is dead there can still be a case on her by his family that she went too far in self defence and could be punished or jailed for it. All this will take up months of her life or maybe even years. Very much fair to the girl who did nothing wrong to be stuck in such a situation.

IDK if what Abir is doing is right. It's easy to say the face the judiciary but we all know how it runs how long it takes to get judgement and if the guys family is powerful how difficult it can get for the girl to prove innocence. All this she has to face coz a random guy one fine day decided to molest n rape her. Her entire life becomes at stake due to that one guy.

When Abir reached both ppl were unconscious mishti n the guy who tried to molest her. Did he know what happened between them. Did he even know mishti hit him in self defence. He just took mishti away without calling the ambulance to take the other unconscious/dead person away. Or maybe he called. If Abir left a random person to die without calling for help it would not be right. It wud have been better if they showed mishti running away to find Abir telling him everything, them coming back seeing the person dead and then mishti becoming unconscious n abir deciding to run away. I don't know what they have shown exactly in the episode though. I am yet to watch it.

Thanks for this post🤗

Yeah first I am disappointed too..then realized its easy to say how to handle when actually we are not in that situation..yeah agree with you when abir reached there both of them were unconcious..abir is not aware what exactly had happened when mishti gained concious then abir tried to reach that guy to check him suddenly he heard the sound of police vehicle..then he took mishti away this was only shown to us today..we have to wait to know what they did exactly

I dont think that the guy died becoz of mishti..more to that even though its becoz of her its not a crime what she did is selfdefecne..but the sad part is we have to prove that in court💔

Evyone plz stay calm na...Abir in his weakest mind set won't leave a person to die..Abir just wont do that..I'm sure there's more into that flashback...🤗🤗