Originally posted by: attiya1.3
Won't agree with all becoz not balanced from my pov..will comment on counter points
1. Asim ...yes was provoking...may be to over the line after one point but, is provocation against rules?
Never said it's against the rules. What I meant was from an audience's point of view. I'd pick Asim over Shukla in this fallout of theirs for two reasons. One, because it's personally great for me to watch someone give Shukla a taste of his own medicine. Asim being that one makes it even better. Two, because on the issues that have caused their fallout, Asim's reasons are admissible. Even if Asim's trying to build a formidable rivalry, his approach and methods aren't exactly working to his benefit completely. He's not winning brownie points because he has build up a case so good that everyone can side him, he is gaining support because someone's finally given Shukla the treatment he deserves. IMO, he shouldn't go behind Shukla time and again, to talk, to sort or to fight. Give it space. Give it a stable momentum. All this is based on my own understanding, I don't know what the statistics are when it comes to who has the maximum number of supporters out there.
2. Sallu didn't clear when mahira mentioned about first push by Asim...yeh bb edits MN nahi dekha sallu n k who pushed first. When he was clearly negating points which were wrong.
I don't remember as to who give the first push in the kitchen area but I do remember Shukla grabbing Asim's shirt/collar so tightly that the guy actually got hurt. Did you honestly expect Mahira to remember the turn of the events and recount them unbiased? She's right now pro-Shukla.
3. Physical on provocation was allowed in sallu books. What this means? It's Shukla weakness that he can't handle verbal games.
Wait. Are you under the impression that I stand by the Sallu rule book? PLEASE NO. I don't. At all. It's only the fact that this is the only episode that Shukla has received the most reprimanding till date. No matter how diluted or civil. And this is honestly as much as Salman will do it either because he personally likes Shukla or doesn't see anything wrong with the guy or because he's bound to follow the channel's protocol/instructions. From what I feel, I don't really think he likes Shukla as such (anymore). Yeah, he goes all pyaar se puchkarna when it comes to him but I think that's more on the channel than on him.
4. Himanshi doesnot deserve that humiliation. Yes push was unnecessary but all other stuff...totally wrong
I did say Himanshi got too much of unnecessary flak today, didn't I?
5. Sana, Paras, mahira should had been reprimanded equally.they were instigators.
I mentioned Sana. I didn't mention Paras and Mahira on this because there's only so much that one WKW episode allotted for discussing the issues can do. Paras and Mahira as such haven't violated the rules or showed aggression beyond a limit they deem permissible or engaged in huge fights of their own. Sure, if it were upto me I'd totally question the sudden pyaar, ishq aur mohabbat for Shukla.
Cricket
