Yaariyan #7 ~ Yaariyan ke baad humari Yaariyan - Page 117

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

40.4k

Users

14

Likes

524

Frequent Posters

sami011 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

u know some times I feel they just edited it so badly and it was not really rape but more forced consummation,where she never really resisted him,all they needed was to show her thinking that she never resisted as she wanted him to not go after her sister as now it would be gunah...us se sab sahi rehta..writer could have gotten some comfort that it was forced initialization of relationship but also that if she did not consent,she never resisted...but they confused everyone for the whole show...

sami011 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
lol this guy is cute narcissist...loves his own looks way too much but still I miss him and momal ....
Ruby7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: sami011

lol this guy is cute narcissist...loves his own looks way too much but still I miss him and momal ....

Yeah i miss his and Momal chemistry. They left such an impact on our minds that we want to watch more of them. But this time no compromises on the script. It needs to be worth it. I rather wait for something substantial than wanting them to do something below their level. Sorry if i sound picky

Edited by Ruby7 - 6 years ago
Ruby7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: sami011

u know some times I feel they just edited it so badly and it was not really rape but more forced consummation,where she never really resisted him,all they needed was to show her thinking that she never resisted as she wanted him to not go after her sister as now it would be gunah...us se sab sahi rehta..writer could have gotten some comfort that it was forced initialization of relationship but also that if she did not consent,she never resisted...but they confused everyone for the whole show...

sadia never ever told her mom or pyari behen about it..She kept it between herself umair and aaliya. Rape was underplayed in the show to maximum level.

Sami do you rem the scene before aaliya told umair that zubi is lieing about sadia ahmer. There both sadia umair were in the hall and she she gives him tea..He was miffed but still took the tea from her. She told him about the doc appointment and he told her to take her mother with her. He was so angry yet was controlling himself. I feel that time he had again started to doubt baby being his.

sami011 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Ruby7

sadia never ever told her mom or pyari behen about it..She kept it between herself umair and aaliya. Rape was underplayed in the show to maximum level.

Sami do you rem the scene before aaliya told umair that zubi is lieing about sadia ahmer. There both sadia umair were in the hall and she she gives him tea..He was miffed but still took the tea from her. She told him about the doc appointment and he told her to take her mother with her. He was so angry yet was controlling himself. I feel that time he had again started to doubt baby being his.

yes he was doubting again at that time,you know writer had in her mind this not as martial rape(which is stupid to extreme in my opinion) but in her quest to show that only reason Umair was doubting the baby was because of not remembering the encounter itself and also from old days when Zoobie used to rant about sadia.In that quest she made it look like rape,I agree next day way they showed it,looked like rape.but way sadia and even aaliya behaved it was more like a domestic situation of husband asserting his rights on his wife while being drunk.See rape is what they showed in ruswai..it damages you till your soul and somehow even forceful relationship with husband is not as traumatic as eg a rape done by family member,person of trust or gang rape etc...they needed to handle it properly.I consider it their major faliure...

Umair was insecure about sadia but he was always there for her at every step of the way.both Ahmer and zeenat claimed to do something to restore Sadia's honor but it was done by umair as khuda intended....their's was a meant to be relationship and it is so sad that makers butchered it in beginning with rape story.Rest doubt and all
I get it as it is drama ,they had to show something....

sami011 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Ruby7

Yeah i miss his and Momal chemistry. They left such an impact on our minds that we want to watch more of them. But this time no compromises on the script. It needs to be worth it. I rather wait for something substantial than wanting them to do something below their level. Sorry if i sound picky

me too would rather wait for a good story...am sucker for sad biwis so may be thoda sa haq for now will be ok,am not sure how will it be when he gets married to biwi no 2
Ruby7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: sami011

me too would rather wait for a good story...am sucker for sad biwis so may be thoda sa haq for now will be ok,am not sure how will it be when he gets married to biwi no 2

One husband 2 wives is something I avoid watching Bec I don't think they have ever handled it with dignity. They will end up butchering one for the other..I am hanging on to tsh until the twist is shown..once it's shown then I will pass my judgement after seeing how it was executed..

Good story is a must Bec they they is scope to discuss and analyse then. right now they is no show on air which I think would have suited them and their chemistry.. the characters need to connect with the viewer. I don't know what's in the director and ph mind. The director should have not increased hopes of fans by saying soon if nothing was in pipeline. He even said they are doing project without zubi and ahmer. Mazak karna tha toh koi aur karta?

Ruby7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: sami011

yes he was doubting again at that time,you know writer had in her mind this not as martial rape(which is stupid to extreme in my opinion) but in her quest to show that only reason Umair was doubting the baby was because of not remembering the encounter itself and also from old days when Zoobie used to rant about sadia.In that quest she made it look like rape,I agree next day way they showed it,looked like rape.but way sadia and even aaliya behaved it was more like a domestic situation of husband asserting his rights on his wife while being drunk.See rape is what they showed in ruswai..it damages you till your soul and somehow even forceful relationship with husband is not as traumatic as eg a rape done by family member,person of trust or gang rape etc...they needed to handle it properly.I consider it their major faliure...

Umair was insecure about sadia but he was always there for her at every step of the way.both Ahmer and zeenat claimed to do something to restore Sadia's honor but it was done by umair as khuda intended....their's was a meant to be relationship and it is so sad that makers butchered it in beginning with rape story.Rest doubt and all
I get it as it is drama ,they had to show something....

Doubt was ok but then sana is right that if he remembered physical encounter with her and still ended up doubting her with ahmer, it would be more sick. They showed him not remember it and then all the doubting. It was shown to exaggerate and increase sadia pain even more. I am sure audience would have felt bad for her most..The writer did the trick that's why show worked really well. Though i must admit if muneeb momal weren't playing umair sadia then I don't think I would have watched the show. They made the most difficult scenes interesting to watch..

But storywise it relevant that he completely tilted towards sadia after that.. He even took zubi pic with himself to annoy Sadia. Umair made many mistakes but he was sincere and real. No fakeness..he could have used sadia to get back at zubi the way ahmer tried to do but he didn't. He rather ran behind her always to know the truth about the baby. He came to.his senses fully at the end and I guess it was shown that way to show that without aaliya being there still sadia umair were together and happy.. this time no compromises.. The destiny couple they were..

sami011 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Ruby7

Doubt was ok but then sana is right that if he remembered physical encounter with her and still ended up doubting her with ahmer, it would be more sick. They showed him not remember it and then all the doubting. It was shown to exaggerate and increase sadia pain even more. I am sure audience would have felt bad for her most..The writer did the trick that's why show worked really well. Though i must admit if muneeb momal weren't playing umair sadia then I don't think I would have watched the show. They made the most difficult scenes interesting to watch..

But storywise it relevant that he completely tilted towards sadia after that.. He even took zubi pic with himself to annoy Sadia. Umair made many mistakes but he was sincere and real. No fakeness..he could have used sadia to get back at zubi the way ahmer tried to do but he didn't. He rather ran behind her always to know the truth about the baby. He came to.his senses fully at the end and I guess it was shown that way to show that without aaliya being there still sadia umair were together and happy.. this time no compromises.. The destiny couple they were..

yes if he remembered and then doubted ,it would look too disgusting.I agree that this trick makers used was to redeem him later,another thing going for him was that he was always honest.whatever he thought he never ever did any planning.He said he would but never did.I also was surprised he never told zoobie about doubts of parentage and all.Ahmer i could not forgive for this reason of marrying zoobie .Umair was all about sadia from day he got married to her,yes he was sad about zoobie but only for short time,rest of the time it was all about sadia.

chemistry was simply out of this world..

sami011 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Ruby7

One husband 2 wives is something I avoid watching Bec I don't think they have ever handled it with dignity. They will end up butchering one for the other..I am hanging on to tsh until the twist is shown..once it's shown then I will pass my judgement after seeing how it was executed..

Good story is a must Bec they they is scope to discuss and analyse then. right now they is no show on air which I think would have suited them and their chemistry.. the characters need to connect with the viewer. I don't know what's in the director and ph mind. The director should have not increased hopes of fans by saying soon if nothing was in pipeline. He even said they are doing project without zubi and ahmer. Mazak karna tha toh koi aur karta?

ya lest see episode 3 was good,i do feel we will see them together soon..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".