Created

Last reply

Replies

116

Views

14.5k

Users

18

Likes

138

Frequent Posters

inlieu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: LoveInAutumn26

Wait what???? HS called Mini his father to impress Babita the whole time?!?!?! Are we watching the same show? 😲

Doesn't look like it. Was he also trying to impress Babita in the hospital when he was freaking out about Minnie or sleeping on the bench?

Edited by inlieu - 6 years ago
asmaanixx thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#22

Okay, this is what I understand from the promo:

HS asks Babes why did she feel so hurt by what he and Kammo said. Although, she may not said the full truth, but there is some elements that are.

She asks him if he called himself Minnie's father and he says yes, to make her happy and reassure her.

Babita says, how Minnie kept thinking that it was genuine all this time to which HS says that no, that's not the case. Veer Balika had understood a long time ago.

Babes says how she's feeling hurt from hearing all this. She questions him if he has never considered Minnie as his daughter.

And then we'll get HS' clarification.

So, from all this, what I'm understanding is that he used the official father tag to keep Babita happy, not everything else. He didn't become Minnie's dad as a means of impressing Babes. He took the step of using the title so that Babita knew for a fact what his and Minnie's relationship is that if she chooses, she can build one with him. Take that extra step, connect herself with him and complete their little family. Otherwise, they were all fine living as they were.

At least, this is what I'm understanding from it. I don't see any malice in HS' words or actions. He seems to be pretty calm here. So I dunno if she says something to piss him off or Minnie.

Jiarao thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: inlieu

I know what you mean but I think even if he decides to go this way it will be because of Minnie and because he resigns and understands that there should be no compulsion in relationships. He won't stop loving her as a father, though. People like him feel deeply and don't just flip a switch on their emotions. I don't even want to think of how much it's going to hurt him. Not being wanted by the lady you love is one thing but not being wanted or loved by the one you consider your child must be painful.

I feel pain just thinking about this. Mhaara kaleja chidh jaata hai.

I know.... my point is why he has to love her like daughter when she doesn't love him as her father? It's more than enough if he loves her as his veerbalika. He has already done everything for her without even asking anything in return and its much more than any father would do.

At one time I too wanted them to be father-daughter in real sense. Now I don't think its necessary for him to consider Mini as his daughter to love her. He will love her anyway. I want him to accept her as daughter only when she accepts him as father.

naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#24

Ok during puja when he declared himself as minis father he was doing it to reassure babita but what about the countless times he has called himself her father before mini. Or was he trying to get the father daughter relation going for babitas sake where as he was actually happy being HS uncle and she veerbalika for him. Or is he trying to explain to babes that not all relations need a name to be special. that inspite of not being father daughter he and mini have a special relation of their own.

Yes he was worried during hospital track and has cared for mini first untill the marriage, but not necessarily he did it as a father. He could do it because he just cared for her and loved her

guddi01 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#25

Lol. You are missing the point.

Babita has been butchered as a Mother to justify Mini pain as she is Katha Kottage favourite now HS because as well as Katha Kottage loves Mini so we have Romeo Mickey waiting in the wings to take over from HS montage.

So PB is now based solely on cheating and deceit of Soulmate Love of Mini and Mickey. Who are so pure and honest with each other, hence the passionate hug with Mickey in public with Preeti present.

Happy endings.

Why the others don't leave the show as its getting worse, better to jump than sink.

Srilata.Mineil thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: asmaanixx

Okay, this is what I understand from the promo:

HS asks Babes why did she feel so hurt by what he and Kammo said. Although, she may not said the full truth, but there is some elements that are.

She asks him if he called himself Minnie's father and he says yes, to make her happy and reassure her.

Babita says, how Minnie kept thinking that it was genuine all this time to which HS says that no, that's not the case. Veer Balika had understood a long time ago.

Babes says how she's feeling hurt from hearing all this. She questions him if he has never considered Minnie as his daughter.

And then we'll get HS' clarification.

So, from all this, what I'm understanding is that he used the official father tag to keep Babita happy, not everything else. He didn't become Minnie's dad as a means of impressing Babes. He took the step of using the title so that Babita knew for a fact what his and Minnie's relationship is that if she chooses, she can build one with him. Take that extra step, connect herself with him and complete their little family. Otherwise, they were all fine living as they were.

At least, this is what I'm understanding from it. I don't see any malice in HS' words or actions. He seems to be pretty calm here. So I dunno if she says something to piss him off or Minnie.

Exactly... Even without hanita marriage Hannie were baap beti as per him just to assure her that taking a step forward is made think about Minni then by saying him Minni father in the Pooja was to make her assured about Hannie....

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: naq5

Ok during puja when he declared himself as minis father he was doing it to reassure babita but what about the countless times he has called himself her father before mini. Or was he trying to get the father daughter relation going for babitas sake where as he was actually happy being HS uncle and she veerbalika for him. Or is he trying to explain to babes that not all relations need a name to be special. that inspite of not being father daughter he and mini have a special relation of their own.

Yes he was worried during hospital track and has cared for mini first untill the marriage, but not necessarily he did it as a father. He could do it because he just cared for her and loved her

@bold: That is likely how the discussion will conclude.

Given the fact that upcoming is all random HB romance and Babita ke headaches or whatever, HS-Mini ka issue will be wrapped up with one token scene of how their relationship doesn’t need a name.

That will be enough to make everyone “happy” for now and then on to next drama 😆

Father-daughter wala angle will be put on the back burner.

Waise toh many here predicted this as a possibility a while back but the execution is just severely lacking these days. 🤷‍♀️

Mannmohanaa thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: inlieu

What does he mean? That he doesn't consider her his daughter or that he doesn't want that relationship?

Why do they have to ruin this? Why can't they be father-daughter after everything that was shown? Was it all a lie? I'm heartbroken.

I don't know Jean. I'm feeling be fooled and tricked. They've cheated us. HS called Mini his daughter just to assure Babita?

GOD SAVE ME!!!

And he says that Mini understands that. What the hell was GP? And why is Mini so heartbroken over it if she wanted it to be this way?

Can someone tell me what and who is a father?

Like how do you define that relation?

Mannmohanaa thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#29

Why did they fool us with that label if it was never supposed to be meant that way? They shouldn't have addressed it that way from the beginning.

Mannmohanaa thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: inlieu

I hope the CVs don't forget that he felt and acted as a father in every sense of the word. Please.

EXACTLY!

He has been her father always, label it or not, but he's been a true dad. Don't know the other way round though.

Related Topics

Patiala Babes thumbnail

Posted by: Anj_01 · 5 years ago

Hii friends, I am back with another story on Miniel. This is totally unrelated to the show. I am posting first part here tell me if you liked it...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".