HE WAS NEVER SERIOUS ABOUT HER...

i was watching episode 15 or 16 of Warrior high featuring fab 5( merger episode ) there was a flashback of manik talking to some girl called Veebha. manik said to her " hamari bhee kafi beautiful memories ban sakti thi if you know what i mean. she said " haan , ban sakti thi lekin hamari beautiful memories kisi aur ke liye sad ban jati. "

she reminds her that aliya loves him. and with some regret he says " yah . of course "

do you guys remember in episode 163 where nandini arranged a cute little surprise for him. he started talking about this " v ". then let it go.

so basically he was with aliya bcoz he knew about her feelings, not bcoz he genuinely loved her. thats why he could break up with her with one mistake on her part . whereas he forgave nandini bcoz he truely loves nandini and he will forgive her later as well !