Critics Corner

REVIEW: 'Aarambh' is the RISE of Indian television, but has its own LIMITATIONS!

You see grandeur, you see splendor and you see something else too..

2017-06-26T11:31:00Z


Welcome to a world that portrays an unknown saga! The mega blockbuster Baahubali franchise spawned off an equally mega show like Aarambh, which touted to explore the story of Devsena. The historic war between the Dravidians and the Aryans was given birth owing to a plethora of happenings and that is what is Aarambh is all about.

Probably the most expensive show in recent times, the promos raised an instant intrigue and caught one's eye. We were witnessing something absolutely novel, especially when it comes to the gigantic canvas of the show.

The show finally went on-air and now 2 episodes down, I will take into account the several factors and whether or not, Aarambh manages to impress.

The Story So Far.



In some illusions and horoscope-looking visuals, a voiceover explains to us about how Sapt Sindhu is the place to be. Apparently, it's so important that the monumental fight of Dravidians and Aryans happened to claim the throne of the Sapt Sindhu! Looking at the visuals of the place, I don't blame them. It's ginormous and opulent as nothing can be.



Coming back, there is a huge fire pit where the head purohit is chanting some mantras and explains how Lord Indra has given them the signs that the clan has to leave for the Sapt Sindhu. Also, there is a never-ending line of people surrounding the pit (where probably 15-20 are real ones, the rest are there thanks to the green screen). The purohit explains that the God of Light (Melisandre reference is obvious here) has also granted them permission to go and find fertile land for the Aryan clan. He assigns Veer Kayast (Tarun Khanna) to lead the troupe and the man's ultimate goal, to lead his men, has been achieved.

Now, there is a Jon Snow doppelganger Varundev (of course, he is the lead here too) (Rajneesh Duggal) who is a brave, honorable and determined fighter. He wants to find fertile land and establish their clan there just like the others, which is a huge task. However, he awaits Veer Kayast's hopes of choosing him to be a part of the troupe. After a little drama of 'he will choose me, he will choose me not', Veer Kayast does choose Varundev.

On their way through the Wall and Wildings (oh sorry, went Game Of Thrones-y again); on their way through frozen mountains, they face cold storms which make you feel cold too.(probably!) Veer Kayast slips and is about to fall just when Varundev saves him. And looking at the weather, they decide to camp and wait for the time to pass. Now, it's morning again and they are ready to go. However, wildling looking people called Nimchas are coming and they literally eat humans, so they have to be fought and killed. After some completely unimpressive fight scenes, Kayast is about to die after being stabbed, when Varundev holds him and Kayast stabs Nimcha throwing him off the cliff. A bruised Kayast feels indebted to Varundev and the latter decides to pick and carry him up on his back for the rest of the journey.



After a flashback scene of Kayast and his father, Varundev with Kayast on his back and the rest of the troupe, cross the mountain and they can see the Sapt Sindhu area. Kayast is amazed and smiles, but also knows that he is going to die anytime soon. In the most quintessential sequences, a dying Kayast hands over his sword to Varundev and alas! Kayast is dead. A shocked and now even more determined Varundev announces that 'Hey there Dravidians, we are coming!'



And now welcome to the Dravidian civilization which is as rich and affluent as the Lannisters in King's Landing. Also here, it is the women in the family who rule and become the successors to the throne eventually. However, there is no Tyrion, Jaime or Cersei here, but there is one lady who could give Petyr Baelish a run for his money and that is Dayalini (Haansaa Singh). The Dravidian kingdom has lost their queen Chamundi and now the rightful heir to the throne is her daughter, Devsena. But the latter is a small kid and cannot rule so soon (not everyone can be Lyanna Mormont). So, Dayalini wants to sit on the throne and rule but is stopped from doing so as she has no claim over it, inspite of being Devsena's aunt.



Now Dayalini has her set of bitching servants who help her in plotting her claim to the throne. Dayalini has done it all; from trying to kill Devsena to plan her rise to the throne, to being damned and much more. However, one of the bitching servants tells that even though Hahumaa (Tanuja Mukherji) loves Devsena, she will not let Devsena become a queen, as she is made to believe that Devsena is not fitting for the throne. Ah! By the way, Hahumaa is 400 years old. Yes!



Cut to a grown up Devsena (Karthika Nair), who establishes to the viewers that she is ferocious and doesn't fear anything by out-swimming a crocodile and doing some aerial stunts. And Dayalini is at her cunning best trying to make Hahumaa believe that Devsena is immature as she is too speedy and does dangerous things, putting the realm at risk and also how she is not going to be a good queen as the people are not scared of her etc. Everything is answered straightly by Hahumaa and Devsena's father at different intervals.



Now, Devsena is also a rebel and she wants to know and enter the prohibited area at Sapt Sindhu as prophesied by Hahumaa that if she goes there, the destruction era of Dravidian clan will begin as it will serve as an entry for their enemy. And that's when Varundev also arrives at the same spot. Devsena and Varundev look at each other and you know a war is going to come up. After some trash talking, Varundev and Devsena are ready and strike their weapons flying in the air.

Cut to the funeral ceremony of Veer Kayast, where the whole Aryan clan are paying their respects and that is when one of the Aryan men, Abhrook (Vipul Gupta) revolts about how Veer Kayast doesn't have his sword and it's a disgrace to not respect a dead man without his sword. That is also when he learns that Varundev has Kayast's sword and that it was Kayast's dying wish that Varundev keeps it and also succeeds him. However, it is later decided that this will happen only after a fair competition between Varundev and the other candidates.



In the meantime, there are some sweet moments between Devsena and her father after which, the coronation ceremony of Devsena is being planned. But, Dayalini and her pupils have their master plan all set, to spoil the ceremony. The entry of Hahumaa in the kingdom is nothing short of an affair, where the coronation ceremony is an absolute splendor. Amidst all this, Hahumaa is getting all the signs about the ceremony being jinxed. And the same is sealed when the buffalo, which was set to be used for the ceremony falls flat, which was obviously planned by Dayalini and her servant-pupil. Thus, Hahumaa announces that the ceremony has to be canceled right away and there will be no coronation.



Simultaneously, the competition to become the new leader of the Aryavarths, is on and needless to say, Varundev wins the competition after a bravura performance and some acrobatic skills too. If you felt sad about Devsena's coronation being canceled, you can have some respite in the form of Varundev's mini coronation as he is now the leader of the Aryan clan, who will lead to capture the Sapta Sindhu. 

And finally, after all this, Hahumaa puts her mind to work and wonders that someone is trying to kill Devsena and her obvious options are Dayalini and an Aryan. But she gets bamboozled on the thought that her father, Arvamadhan can also be one of them.

Thus begins the game of betrayal, backstabbing and claim to the throne for one and capturing of lands for the other! Too Game of Thrones-y? That's how it is. Will Devsena's coronation take place? How will Varundev plan his war against the Dravidians? Is Arvamadhan really the loving father that he acts to be? Only time will tell.

Rating - *** (3/5)

What's Good?



This point comes as a mandate given the scale of the show. The show's visuals are resplendent and extravagant. It is no secret how the show is a mega budget one and the money seems to be put to good use, as the locations and the cinematography of the same is stunning and the spectacle is worth watching.



Finally, we can say that we are witnessing good CGI effects in an Indian TV show! The effects in the show are completely believable and does fool the eye in the apt manner. Look at that croc! It looks more real than Rakhi Sawant on the whole! (Sarcasm not intended)



The screenplay is captivating as you have action rather frequently, which is good as it keeps you engaged in this otherwise convoluted show.

What's Not-So-Good?



Taking lead from the last point mentioned above, the plot and the dialogues are extremely convoluted for Indian audience to endure. Of course, we don't expect youth slangs, but the treatment of dialogues needs to be simplified for better interpretation. Infact, there is a bit of disconnect too, where Varundev and Devsena clash at the end of the episode and the next episode begins with Kayast's funeral ceremony.

The tempo of the show drops drastically from the first episode and it even becomes apparent when the scenes at the Dravidian kingdom are portrayed. Also, there are too many flashbacks in the show which leave you disoriented as a viewer. 

There is a lot of reference to the popular epic drama, Game Of Thrones. OK, I understand how this was rather predictable for some of you that Aarambh will be compared to Game Of Thrones and that it is not fair to do so etc. But, I wouldn't have been considering it, if there were not so OBVIOUS 'similarities' between the two. Especially, the Nimcha and Aryan clan fight scene makes you remember the Watchers on the Wall and 'Wildling-meets-White Walkers' time and again. So, even though this doesn't spoil the plot line completely, such obvious references to yet another Hollywood saga was the last thing expected out of Aarambh. Here are some proofs of the same-

Be it the Jon Snow poses and looks


Or the entry to Westeros-


And the Nimchas' costumes seem to be borrowed from the wildlings-


Three Eyed Raven must be missing having snakes around him-


Veer Kayast couldn't have burned in a better way than that of Mance Rayder's-


Rating - ** (2/5)

The Performances



To begin with actor Tarun Khanna aka Veer Kayast manages to put in a decent performance as the Lord Commander. However, now that his character is dead, we wonder was it for an episode only? Probably not. We will have to wait and see.



Rajneesh Duggal as Varundev looks fierce and is impressive playing the man who has to take over the reigns in an unanticipated manner and has to lead his troupe. There is a sense of discomfort when it comes to the times, where he has to be subtle and mellow, but that will certainly get better with the future episodes as we will see a lot of action apart from mellow scenes.



Karthika Nair as Devsena is fantastic. She has to sport a confident smile and still manage to not look overconfident, which is done exceedingly well. Her comfort with the action sequences, portrays the level of hard work and practice she must have put in to get that ease. As the titular character, Karthika is fabulous and leaves a lasting impact.



Tanuja Samarth Mukherji makes her television debut with this show and the veteran is no stranger to acting, having given some of the most memorable performances. Here, she plays a 400 year old woman wearing snakes and doing prophecies. She is good and what's best about her is her voice, which is also used as the voice over when the show begins.

The rest of the cast which include Dayalini (Haansaa Singh), Devsena's father (Joy Sengupta) and the plethora of supporting actors manage to give decent performances which lift the show up.

Rating - ***1/2 (3.5/5)

The Verdict



As intriguing as the base plot of the show sounds and appears, one of the biggest drawbacks of the show is the treatment of the main plot. The screenplay is too convoluted and can be difficult for the Indian viewers to endure such 'heavy' lines and scenes. Having said that, Aarambh is a celebration of new age of television and ups the ante to the maximum, where we can be proud that Indian TV gave us a show like Aarambh. The grandiose of the show is an absolute treat to the eyes. We were watching a revolution on television and the obvious faults in the show can be given a skip, for the sake of someone daring to have the guts to make a show like this in India. Hats Off for that Sir!

Rating - *** (3/5)

What do you have to say about the show? Leave in your comments below...

8 Likes

Tarun Khanna Tanuja Samarth Joy Sengupta Rajneesh Duggal Karthika Nair Aarambh  Star Plus 


Comments (14)

View all
Nichuss
Nichuss 3 years ago 100 % agreeing to the article... this is really a best VFX grand currently aired in tellyworld... crocodile as article say is the best example...
i too had a confusion with 1st epsd end and 2nd eps start... it was nt connecting at all...

may be from 2nd epsd the real story. started the flashback and may gradually reach to the situation shown on 1st epsd...

nicely written article...
lovely_lady
lovely_lady 3 years ago Not a big fan of this article. The reference to Rakhi Sawant was completely unnecessary and unneeded. In fact, it was rude.

Secondly, the whole comparison thing to GOT is stupid. Half of the images compared to GOT are in fact not originally created by GOT. For example, the whole person burning echoes the persecution of witches in the States vs. that of Mance Rayder. Same with the whole snakes on the shoulder post -- that's a classic indian reference to ichadari naag/naagins and/or homage to Shiva who is often depicted with snakes (esp on shoulder). Plus, the nimchas costumes are reminiscent of Northern Native populations (that actually exist and wear such clothes) rather than GOT. These are only three things and there's many more.

Article would've been much better off without the comparison and with some proper editing.
*Dev.*
*Dev.* 3 years ago This writer who is not even mentioned in the article is SO obsessed with Game of thrones that he/she has not only compared but tried his/her level best to tarnish the image of Aarambh. This review does not look apt as it compares more. Even though things look similar to GOT,the stories are completely different. Indian viewers can for sure enjoy watching it. The sarcasm at times appears funny but this whole review appears sarcastic.
BabyHimavari
BabyHimavari 3 years ago Well true to say I have never been through GOT till now. But I can bet that Arambh is not a screen to screen copy of the nemesis. It has its own charm and more over the show at least deserves 4 star in rating. 3 star is like a medicore rating for such a show like Arambh which is a milestone for Indian Tv itself.
Shaina_b
Shaina_b 3 years ago The VFX is fabulous!!!!

God of Light, yes it did remind me of Game of Thrones!!!!

The mountain portions was totally like GoT and wildlings, even here Lord Commander have Jon Snow his sword!!!!

Like Jon went through an election, even Varundev had to go through the obstacle course!!!!

I loved the Dravidian society!!!!It is fantastic, just like the Amazons!!!!

Devsena is fabulous and perfect to be a queen!!!!Glad to have a heroine like her on TV!!!!

I liked the scenes between Devsena and her father!!!!

You have not been watching carefully else you would know Varundev-Devsena scene was a vision of Hahumaa!!!!

Game of Thrones is an iconic show and I would be happy if Aarambh manages to copy it well!!!!

That was the entry to Essos and not Westeros, and I don't think this is similar!!!!It is natural to have a gate with their sigil!!!!

Yes Hahumaa is a lot like Three Eyed Raven!!!!

Veer Kayast's funeral reminded me of GoT but it also reminded me of a Viking Funeral!!!!

Karthika Nair is fantastic as Devsena!!!!

Of course the screenplay is too much to take in for Indian critics/audiences as they can't understand anyting other than saas-bahu or hero and heroines who fight like kids!!!!

I can't believe you gave 3 to Aarambh!!!!It deserves 4 or 4.5 at least!!!!

You gave 3 to that trash Chandrakanta just because it is by Ekta!!!!Honestly how can both these shows have the same rating??




candy02
candy02 3 years ago Why IF is so obsessed over GoT!! The concept of Aarambh is totally different than that of GoT and GoT itself is inspired by many books. Any show can have a couple of similar scenes w.r.t. any other, but that does not imply that the former has been influenced or is a copy/paste!!! Very unfair!!!
The grandeur of the show, the pace, the VFX and the acting - all are top-notch.. Considering the first two episodes, it has got every chance to be a real trend-setter on ITV. The way Dravidian women have been portrayed is extremely impressive; a very welcome change from the usual all-problem-solving, relationship counsellor, mahaatma dutiful bahu, who digests every abuse been thrown towards her by the ML in the name of "love".
All the best to the whole team of Aarambh...2017-06-26 12:43:55
adityarox
adityarox 3 years ago hey IF kya apko colors ne paise die hai kya chandrakanta jaise bakwaas show ko 3 stars and aarambh jaise great show ko bhi sirf 3 star dene k lie i think ye aur chandrakanta ka review likhnewala writer 100% ekta ke saas bahu soaps ka hardcore fan hoga
LawlessLawyer
LawlessLawyer 3 years ago Whoever wrote this article should quit writing once and for all.

What is this obsession of comparing each and every thing with GoT?? Aarambh is nowhere related to GoT.Its a story with an identity of it own.As an avid GoT fan myself I can vouch for that.

GoT itself is inspired from many historicals events and epics.
A show like Aarambh is a game changer on Indian TV.It doesn't deserve to be demeaned in such a manner.2017-06-26 11:57:21
Fairy_KimBokJoo
Fairy_KimBokJoo 3 years ago This review is absolutely awful. Do you guys know something apart from GOT, which had/has very little original elements and thrives on perpetuating violence against women? Such an absurd comparison without a singular valid point. Either, review the show properly or do a pointless and invalid comparison post. Don't attempt to be both. Terrible.2017-06-26 11:46:21
Annabelle96
Annabelle96 3 years ago Nothing say about this poorly written review or I should say an exaggerated comparison with GoT.
IF seriously need to put an end to their shitty biasedness.They gave 4 in the performance of the actors in Colors Ck just bcus it is of EK 's PH here just 3.5 in spite of of the talented bunch of cast playing in Aarambh.
I would have given 4.5 out of 5 in the overall ratings instead of a mere 3 points.Looking forward to weekends.
see more
TOP