City of Gold - Movie Review
A gritty take on how a slice of South -Mumbai got revamped by taking away pretty much everything that the mill workers had
Published: Friday,Apr 23, 2010 18:30 PM GMT-06:00
Cast: Seema Biswas, Karan Patel, Sameer Dharmadhikari, Kashmira Shah
Director:Mahesh Manjrekar
City of Gold – In your face
Step by step violence and vice take prominence. Naru is shown hitting a mutton shop owner. Manju's beautician friend tells her to take it slowly with her rich boyfriend. The logic behind it – 'In paisewaalon ko kaato; phir baato.' Mohan swindles 25000 over betting in cricket match. The grime piles up more as the frames flash by. Manju has pre-marital sex with Jignesh. During Ganpati Visarjan, Bajirao shoots someone. Mohan sleeps with a neighboring Mami (Kashmira Shah). To make matters seem more yuck, Mami is shown justifying her act with a speech that comes out in bits and pieces on her way to orgasm.
After interval, the trend of escalating goriness only gets severe. The scenes are so strong, it takes you on a trance. It's a hypnotic vortex that strangles you to the point of suffocation. It's not easy to handle to this bitter pill.
A lot of things go on at the same time and for the major part of the film, the focus drifts away from the problems of mill workers to the shady activities their loved ones got involved in. The negativity has been over-exaggerated to get supreme effect of shock value of imagery. Yes, you can see shades of cannibalism sprouting up among the children and prostitution as key to escape poverty for the women.
The songs are outdated, can't complain there as it could be to add authenticity. The dialogues are sleazy. Get this- A asks B - Who's that with your wife, a relative? B answers - That's dessert for you. There's no relief of humor. No positivity. Just bleak desperation and gross bloodshed.
If I'm not too wrong, then not all kids of mill workers went on to become gangsters. There were some who did cling onto education to make it big in the corporate sector, the offices of which now thrive in South Mumbai. Mr. Manjrekar could've brought an angle of positivity while exhibiting the injustice done to the workers. Or maybe, that was never what the film was about…just a phrase to spin promotions, eh?
If you can handle dark and wholly negative films, you may give it a try.
Rating: **
Reporter and Author: Susan Jose
Your reaction
Nice
Awesome
Loved
LOL
OMG
Cry
Fail
Comments (3)