Hindi Tv

'C-2007 is over, so lets move on now' - Vishal & Shekhar

SaReGaMaPa C-2007 is over and yet it is a hot topic of discussion. This time it's the results and their validity in question.

Published: Wednesday,Oct 24, 2007 13:47 PM GMT-06:00
facebook twitter whatsapp

Even though the show is over and the winner declared, it is not accepted by all. A few issues are still cropping up with regards to fairness in voting, thereby questioning the validity of the results. A lot of questions are being raised on Raja not winning the show, despite being more popular, and that both the mentors of Raja are miffed with the channel house on the issue. We decided to talk to his mentors Vishal and Shekhar and get their views on the issue.

C-2007 is over, so lets move on now - Vishal & Shekhar
Vishal Dadlani, one of the mentors of Raja feels Zee never did any cheating as far as voting goes. “I am very clear of the fact that Zee was very transparent, and very straightforward as far as votes are concerned. My only issue is with the voting software’s used by all fans as that I consider as cheating. I do believe that Aneek deserved to win, and I have no negativity against him. I hope people would support him and also Raja and Amanat as all three are really good.” So what about Aneek’s victory? “Aneek won fair and square. I do believe Raja and Amanat both also deserved to win, as much as Aneek deserved to win. I have no problem that Aneek won. I definitely think there was no cheating involved. The sad part I feel is, Aneek is getting lot of negative publicity because he won which is actually quite tragic. We should all be sporting enough, and we should all congratulate him and move on now. This is not the end of anyone’s existence. I feel people should support Aneek as of now, and I would request them to support even Raja and Amanat.”

C-2007 is over, so lets move on now - Vishal & Shekhar
Shekhar also had similar views but has some reservations against this public voting format in itself. “For me SRGMP is now over. People have made their decision. Aneek won fair, no questions there. But at the same I feel all of them deserved to win. Also, I personally feel that voting, winning doesn’t make a difference. At the end of the day, the singer has to become a professional, has to become among the top five singer of the industry.” He had a message for all who had voted for the contestants during the show. “People who have voted are all well wishers of these contestants. They are voting, taking their precious time and money out to vote for them as they want to see them big in the industry. I don’t think 80% of these very voters would want them to now disappear after the contest. They want to hear more of the singers. I would like to thank them all, irrespective of whose fan they are, for spending so much time on these contestants.” So who was better according to him? “If I had to choose, I would have gone for maybe Amanat. Because, I feel he is the one who is the most talented one and ready for playback singing. Raja still needs to get bit more experience, even though we are just now recording a song of his for one of our forthcoming movie. Aneek is still young. But he is a very very talented young boy.”

Now that the show is finally over, what do both feel aboutl some controversies that are coming out? Vishal had a very straightforward reply, “What I feel is that there’s so much love for these kids that it has gone mad beyond anyone’s expectations. Reason being all three were so good.” Shekhar in turn wished something that maybe all music lovers are wishing for long. “Personally I feel SRGMP needs to go back to its old format where eminent music personalities as judges make the decisions. And we have decided that if we do SRGMP C-2008, we’ll make sure to go back to the old format. We already informed the channel house about it, and they are also now thinking on this issue. The credibility of this show, when the SRGMP started was that only really good singers come out from this show. People actually die to watch SRGMP not for glamour, drama or us but for pure music. That is our Indian crowd and I really appreciate them for this.”

So this lays to rest the controversies about Vishal-Shekhar being miffed with Zee Channel. They both want that now, everyone should move on. But one thing is clear. With judges like Shekhar and Vishal as part of this show, viewers can now keep their hopes alive to see a better format on this show, a format that can be related to just music.

Reporter: Barnali
Author: Barnali

ALSO READ: Indian Idol Judges Vishal Dadlani and Kumar Sanu compete for Sonali Bendre's affection on India's Best Dancer

Comments (29)

View all
rose @rose82 16 years ago Srija has taken the matter too far.We all respect Chiranjeevi so much...she hasnt thought of her father,his image at all....she has thought only of herself.love is blind,deaf and dumb really
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
Ammu @ammmu 16 years ago Yess... Shekhar picked Amanat!! :) Very nice article, and very true also what they said.. all three are so talented, and hopefully the janta will also make good decisions in the future.. thanks Barnalidi for the article!
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
Anuradha Ravi @Anuradha 16 years ago This proves that VS are the best mentors we have ever had!! Now this ends C2007!!
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
Megha @.:Megha:. 16 years ago Nice answers by both VS. I agree with Shekar. I also thought Amanat was the most most talented and should win, but Annek did. It's fine but his voice should become a little more mature.
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
ovaltine @ovaltine 16 years ago Way to go VS. Loved their comments and their frankness. Even though Raja was from their gharana , Shekhar has openly stated his choice. I applaud them.
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
teddysweety @teddysweety 16 years ago awesome article.. i agree with their opinion on amanat (my fav).
i am glad that they are considering their old method of choosing a winner. aneek is really good.. all three were rly good but c2005... i don't think the best singer won... (i thought hemu was the best singer)
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
desigrl27 @desigrl27 16 years ago I agree with both V & S...personaly I am glad Raja didn't win.
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
griffy.fz @griffy.fz 16 years ago i agree they SRGM shud go to old forma t so thatwe get good singers ..like kunal ganjawala and shreya ghoshal!
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
simz @live_life 16 years ago awww their answers were supercool....so theres a chance of them coming bak...........Supasweet...and shekhar is so cute
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
bittersweet93 @bittersweet93 16 years ago Good idea to get this interview. Shekhar, I couldnt agree with you more. Amanat to me was the most desrving as well...great to hear he feels the same way. And I also highly agree with Vishal- tellig us to vote online and then finding out that the votes didnt even count, IS cheating and a big waste of time. It's so frustrating to know that all of all the votes i gave, not one counted. That was just cheap.
Reply thumbs-up thumbs-down
see more
up-open TOP