Ishita =/= (doesn't equal to) Shagun - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.6k

Users

11

Likes

67

Frequent Posters

-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: mischief


What Raman has is a REASON 😆
He has REASON to let every family member of Iyer family to go through horrible grievance of seven years+ by not letting them get close to their deceased daughter's child
He has REASON to abandon Ishita when Ruhi was declared dead.
He has REASON to choose Shagun as the surrogate mother of his & Ishita's kid
He has REASON to marry Shagun for Pihu (assuming they are married)
.
.
.
And the REASON never ends...😆

Therefore going by your own reasons, it gives many more REASONS why ISHITA = RAMAN 😃


Lol. This thread is for showing the similarity between Ishita and Shagun. But you had to import Raman to defend Ishita. Next is what justifying IshAni because of ShaRam or that they are already doing...IshAni confession happened because ShaRam. 😆 I can still answer how Raman and bhagoda Ishita are different but it will create a war here.
mar_21 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: -MS-


Lol. This thread is for showing the similarity between Ishita and Shagun. But you had to import Raman to defend Ishita. Next is what justifying IshAni because of ShaRam or that they are already doing...IshAni confession happened because ShaRam. 😆 I can still answer how Raman and bhagoda Ishita are different but it will create a war here.


Tumare Reasons tumare pass aur mere Reasons mere pass...Life is too small don't waste them on FanWars 😃

Well, Shagun's reasons are such that I can't post them here due to IF RULES (they are censored) 😉

But nothing stops me from proving that RAMAN = ISHITA and ISHITA = RAMAN
mar_21 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: -MS-


Lol. This thread is for showing the similarity between Ishita and Shagun. But you had to import Raman to defend Ishita. Next is what justifying IshAni because of ShaRam or that they are already doing...IshAni confession happened because ShaRam. 😆 I can still answer how Raman and bhagoda Ishita are different but it will create a war here.


Hey I'm back after reading Ramona's post confirming that Ishita has rejected Mani's proposal... Her REASONS are yet to be know though 😉


sririt thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
It is not possible to compare these two. They are poles apart. Leaving and living with other man doesn't bring them at the same base. There is no relationship b/w Ishita and Mani except being friends and sense of responsibility and gratitude for saving her and giving new life.
Shagun wanted more from her life, while Ishita wanted nothing from her life; infact she wanted to leave her life. Raman asked her to leave in anger, she left the place and thought of ending up her life. To much surprise Mani came out of nowhere and saved her losing his legs.

To be true, if someone will ask me to leave and never come, I would also never return back to see if he really hate or was that just out of anger. Some things subside into your heart for ever. And even if Ishita wanted to come after she was saved, was it good to leave Mani who became handicapped in order to save her. That time Mani niece/nephew weren't too old to take care of themselves as well as Mani. Ishita felt it right helping her friend who almost became handicapped in saving her. There might be myriad of emotions running in Ishita's heart and mind. She herself wasn't sure; if she would be welcomed warmly by Bhallas specially Raman.

Apart from this, Shagun after leaving Raman also; never let Raman live in peace. She with Ashok planned lot against Raman and Ashok always showed off his possession to Shagun time and again in parties. I would have really accepted Shagun betrayal little easily if she would have never poked into Raman's life later. But she had a motive of ruining him time and again using Adi/Ruhi etc.

One more thing if Ishita now accepts the proposal of Mani, it's not that she is betraying her marriage. It's already 7 years and the marriage is null and void (according to Law). So, we shouldn't question even that now.

I can never agree Ishita=Shagun

Ishita was forced to leave while Shagun choose to Leave.

P.S. Sorry to hurt, but this is what I feel.
curepipe thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: RS472

Yap, u heard it right. With our jagat mata accepting her best friends love proposal, there r now no diffrences between ishita n shagun. Ishita did everything that shagun did from leaving her new born to staying with another man. Ofcourse, she is SP's super bahu, so she has her own emotional excuses, which can b accounted. But now, as she accepted Mani's proposal, while still being married(she herself considered Raman her 'pati') there is officially no diffrence between her n shagun. Both loved another man while they were married. While raman doesn't even knw ishita is alive, she is having redezvous in Australia! Well done CVs, i salute. U guys turend a perfectly fine show into a typical betreyal n adultory juncyard.

I don't agree with that statement Ishita can never be compared to Shagun i don't have to go into details .if u have watched the show from the beginning you can see the differences between the two clearly.Ishita is a very good mother .If she left her baby it was not like Shagun for lust.She did so as she thought she was MANHOOS and didnt want to bring badluck to family.As for living with Mani :they live in same house but not in same bed as Shagun and Ashok.so no comparison between the two.Ishra is the soul of YHM and that cannot be changed am sure.
gaushiv13 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
Please don't compare ishita and shagun
It's not good to leave ur child for 7 years but keep itself at ishita place she was called manhoos banch and what not so she not came so that she not become unlucky for them again and the person whose life again turne unlucky due to her she wanted to remove some pain
What Raman has said to ishita has no offence of calling her banch
And what u want ishita to live abla nari life for her children with loosing her self respect where after being so caring her motherhood was always questioned andBANCH such a cheap and what u can say is for a woman who is always loving toward her children
I can say u all typical Indian female or people thinking where a woman have to tolerate everything just for her children on the cost of her self respect
And let me tell u ishita loved everyone unconditionally but here shagun is nice to pihu because she is is and will be the reason to climb ladders as always she has used children for her benefit
She knows that shecant use Adi as he love ishimas and now only pihu is a tool
No mother if a child would do wrong will not make her understand yesterday u can see how she said pihu Papa does what she say so she should ask him
U can see aliya ishita bond she shouted at her when she lied to her and reasoned her and was worried only had chiz mein hami bhar dene SE koi accha mahi hi jata
The person who loves u will never take a second to hate u if it is for ur benefit
Ishita has spent qualitative time that after her death also everyone misses her even Adi who has spent some month with her

3fra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17
let ishita back to ballahs house and naagin auntyjii chapter close than apshagung shagun ture colour will come out than we have another talk till than guys keep flying high
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: mischief


Tumare Reasons tumare pass aur mere Reasons mere pass...Life is too small don't waste them on FanWars 😃

Well, Shagun's reasons are such that I can't post them here due to IF RULES (they are censored) 😉

But nothing stops me from proving that RAMAN = ISHITA and ISHITA = RAMAN


Of course you have REASONS. You have REASONS to copy and twist my words cuz life is too short to bring own inputs 😃
I didn't say "Fan" wars re. Whose fan is whom is no secret but in most cases people tend to hide the real intention and conveniently put blame on others. So, it's just a war they prefer to engage in being in a safe zone. 😳

Well, Shagun's reasons are of course censored but not all. Like here you blame Shagun entering into Raman's room for telcon but conveniently forget Ishita has been living with Mani under the same roof. They feel disgusted seeing Shagun in Raman's room but conveniently forget Ishita is doing the same thing with Mani if not more. Ishita poses with Mani like a married couple and later hangs those pics on the wall of THEIR house but it doesn't induce any disgusted feeling. Because Ishita must have a REASON for that. 😆
Yeah Ishita=Raman and Raman=Ishita for you but Ishita is always right no matter what. 😃
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: mischief


Hey I'm back after reading Ramona's post confirming that Ishita has rejected Mani's proposal... Her REASONS are yet to be know though 😉



There are couple walo photos of IshAni on the wall of THEIR house...her REASONS for that are yet to be known. 😉 Not actually... 😆
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: sririt




One more thing if Ishita now accepts the proposal of Mani, it's not that she is betraying her marriage. It's already 7 years and the marriage is null and void (according to Law). So, we shouldn't question even that now.


Ishita was forced to leave while Shagun choose to Leave.



@Blue: Well, I agree. IshRa marriage is void. But people tend to forget that and start bashing Shagun & Raman, and question Raman's love for Ishita. More than their marriage being void, they overlook the fact that they all know Ishita is dead. On the other hand, Ishita still considers Raman as her husband and very well know he is alive. So her moving on raises question on the love she had for Raman. And the moving on isn't just limited to accepting or rejecting Mani's proposal.

@Red: Ishita too made a choice. It was only her decision to leave her parents. It was only her decision to leave her kids. The guilt, hurt or whatever the reason is just overplayed. A woman who is in THAT kinda guilt doesn't lead a normal life with another man raising his children. That simply doesn't match.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".