Why couldn’t Kajol do a film like Black in her overrated career?! - Page 2

Originally posted by: Clochette

Actually, when watching a movie I don't care who else had been in the filmmaker's mind for a certain role...why? because it simply did not happen and in front of my eyes is the movie he made with exactly the actors/actresses I see on screen.

Nevertheless, just as an information, I like to read posts like mugda's (hoping that they are in the knowing and not in the fantasizing ).

sorry if I offended you. The other member I am asking not to post in my topic has accused me of things which are not acceptable to me. So yes I have asked them to stop posting. Anyway, you are welcome to post and if not it’s okay.

Originally posted by: MrChatVsNorway

Rani was the first and only choice for Black and I will put the video interview link where SLB has himself confirmed that had it not been Rani , he would not have made black . Ash fans should go to jail for concocting imaginary stories to snatch credit from Rani . Arey kuch to sharm Kar . Kareena was cast for Bajirao Mastani which Snooty Ash wanted to do without Salman but SLB did not fulfill her wish . SLB was not insane to cast Kareena in the role of Michelle . Back then Kareena was doing films like Khushi and MPKDH. Also SLB did not even consider Ash or Kajol for this challenging role as even he knows that these are candyfloss actresses , one known for being Ms world and the other for her famous pairing with SRK

Rani is an opportunist. She always snatched other roles. Its a fact.

When Amitabh Bachchan Refused To Work With Kareena Kapoor Khan In Black & Bhansali Dropped Her In A Jiffy – Story Behind His Revenge!

https://www.koimoi.com/bollywood-news/when-amitabh-bachchan-refused-to-work-with-kareena-kapoor-khan-in-black-bhansali-dropped-her-in-a-jiffy-story-behind-his-revenge/

Originally posted by: MrChatVsNorway

I hope you are not believing what the Ash fans are writing . Use your own judgement and also use google .

If it is an information that matters to me, I would do so.

Those about who got or didn't get offered a role first/second/third or not at all do not fit into that category.

Originally posted by: fazgostoso

sorry if I offended you. The other member I am asking not to post in my topic has accused me of things which are not acceptable to me. So yes I have asked them to stop posting. Anyway, you are welcome to post and if not it’s okay.

You didn't offend me, dear. Actually, it isn't that easy to do so.

I just was thinking practical...if one doesn't want to interact with someone on the forum, just don't read him/her and/or ban him/her.

Rani is the best actress of her generation who does minimum publicity. A comparison with unidimensional Kajol is actually belittling her talent. Bollywood is actually not the right industry for a talent like Rani.I wish she did Namesake which was offered to her and made entry into Hollywood. An unique talent like her would have got great opportunities in the west.Her exotic Indian looks would have actually helped her.

Originally posted by: Mugda

Rani is an opportunist. She always snatched other roles. Its a fact.

When Amitabh Bachchan Refused To Work With Kareena Kapoor Khan In Black & Bhansali Dropped Her In A Jiffy – Story Behind His Revenge!

https://www.koimoi.com/bollywood-news/when-amitabh-bachchan-refused-to-work-with-kareena-kapoor-khan-in-black-bhansali-dropped-her-in-a-jiffy-story-behind-his-revenge/

Yes, we are supposed to believe this phoney article made out of Bollywood Reddit thread I think you Ash fans are on the lookout for these , aren’t you ?

Here in this video , SLB clearly mentions that Big B and Rani were the only choice and he would not have the film without them https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M6TXFgcTmpo&pp=ygUfQmhhdmFuYSBzb21heWEgIGJsYWNrIGludGVydmlldw%3D%3D

Originally posted by: Mugda

When Bhansali couldn't cast Salman & Aishwarya together in Bajirao Mastani he then announced a small budget film Black with Amitabh Bachchan & Kareena Kapoor.

Bhansali signed Kareena for 2 films. Black & Bajirao Mastani.

In Bajirao Mastani Kareena was 2nd choice after Aishwarya rejected the role but in the meantime he started Black with Amitabh & Kareena.

When Black was announced in 2004 Abhishek broke his engagement with Karishma.

Due to tension between Amitabh & Kapoor family Kareena was dropped from film Black.

Rani Mukherji is the only actress who grabs all other heroines films.

She grabbed Chalte Chalte from Aishwarya Rai & numerous other films.

She also grabbed Kareena's role in Black as well.

Kajol was offered Khamoshi & HDDCS. She rejected both films.

Ok, so Ashwarya snatched HDDCS from Kajol

Originally posted by: Mugda

When Bhansali couldn't cast Salman & Aishwarya together in Bajirao Mastani he then announced a small budget film Black with Amitabh Bachchan & Kareena Kapoor.

Bhansali signed Kareena for 2 films. Black & Bajirao Mastani.

In Bajirao Mastani Kareena was 2nd choice after Aishwarya rejected the role but in the meantime he started Black with Amitabh & Kareena.

When Black was announced in 2004 Abhishek broke his engagement with Karishma.

Due to tension between Amitabh & Kapoor family Kareena was dropped from film Black.

Rani Mukherji is the only actress who grabs all other heroines films.

She grabbed Chalte Chalte from Aishwarya Rai & numerous other films.

She also grabbed Kareena's role in Black as well.

Kajol was offered Khamoshi & HDDCS. She rejected both films.

So, According to you, no one should accept any offers if the intended cast, for some reason, is unable to take up the role? That's not how the world works; no project ends up being completely the same as it was on paper during the initial stages.

A role belongs to the director, writer, and finally, the person who portrayed it in the end. Everyone before that is just a muse, not the owner.

Rani did no wrong accepting what was offered.

Topic is about kajol but Rani and Aish fans are arguing here lol

Kajol is over rated